American Express (NYSE:AXP) has stuck to its strategy of targeting high-income customers for years in its bid to differentiate itself from competitors who largely seek volumes in issuing their Visa (NYSE:V) and MasterCard (NYSE:MA) branded cards. However JPMorgan Chase (NYSE:JPM) aims to give the card company a run for its money by targeting the affluent. The company was recently highlighted in a presentation by AmEx’s Vice Chairman Ed Gilligan at a recent conference. 
We are in the process of updating our price estimate of $51 for AmEx, which is about 12% below the current market price.
- American Express Q3 Earnings: Investments Hit Profits, Cardmember Growth Solid
- American Express Strikes Deal With Sam’s Club; But Won’t Be Enough To Offset Costco Loss
- Q2 2015 Banking Review: Credit Card Payment Volumes
- Q2 2015 Banking Review: Credit Card Charge-Off Rates
- Q2 2015 U.S. Banking Review: Outstanding Card Balances
- American Express’ Q2 Earnings Hold Still Despite Currency Headwinds. Spending On Growth Initiatives To Increase
American Express owes well over 90% of its value to its credit card business with its travel services business making up the rest of its value. The importance of ensuring the long-term sustainability of its card business, therefore, cannot be overstated.
On the other hand, our analysis of JPMorgan shows that the gargantuan banking institution also owes a substantial part of its value (nearly a quarter based on our estimates) to its card business. Incidentally, JPMorgan’s card business is its most valuable business – easily ahead of its retail banking and investment banking businesses. So the bank’s push in growing this business hardly comes as a surprise.
AmEx’s strategy of focusing on the high-income group has clear, distinct advantages – the most notable being the ability to charge merchants more for the ‘distinguished’ customers being brought in. Additionally, the services also come with a high membership fee which AmEx graciously pockets. A clear comparison between transaction fees charged per swipe by AmEx and JPMorgan Chase can be made by looking at the charts above (AmEx) and below (JPM).
AmEx’s fears about JPMorgan’s push on its home turf is understandable, given the significant strength the latter’s employee numbers brings to the stand-off. Moreover, JPMorgan’s extensive network across the country also makes it a formidable opponent.Notes:
- American Express Says JPMorgan Is Credit Card Copycat, The Street, Mar 20 2012 [↩]