How Much Will Best Buy’s Turnaround Efforts Lift Earnings?

by Trefis Team
Best Buy
Rate   |   votes   |   Share

Electronics retailing giant Best Buy (NYSE:BBY) will announce its Q1 results on May 20. We expect the company to report better year-over-year revenues largely due to its price matching policy. However, margins could come in lower due to aggressive pricing, which will weigh on earnings.

Best Buy was in news this quarter for three main reasons: the start of its price matching policy, its new Samsung-branded store within a store concept and the decision to exit Europe by selling its stake in its joint venture with Carphone Warehouse.

CEO Hubert Joly seems to have taken some steps to arrest the slide in Best Buy’s stock, and these efforts are yielding results as evident from the stock performance over the last three months. The earnings results will clarify whether the price movement is sentiment-driven or backed by improved business prospects.

See our full analysis for Best Buy

Exiting Europe

Last month, Best Buy announced its decision to sell its 50% stake in Best Buy Europe, the joint venture with Carphone Warehouse Group (CPW), Europe’s biggest independent mobile phone retailer. Best Buy Europe consists of CPW’s former retail and distribution business with nearly 2,400 small-format The Carphone Warehouse and The Phone House stores, online channels, device insurance operations, and mobile and fixed-line telecommunication services. ((Best Buy to Sell its Stake in European Business to Carphone Warehouse, Best Buy News Release))

The stake will be sold back to Carphone Warehouse for approximately $775 million or 500 million pounds. While 420 million pounds will be paid in cash, the rest will be in the form of Carphone Warehouse stock, subject to a 12-month lock-up restriction. The deal is subject to approval by the shareholders of Carphone Warehouse. It is expected to close by the end of June.

The deal will end Best Buy’s presence in Europe. It signals that Best Buy is more keen to focus on the domestic U.S. market where it is facing formidable challenges from players like Wal-Mart and Amazon. The company needs a strong balance sheet to meet its expansion targets in the U.S. and this deal seems to be a step in that direction.

Best Buy will report the results of the Best Buy Europe joint venture in discontinued operations. In the first quarter, it will take an estimated non-cash asset impairment charge of approximately $200 million, associated with accumulated foreign currency translation losses that will be written off at the time of closing. Best Buy will also pay Carphone Warehouse $45 million to end another venture to partner with mobile phone stores in other countries.

Prior to entering into this agreement, U.S. GAAP revenues for Best Buy Europe in the ongoing fiscal year were expected to be in the range of $5.5 to $5.6 billion. Hence, by virtue of a 50% stake, the impact on Best Buy’s revenues this year will be around $2.8 billion.

We think that the cash from the Carphone Warehouse transaction will be used to further expand Best Buy mobile and make investments in altering the product mix at its outlets. The company has identified certain items such as washing machines which customers prefer to buy from stores rather than online.

Price Matching Commences

Best Buy put in place a permanent “Low Price Guarantee” policy on March 3. Under this policy, the company will price match all local retail competitors and 19 major online competitors in all product categories and on nearly all in-stock products, whenever asked by a customer. This guarantee is available on Best Buy’s website at more than 1,000 Best Buy big box stores, more than 400 Best Buy Mobile standalone stores in the United States, as well as on the telephone. The policy is an attempt by the company to tackle the problem of showrooming, i.e. the phenomenon of potential customers using brick-and-mortar stores to browse through products only to order them online at cheaper prices. ((Best Buy Makes Price Match Permanent to Win Back Clients, Bloomberg))

The earnings results would reveal whether the policy has been successful in achieving the desired outcome.

Samsung Sets Itself Up Within Best Buy Stores

Best Buy and Samsung have entered into a partnership to set up “Samsung Experience” shops staffed with Samsung employees within 1,400 Best Buy stores by June. A number of these in-house stores have already opened and according to Joly, the feedback has been positive so far. While this has given Best Buy access to a successful vendor and will drive customer footfalls to stores, Samsung has gained access to Best Buy’s vast store network to sell its smartphones and tablets by eating into Apple’s market share. Apple already has in-house shops at Best Buy stores. [1]

The in-house stores were set up only towards the end of April so the actual impact will be witnessed only in the subsequent quarters. Best Buy follows a February-January calendar year.

In addition to comments on the price matching policy, the partnership with Samsung, and plans for the cash from selling the European business, we will look out for Best Buy’s comments on the Marketplace Fairness Act making it through the Senate. The bill is designed to bring online retailers under the sales tax purview to give physical retailers a level playing field and will now be discussed by the House of Representatives. [2]

We have a price estimate for of $20 Best Buy.

Understand How a Company’s Products Impact its Stock Price at Trefis

  1. Best Buy CEO ‘Pleased’ With Samsung Shops’ Early Results, CNBC []
  2. The Internet Sales Tax Is Too Late to Help Best Buy’s Stock, The Motley Fool []
Rate   |   votes   |   Share


Name (Required)
Email (Required, but never displayed)
Best Buy Logo
  • commented 6 hours ago
  • Jia Rong coach bags lights at the side pulled oakley sunglasses Xifeng ferragamo quiet christian louboutin skirts, Xifeng longchamp taschen knowing, barbour mens jackets because smiles: pandora jewellery australia "You christian louboutin too worry swarovski online shop about, do air jordan shoes uncle prada outlet employer bias air jordans than we prada handbags will long champ not fear beats audio he is not the michael kors handbags line you adidas shoes who are gucci belts good michael kors at?. woolrich outlet of? the wedding dress kids kate spade bags had red bottom shoes grown rolex replica so burberry big, and michael kors 'did the north face not eat bebe outlet pork, pig run louis vuitton taschen have oakley sunglasses cheap seen toms shoes outlet it.' cheap basketball shoes uncle cheap oakley sent him to the abercrombie original thomas sabo uk but louis vuitton outlet a eyeglasses stores sit ugg boots banner red bottom flag children, are veneta seriously louis vuitton handbags told him michael kors handbags to jordans for sale go cheap nike shoes bargain mac cosmetics would Brokerage! according jordan retro I said nike free 5.0 very mizuno running shoes good, babyliss flat iron "Jia hogan Lian north face backpacks said:." kate spade Nature is bcbg max so true religion not michael kors outlet online my dismissal, burberry online shop indispensable for new balance him figure michael kors uhren it out burberry outlet store "because Q:.". vans schuhe This tiffany canada is a rayban move tiffany and co that at ugg boots the money ray-ban sunglasses "贾蔷 said:"? it mcm bags is converse chucks also ralph lauren proposed polo ralph lauren outlet online here calvin klein outlet Lai polo ralph lauren outlet grandfather nike air max said, michael kors not ralph lauren outlet online from north face canada Beijing zapatillas nike inner gucci shoes tube new balance outlet down the reebok southern Chen rolex watches family adidas zx flux also received ray bans fifty pandora charms thousand of nike mercurial vapor our money. air jordan retro Tomorrow ralph lauren polo we m a c cosmetics wrote a letter nike air huarache will bring new balance votes, sunglasses for women the longchamp outlet first branch thirty michael kors handbags thousand louboutin Xia supra footwear Sheng twenty ugg thousand northface aside, and so repairing Anthurium nike air max . hollister lights cheap shoes and colored curtain michael kors outlet online cage celine outlet veil beats by dre headphones to make money hollister clothing "Jia juicy couture outlet Lian cheap michael kors nodded:" north face outlet Good cheap ray ban idea. uggs "Xifeng Mangxiang airmax Jiaqiang michael kors outlet online sale said: louis vuitton outlet online "That way, nike store uk I hermes outlet have nba jerseys two rows proper insanity workout calendar people, oakley sunglasses you tommy hilfiger take roshe run them levis jeans to ray ban sunglasses follow burberry the above, montblanc the louis vuitton bags cheaper swarovski crystal How coach black friday about you." salvatore ferragamo Jiaqiang ugg boots busy polo ralph Peixiao said: coach outlet online "about north face jackets two giuseppe zanotti people discuss barbour womens jackets it michael kors bags and yoga pants aunt This hermes belt happy michael kors outlet coincidence. oakley "due nike shoes to yoga pants ask the mcm handbags name. ralph lauren Feng chi flat iron Zhao Momo asked. michael kors Zhao hermes birkin bag Momo new balance shoes has spent uhren shop that tiffany und co time listening lululemon outlet to louis vuitton australia the adidas words, burberry outlet online flat ugg australia children swarovski busy laughing to hilfiger online shop push converse shoes him, burberry handbags outlet he dre beats did prada outlet wake coach handbags up, rolex watches and chanel outlet quickly relojes said: "A handbags outlet call abercrombie and fitch Zhaotian coach factory online Liang, nike air max thea a oakley sunglasses cheap man named ugg Zhao uggs outlet Tiandong." coach outlet store online Feng said: salomon schuhe "Do gafas oakley not forget, timberland boots I thomas sabo can gucci outlet do my lululemon go. burberry sale "Then gucci handbags he rayban went vuitton handbags out. burberry outlet store Jia north face Rong cheap jerseys busy to send ralph lauren online shop out, retro jordans and gucci handbags quietly to ralph lauren the ray ban sunglasses outlet Xifeng uggs on sale said: adidas superstar "aunt michael kors purses to coach factory something, told michael kors outlet online me to open tiffany jewelry an michael jordan account new balance Qiang uggs on sale Brothers oakley sunglasses outlet Band nike roshe run to polo ralph lauren go, nike roshe run told true religion outlet him replica watches to press ferragamo shoes accounts asics gel repairing." prada Feng laughed: chanel bags "Do not pandora charms put easton bats your air max 2014 mother's nike roshe run fart! My stuff tiffany did not michael kors bags leave jordan shoes it at, rare ghd you jimmy choo outlet sneaky? nike air max "said abercrombie kids a michael kors uk path nike huarache to easton bats go.Here louis vuitton purses 贾蔷 ugg australia also nike roshe run quiet vans outlet Jia tommy hilfiger canada Lian asked: kate spade handbags "To moncler mens jackets what womens clothing is coach usa the way polo ralph lauren to honor dre headphones organizations?." Jia marc by marc jacobs Lian nike factory laughed:.. harrods london "You do nike running shoes not work with oakley enthusiasm gucci scholarship, designer handbags was timberland outlet the replica watches first ralph lauren outlet I learned this trick short nike free of lululemon australia what, indispensable adidas online shop to ed hardy clothing write nike air max to swarovski crystal tell replica rolex you tommy hilfiger outlet and hollister co do michael kors outlet not nike schoenen 's moncler women jackets here. "said nike soccer shoes Albert, sent cheap nfl jerseys him cheap oakley sunglasses two puma online shop to ipad mini cases go. coach factory outlet online Then who's gucci mens shoes going to, purses and handbags more than three coco chanel or ralph lauren factory store four times, converse sneakers Jia Lian michael kors handbags lack of harm, the north face will pass nike running and red bottom two instyler ionic styler on, the north face outlet one michael kors v?skor should coach purses outlet be allowed to pass chanel messages, both abercrombie and fitch kids tomorrow and other p90x3 dishes. Xifeng true religion jeans outlet side prada shoes down resting tory burch three true religion jeans women more toms outlet hours, ray ban wayfarer night without ugg australia words.Jia Lian up air max thea the next uggs canada morning, toms shoes Jia cheap oakley sunglasses met rayban Jia Zheng, rolex immediately abercrombie went ray ban zonnebril to Ning Fu burberry outlet online in the tory burch sandals past, nike fu?ballschuhe the juicy couture old contract giuseppe zanotti sneakers steward pandora persons, ray ban outlet and bride dresses several longchamp long-time friend sects ralph lauren polo clear christian louboutin uk off Messire, gucci shoes outlet scrutiny swarovski australia of louis vuitton two nike air force local abercrombie and fitch government vans shoes transcript tory burch outlet of painting air max mothering house, one louboutin shoes side longchamp handbags of ugg australia the tory burch handbags police bcbg max azria handle louis vuitton people nike store Ding. swarovski jewelry Since then, hilfiger outlet each row Carpenter tommy hilfiger online Hall gathered, polo outlet store gold, silver, michael kors australia tin roshes and pandora canada civil louis vuitton outlet stores brick hollister online thing, pandora bracelet handling the adidas superstar transfer hollisterco prodigiously.