$100K In Anthropic Stock: Buy Now Or Wait?

SPYYTD+7.9%QQQYTD+7.7%
Analyze ANT →

Today’s big story: Could Anthropic Stock Fall 25%?

Anthropic starts trading today, Thursday, Nov 19. Say you have already decided that $100,000 of its stock is the right amount for you. The question left is when to buy.

You could buy today. You could wait ten days for the excitement to fade. Or you could wait 100 days, until large blocks of insider shares are freed for sale. We looked at that wait in Anthropic IPO: Buy Day One Or Wait?

We tested each choice on 31 big US listings since 2008. They run from Visa and Facebook to Uber, Arm, Reddit and SpaceX. In our test, a day-one buy is at the first day’s closing price, not the opening price.

The first finding is simple. Which stock you buy matters more than the day you buy it.

Image from Pixabay

Does Waiting Pay?

About half the time. Ten days after listing, 17 of 31 stocks were below their first-day close.

So more than half of day-one buyers were sitting on a loss ten days later. A loss that early is easier to sit through when the rest of your savings drops less. When the market has fallen, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio has lost about 81 cents for every $1 its benchmark lost, on average. See the HQ record.

After 100 days, 15 of 31 were below their first-day close. After a year, 16 of 30 were. On day 100, the typical stock was exactly where it closed on day one. So waiting is a coin flip.

The table shows what $100,000 was worth two years after listing, by the day you bought. It covers the 27 listings with two years of trading.

Bought on Typical, 2 years on Worst Beat day 1
Day 1 close $105K $17K –
Day 10 $104K $15K 15 of 27
Day 100 $109K $25K 13 of 27
Day 250 $116K $27K 15 of 27
4 steps $121K $28K 14 of 27

Each row buys $100,000 at the close of the day shown and values it 500 trading days after listing. “4 steps” means $25,000 on each of days 1, 30, 100 and 250. Typical is the median, the middle of the 27 results. Daily closes, adjusted for dividends. Source: Trefis, prices through Nov 18.

The gap between companies is far wider. The same $100,000 on day one became $17,000 in Rivian. It became $712,000 in Cloudflare. The day you bought moved the typical result by about $17,000. The company you bought moved it by $700,000. That is why the size of the bet comes before its timing.

So Is Timing Useless?

No. The market usually offers a second chance. Within their first year, 21 of 31 listings closed at least 25% below their first-day close at some point. The typical low was 35% below.

The problem is when. The low came anywhere from day 6 to day 250. You can’t guess the day. But you can wait for a price you choose today.

So we tested a simple rule. Buy half on day one, at the first-day close. Put in a limit order for the other half at 15% below that close. A limit order buys only if the price falls to the level you set. If it never fills within a year, buy the second half on day 250.

Plan Typical, 2 years on Beat day 1
All on day 1 $105K –
Half now, half 15% lower $96K 22 of 27
Half now, half 25% lower $96K 19 of 27

A limit counts as filled if any close within 250 trading days reached it. It then buys at the limit price. Otherwise the second half is bought on day 250. The 15% limit filled in 22 of 27 cases, the 25% limit in 18 of 27. Values are 500 trading days after listing. Source: Trefis, prices through Nov 18.

The 15% rule beat buying everything on day one in 22 of 27 cases. It typically won by about $7,000. Its typical value in the table looks lower for one reason. Hilton, the middle listing, never fell 15%.

The rule lagged when the limit never filled. The biggest gap was in Zoom, where it trailed by $157,000. The deeper 25% rule paid more when it filled, but it filled less often.

Neither rule fixed the worst case. Half-and-half in Rivian still left about $19,000 of the $100,000. Only the size of the bet can limit that.

What Is The Plan For Anthropic?

Our read is to buy half today and pick a price for the rest now.

For $100,000, buy $50,000 at or near today’s close. Then put in a limit order for the other $50,000, 15% below that close. Make it good for a year. If it has not filled by about November 2027, buy the rest then.

By then, the last scheduled insider lock-ups end. A lock-up is a set period when insiders may not sell their shares. Anthropic’s first annual report will also be out.

Before the second half fills, check one number in each report. That number is cash. Anthropic’s business brought in $6.6 billion of cash in the first nine months of this year. If that number grows, buying the second half is easy. If it shrinks, you will be glad you waited.

Today’s big story compares the IPO price with past giant listings. What the upside would take is in Anthropic Stock To $500 In 5 Years? Past IPOs do not predict how Anthropic will trade.

So size the bet first. Then buy half, and wait for your price on the rest.

With this plan, the second $50,000 may wait up to a year for its price. That money does not have to earn nothing while it waits.

Waiting To Buy Anthropic? Why Let Your Cash Sit Idle?

The right price can take months. Meanwhile, the Trefis Income Solution pays a dividend yield about 3x the S&P 500’s, from 50 stocks with at least 10 straight years of dividends. Why not choose a better approach?

See If It Fits Your Plan

For education, not a recommendation to buy or sell.

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.