IT Keeps Buying What The Market Keeps Selling

The market is punishing this company’s stock, but its biggest and most aggressive buyer believes the price is deeply wrong.

Gartner (IT) sells research and advice to the world’s top executives. When a Chief Information Officer needs to build an AI strategy or a the Chief Financial has to navigate a complex new regulation, they often turn to Gartner for guidance. Yet despite this entrenched role, the company’s stock has fallen 66% over the past year, trading near its 52-week low of $125.73. On the other side of that trade is a buyer with unmatched conviction: Gartner itself. This has created a stark standoff. Who is right about this business: the market or the company’s own management?

How much conviction does management have?

Over the past three years, the company has repurchased $3.8 billion of its own stock. That amounts to an astonishing 40% of its entire current market capitalization. The pace is not slowing. In the most recent quarter alone, Gartner bought back $535 million of stock, shrinking its total share count by more than 4%. This is an aggressive bet that each remaining share is worth substantially more than its current price.

This capital return is funded by a healthy business, not by taking on excessive risk. The company’s net debt to equity is a modest 0.17, and its operating cash flow is a strong 185% of its net income. The buyback is a deliberate strategic choice to concentrate future earnings into the hands of fewer owners.

Why is the market selling what management is buying?

The market’s skepticism is rooted in a single, critical slowdown. Gartner’s forward-looking growth engine is its contract value, or CV, which represents the value of its subscription contracts. After years of solid growth, total CV grew just 1% year-over-year in the last quarter. Management noted that after a strong start to the quarter, “client decisions slowed somewhat in March” due to the geopolitical environment.

The market fears this is more than a temporary blip. It could signal a new reality where corporations, facing their own uncertainties, are delaying spending on advisory services. This concern is echoed in the company’s consulting segment, where revenue fell to $119 million from $140 million in the year-ago period. While the overall business is not shrinking, trailing twelve-month revenue is up 2.3%, this deceleration is what worries investors. The debates that matter for a consulting peer like Accenture often revolve around similar questions of client spending cycles.

The number that breaks the standoff is Contract Value growth.

The confrontation comes down to this: management is using its significant free cash flow to repurchase shares, betting that its initiatives to drive client engagement will reignite growth. The market is pricing the stock as if the recent slowdown is the new normal. The standoff will be resolved by the trajectory of Contract Value.

Management has been clear, stating they “expect contract value will accelerate.” The last reported figure was 1% growth, or 3.5% when excluding the challenged U.S. federal government business. A meaningful re-acceleration would prove management’s strategy is working. Continued stagnation would validate the market’s fears, suggesting the billions spent on buybacks came at the expense of a business that needed to conserve its cash.

If buying weakness in sound businesses is your style, our Buy the Dip screen ranks the dips where quality metrics say the business still works.

Prefer the theme to this single name? our ETF Scorecard shows how the technology funds stack up. That way no single company’s next surprise decides the outcome.

Management Is Betting Its Cash. Do Not Bet Your Future

The company buying its own dip is making a calculated bet with corporate cash. If that same stock is an outsized share of your wealth, you are making the identical bet with your retirement – and cutting it back triggers a tax bill. There is a way to protect the position and diversify out tax-efficiently.