Jensen Huang, Elon Musk Or Dario Amodei: Who Is The Better Leader For Investors?

NVDAYTD-16.1%SPYYTD+9.4%QQQYTD+8.1%
Analyze NVDA →

Today’s big story: Could Nvidia Stock Fall 50%? Follow The Cash

Coffee, and a week of headlines about three men. One co-founded Nvidia and resigned as its CEO last week. One runs Tesla and is rarely out of the news. One is about to take Anthropic public, as soon as Thursday. Your index fund already owns two of their companies; this week you may be offered the third.

Nvidia announced on Nov 12 that Jensen Huang had resigned as its president, CEO and director, effective immediately; finance chief Colette Kress is interim CEO while the board looks for a successor (Nvidia 8-K filed with the SEC). Nvidia gave no reason. Four days earlier, on Nov 8, the board had opened an independent investigation into reports he was the target of a foreign intelligence effort, at a company whose chips sit at the center of US export policy. Since the Nov 6 close, Nvidia is down 16.3%, while Tesla is up 6.0%. Monday alone took 4.1% off Nvidia as tech led a broad market fall.

That 16.3% came in six trading days, and Nvidia, Tesla, Amazon and Alphabet sit in the same funds.

When the news is about one person, the damage lands on one stock. It hurts less when the rest of your portfolio falls less than the market. For every dollar its benchmark lost, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio lost about 81 cents on average, spread across 30 quality stocks in equal weight. See how HQ held up.

Image from Pixabay

What Did Each Leader Build For Investors?

Judge them by what an investor could own. Over the 10 years to Monday, Nvidia returned 6,846%, nearly all of it under Huang, and Tesla 2,997% under Musk, against 298% for the S&P 500 fund. There is no Anthropic stock record yet: the company has not listed; CNBC reported it plans to price on Wednesday and start trading Thursday. Investors who wanted a piece of Amodei’s work held two of its backers, Amazon and Google.

Leader Stock you can own 10 years
Huang (left) Nvidia +6,846%
Musk Tesla +2,997%
Amodei none yet; backers Amazon, Alphabet +591%, +634%
S&P 500 index fund +298%

Nov 16, 2016 to Nov 16, 2026, with dividends. Source: Trefis, prices through Nov 16. The backers’ returns are mostly search, cloud and shopping: a proxy, not Amodei’s record.

Each carries a different key-person risk. Huang’s was scrutiny from Washington; Nvidia gave no reason for his exit. Musk’s is attention, which we measured in Is Musk A Risk To Tesla Stock? Amodei’s is a first public test.

What Happens After A Founder Leaves Or Stumbles?

The record of founder shocks says the first year misleads. A year after Steve Jobs stepped down, Apple was up 76.9%; a year after Musk’s “funding secured” tweet, Tesla was down 31.7%, and five years later up 962%.

Leader shock 1 year 5 years S&P, 5 years
Apple, Jobs, 2011 +76.9% +117% +104%
Tesla, Musk, 2018 −31.7% +962% +70%
Alphabet, Page/Brin, 2019 +41.0% +167% +112%
Oracle, Ellison, 2014 −11.3% +39% +64%
Amazon, Bezos, 2021 −10.5% +24% +95%

From the last close before the news, with dividends; one year = 252 trading days. Source: Trefis, prices through Nov 16. Three of five beat the S&P 500 over five years; Tesla did it after the worst first year of the five.

The business made the winners worth owning. In the five years after each shock, Apple’s sales went from $108.2 billion to $215.6 billion, Tesla’s from $21.5 billion to $96.8 billion, Alphabet’s from $161.9 billion to $350 billion. Oracle’s barely moved ($38.3 billion to $39.5 billion) and the stock trailed. Amazon is the exception: sales rose from $386.1 billion to $716.9 billion and the stock still lagged; the starting price matters too.

What If The Headline Fades?

That is the other real possibility. Nvidia has had 41 days since 2003 when it fell 5% or more while the S&P 500 fund fell less than 0.5%; in 32 of the 40 with three months since, it was back above its pre-shock close within three months. Its product roadmap does not resign with its CEO.

So Who Is The Better Leader?

For investors, the better leader is the one whose company keeps growing after the headlines, and the first year rarely tells you which. What to watch: Nvidia’s first results under Kress, for the third quarter of fiscal 2027, after the close today; the board’s choice of a permanent CEO; and Anthropic’s IPO pricing, expected Wednesday.

Bet on businesses, size the people. The founders built the value; the businesses kept it.

What Should You Ask Next?

How Much Of Your Plan Rides On One Person?

The first year after a leader shock misled; the business decided the next five. Huang led Nvidia through most of a 6,846% decade and still left abruptly. No leader, however good, is a plan.

So rather than staking your money on whichever of these leaders you trust most, it makes more sense to own many quality companies in equal slices, where no single exit decides how you do.

Why Own One Leader When You Can Own 30?

If you like finding quality companies like Nvidia, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio holds 30 of them in equal weight, and has returned more than 105% since its September 2020 launch. You’re welcome to look inside.

See The HQ Portfolio

For education, not a recommendation to buy or sell.

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.