Carvana Grows Faster. Is The Stock Really Cheap?

CVNAYTD-15.8%SPYYTD+8.2%XLYYTD-1.3%
Analyze CVNA →

Today’s big story: Anthropic IPO: Priced For 2031, Or 2036?

Carvana sells used cars online, and it lends many of its buyers the money to pay for them. Last quarter it sold 217,385 cars, 39% more than a year earlier. Its sales over the last 12 months reached $27.5 billion, up 50%.

Analysts expect sales to grow another 27% next year. That would be faster than every Consumer Discretionary company worth more than $50 billion except MercadoLibre. Yet 14 of those 21 companies cost more than Carvana per dollar of sales, from Amazon to McDonald’s. Carvana’s market value is 2.9 times its sales. Three things explain that low price: the yardstick, the stock’s fall in 2022, and car loans.

Image from Pixabay

Is Carvana Really Cheap?

Only per dollar of sales. Selling a car brings in a lot of money but leaves a thin profit. Over the last 12 months, Carvana kept 19 cents per dollar of sales after the cost of the cars. It kept 8.7 cents of operating profit, what is left after all running costs. McDonald’s kept 46.1 cents of operating profit per dollar.

On operating profit, Carvana’s market value is 32.7 times, more than investors pay for Home Depot or McDonald’s. Carvana has two classes of shares, and its market value here counts both.

Company Price ÷ sales Price ÷ operating profit Operating margin
Carvana 2.9x 32.7x 8.7%
Home Depot 2.0x 16.0x 12.4%
McDonald’s 7.0x 15.2x 46.1%
Amazon 3.5x 26.7x 13.1%
CarMax 0.3x loss −1.4%

Source: Trefis company data, prices through Nov 17. Market value divided by the last 12 months of sales or operating profit.

Of the 21 peers, 18 cost less than Carvana per dollar of operating profit. Only Tesla, DoorDash and Airbnb cost more. Priced on net profit, Carvana’s 33 times is also above most of them. CarMax costs 0.3 times sales but made an operating loss. So Carvana’s low price per dollar of sales comes from the yardstick. It is not a bargain. For the forecast view, see Is Carvana Stock Really Expensive?

On profit, Carvana is not cheap. Buyers who want a lower price may have to wait. Meanwhile, the Trefis Income Solution pays a dividend yield about 3x the S&P 500’s. It holds 50 stocks with at least 10 straight years of dividends. See if it fits.

Why Won’t Investors Pay Up For The Growth?

Because they watched the stock fall 99%. In 2022, sales growth stalled. Gross margin, the share of sales left after the cost of the cars, fell to 9.2% from 15.1%. Carvana lost $1.5 billion on its operations, and its debt climbed to $8.8 billion.

Year Sales Operating profit Debt, year end
2021 $12.8B −$0.1B $5.8B
2022 $13.6B −$1.5B $8.8B
2023 $10.8B −$0.1B $6.7B
2025 $20.3B $1.9B $5.5B
12 months to Sep 2026 $27.5B $2.4B $5.6B

Source: Trefis company data (Morningstar statements). Calendar years. The last row is the 12 months to September, with debt at Sep 30.

The stock fell 99.0% from August 2021 to December 2022. By the end of 2022, shareholders’ equity was below zero. That means the company owed more than it owned. The stock then took 31 months from its bottom to get back to its old high. For how far it can fall in a normal year, see Can Carvana Stock Fall 40%?

Debt is lower now. It is $5.6 billion, against $3.0 billion of cash. But in our view, buyers who remember 2022 still want a discount.

How Do Car Loans Affect Carvana?

Carvana lends to many of its buyers. It then sells those loans to investors. So its profit per car depends on interest rates.

Rates are higher than a year ago. The 10-year Treasury yield, the interest rate on 10-year US government bonds, is 5.10%. A year ago it was 4.13%. A 60-month car loan at banks costs 7.54%, against 4.67% in late 2021. Carvana itself put the hit from fuel and rates at about $200 per car last quarter.

The stock reacts to rates. In the past year, there were 9 days when the 10-year yield jumped 0.08 percentage point or more. Carvana fell on 8 of them. Its median fall was 3.7%, more than five times the S&P 500’s 0.7%.

How Much Can The Stock Move?

The stock closed Tuesday at $71.10, 26% below its January high. We looked at the 653 stretches of 70 trading days since January 2024. In 549 of them, Carvana was at some point 20% or more above or below where it started. The S&P 500 did that in 9. So a 20% move either way by early March should not surprise.

Two things could change the picture. One is the 10-year yield falling back toward last year’s 4.1%. That would help Carvana’s loan business. The other is another year of 8.7% operating margins with debt held flat. That would help investors move past 2022.

So, Is Carvana Stock Cheap?

Only per dollar of sales. Carvana is a fast-growing car store, but investors price it more like a lender. In one way it still is one. And its stock once fell 99%.

When one stock is this hard to price, owning a group of quality companies can make more sense.

Why Own One Leader When You Can Own 30?

If you like finding quality companies like Home Depot and McDonald’s, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio holds 30 of them in equal weight, and has returned more than 105% since its September 2020 launch. You’re welcome to look inside.

See The HQ Portfolio

For education, not a recommendation to buy or sell.

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.