INTU: Priced Like A Decline, Paying Like A Machine

The market has punished this financial software giant as if its core is crumbling, yet the business keeps producing cash at a rate that dwarfs the average company.

Intuit (INTU) makes the software millions of Americans and small businesses rely on, from TurboTax for tax season to QuickBooks for accounting. Yet the market has treated it like a broken operation. The stock trades about 65% below its two-year high, a significant decline for a household name.

At the same time, Intuit’s financial statements tell a story of stability and growth. The business still generates 10.0% of its current market value in free cash flow each year, more than double the 4.1% median for an S&P 500 company. This raises a question for investors: is this business actually broken, or just steeply discounted?

If the business is broken, why is it still growing and so profitable?

The numbers argue against a breakdown. Trailing twelve-month revenue grew 15.1%, showing the top line is still expanding. Profitability remains elite, with an operating margin of 28% that far outpaces the 18.4% S&P 500 median. Its price-to-earnings multiple of 16.8 sits well below the index median of 24.2.

This performance isn’t accidental. Management points to specific strategic growth engines that are performing strongly. Key segments including “Assisted tax, money, portfolio and mid market,” are all “growing north of 30%,” according to the company’s latest earnings call. This suggests the company’s newer, higher-value services are successfully finding a market, generating the cash that seems to contradict the stock chart.

What must the market believe for a 65% markdown to be right?

The market’s deep skepticism is rooted in the company’s core tax business. Management was blunt on its recent call, admitting, “We lost on price” among the “most price sensitive DIY filers.” This isn’t a new issue, which raises a familiar question for investors: is this dip different?

Compounding the problem is a shrinking overall market, with the company noting that “total IRS filers are expected to decline by approximately 30-basis-points this season.” At the same time, Mailchimp, a major acquisition, continues to weigh on results. Its revenue was “down slightly versus a year ago,” prompting the company to begin “rightsizing our investment in Mailchimp.” The fear is that these persistent weaknesses could eventually overwhelm the high-growth segments and cause the company’s impressive cash generation to slow or reverse.

Does the high-growth assisted tax business decide the outcome?

The contrarian case for Intuit rests on whether its new initiatives can outrun the troubles in its legacy DIY segment. The company is betting heavily on its human-assisted tax services, a market it estimates is worth $37 billion and represents “88% of the total TurboTax TAM.” This is the key area where the company’s future will likely be decided. For investors who prefer the theme but not the single-stock risk, a broader software ETF like IGV offers an alternative.

The one number to watch is the growth in this critical segment. Management expects “TurboTax Live customers to grow 38% this year,” with revenue from the service projected to grow 36%. If Intuit can sustain that momentum, proving it can dominate the larger, more lucrative assisted market, the current stock price will look like a historic overreaction. If that growth stalls, the market’s verdict will have been right all along.

For more stocks priced like decliners while the cash keeps arriving, our Buy the Dip screen runs exactly that screen, every day.

Contrarian Bets Belong In Portfolios, Not On Top Of Them

A contrarian entry can pay off handsomely, and turnarounds fail often enough that sizing is the real edge. How much damage any single position could do to your net worth is a question with a precise answer. The Trefis Wealth team computes it for investors professionally, with the same rules-based systematic discipline that runs our High Quality Portfolio. Request a free vulnerability audit of your biggest positions.