What’s Next After MP Stock’s 5X Surge?

MP Materials (NYSE:MP), America’s leading producer of rare-earth elements, has become one of the standout stories of 2025. Shares now trade near $70, having grown almost 5x year-to-date, as investors pile into the U.S. rare-earth revival story. The surge reflects optimism that MP’s long-term vision—building a fully domestic supply chain for critical EV and defense metals—is finally coming to fruition. But with the stock already up nearly five-fold, the question is clear: could MP double again, reaching $150 or more per share? Let’s break down the thesis. The recent selloff has left investors wondering: is this just a sharp correction in an overheated stock, or the start of a deeper reckoning for one of the fastest-growing players in mobile advertising? Separately see, Can Lithium Americas Stock Double Again?

If you seek an upside with less volatility than holding an individual stock, consider the High Quality Portfolio. It has comfortably outperformed its benchmark—a combination of the S&P 500, Russell, and S&P MidCap indexes—and has achieved returns exceeding 105% since its inception.  

Photo by ELG21 on Pixabay

Core Thesis: The Path to $150–160

Revenue Acceleration & Valuation Reset

MP Materials generated about $204 million in revenue in 2024, weighed down by softer rare-earth prices and startup costs tied to its magnet facility. But 2025 marks a clear turning point: production from its Mountain Pass separation facility and new Fort Worth magnet plant is ramping up, setting the stage for a shift from low-margin mining to higher-margin manufacturing.

Analysts expect revenue to accelerate meaningfully over the next two years as downstream volumes scale, with EBITDA potentially rising toward $500–700 million by 2027. The real story here isn’t about top-line growth — it’s about margin expansion and operating leverage as MP transitions from raw materials to finished products.

At present, however, MP trades at a lofty 52× EV/EBITDA, implying the market is already discounting years of growth and flawless execution. If MP delivers on its 2027 profitability targets, and the multiple falls to say 40x, a level more consistent with other high-tech materials or defense-linked manufacturers. That kind of earnings growth would support an enterprise value above $25 billion — roughly double current levels — translating into a share price in the $140–150 range. In other words, MP doesn’t need higher multiples to rise; it simply needs to grow into its current one.

Key Growth Drivers

• Vertical Integration from Mine to Magnet – MP is one of the few companies outside China with end-to-end capabilities—from mining and separating rare-earth oxides to producing finished magnets used in EV motors, wind turbines, and defense systems. This integration dramatically expands its profit potential beyond raw ore sales.
• Strategic Demand from EV and Defense Sectors – Electric vehicles and renewable energy technologies are heavily dependent on neodymium and praseodymium (NdPr) magnets. With U.S. automakers and defense contractors seeking domestic sources, MP sits at the center of a national supply chain priority.
• Government and Policy Tailwinds – The U.S. government has designated rare earths as a critical resource, providing funding, tax incentives, and procurement support. The Department of Defense has already backed MP with contracts to accelerate magnet production.
• Improving Margins Through Scale – As production ramps and processing capacity expands, MP’s gross margins—currently near the mid-20s—could improve substantially. The shift from mining to manufacturing is key to achieving higher EBITDA leverage.
• Strategic Partnerships and Offtake Agreements – MP has established supply relationships with General Motors and other major OEMs, providing predictable off-take volumes and revenue visibility as the Texas magnet facility comes online.

Risks That Remain

• Execution Risk: Scaling complex separation and magnet production processes poses technical and operational challenges that could delay profitability.
• Capital Intensity: Building and maintaining processing facilities requires heavy upfront investment; additional capital raises could dilute shareholders.
• Commodity Price Volatility: While rare-earth demand is strong, pricing for NdPr and other metals remains cyclical and sensitive to China’s export policies.
• Competition & Geopolitical Pressure: China dominates the rare-earth market and could respond to U.S. expansion efforts with price undercutting or export restrictions.
• Valuation Stretch: After a 335% rally, expectations are high. Any production hiccup or cost overrun could trigger sharp corrections.

The Verdict

At near $70 per share, MP Materials has already priced in a major turnaround — but not necessarily the full downstream earnings potential. If EBITDA expands as expected and the company hits its production milestones, MP could grow into its current valuation and beyond, making a $140–150 share price a realistic medium-term target.

That said, this is no longer a deep-value story — it’s a high-expectation execution story. MP must now prove that its transformation from miner to magnet-maker can generate consistent profits. If it does, the reward could be significant.

 To reduce stock-specific risk while getting exposure to upside, consider taking a look at the High Quality portfolio, which has comfortably outperformed its benchmark—a combination of the S&P 500, Russell, and S&P MidCap indexes—and has achieved returns exceeding 105% since its inception.  Why is that? As a group, HQ Portfolio stocks provided better returns with less risk versus the benchmark index; less of a roller-coaster ride as evident in HQ Portfolio performance metrics.

Invest with Trefis Market-Beating Portfolios

See all Trefis Price Estimates