Own Walmart? Its Cash Lags Its Price

WMTYTD+13.9%SPYYTD+5.8%XLPYTD+17.9%
Analyze WMT →

Today’s big story: Will 2027 Be A 2022 Repeat For Stocks?

Walmart (WMT) did better than expected on Thursday, and its stock still fell. Revenue for the quarter to October grew 4.5% in constant currency. Constant currency means before the effect of exchange rates. That was 0.75 points above the top of the range Walmart gave in August, though that range covered net sales only. Earnings and revenue also came in just above analysts’ expectations. The shares closed down 1.0% at $126.04.

Walmart’s growth story now rests on its online and advertising businesses. Its online sales grew 17% and its advertising business grew 25%. This article asks whether Walmart’s cash backs the price investors pay for that story.

Walmart trades at 46.2 times last year’s earnings per share. That is below Costco Wholesale at 52.7 and above Amazon.com at 35.9. Yet Walmart kept only 2.09 cents of each dollar of sales as free cash flow last year. Its free cash flow per dollar of sales has been below its 10-year median of 2.55 cents in each of the last five years.

shopping cart
Image from Pixabay

Did Walmart fall because of its report or because of the market?

The whole market fell on Thursday. SPY, a fund that tracks the S&P 500, dropped 2.0%. Walmart fell 0.93 points less than SPY, so the market explains more of the day than the report does. Walmart had also fallen on each of its three report days before this one.

Walmart dropped 9.2% on its August report day, and it slipped again this time despite a beat. If Walmart is a big part of your savings, drops like that are hard to sit through, good news or not. When the market has fallen, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio has lost about 81 cents for every $1 its benchmark lost, on average. See the HQ record.

Other retailers had a mixed day. Target rose 0.92%, while Kroger fell 1.6%.

Where did Walmart beat its own plan?

Quarterly revenue was $188.8 billion, up 5.2% as reported. In August, Walmart had guided to net sales growth in a range that topped out at 3.75% in constant currency. The two are close but not identical. The release headline counts total revenue, which includes membership fees. The guidance counted net sales only. Walmart also raised its full-year sales and earnings outlook.

Three parts of the business grew much faster than total revenue:

  • Online sales grew 17% worldwide.
  • Advertising grew 25% worldwide.
  • Membership fee revenue grew 17%.

Does Walmart’s cash support its high price?

Free cash flow is the cash a business makes from operations, minus what it spends on buildings, equipment and technology. The table below sets that cash against what investors pay for each company’s earnings.

Company P/E, last full year P/E, this year’s estimate Free cash flow per dollar of sales, last full year Ten-year median Last four reported quarters
Walmart 46.2 43.6 2.09% 2.55% 1.84%
Costco Wholesale 52.7 47.9 3.09% 2.76% n/a
Amazon.com 35.9 20.1 1.07% 5.38% -5.88%

Source: Trefis analysis of Intrinio closing prices at the latest close and Morningstar financial statements. P/E is the share price divided by diluted earnings per share. The estimate column uses the analysts’ average in the Trefis estimates feed. Each company’s own fiscal year is used. Walmart’s last four quarters run to July 2026. Amazon’s run to September 2026. Costco’s last four reported quarters are its full year, which ended in August 2026.

Walmart’s cash has thinned as it spends more. Its spending on buildings, equipment and technology took 64.1% of its operating cash last year. In the year to January 2017 it took 33.7%. Over the four quarters to July, free cash flow fell further to 1.84 cents per dollar of sales.

Costco tells a different story. Costco kept 3.09 cents of each dollar of sales as free cash flow last year. That ranks eighth of its last 10 years, counting from the lowest. So Costco’s higher price comes with cash near the top of its own record. For a closer look, see Are You Overpaying For Costco Stock Versus Its Rivals?

Why do investors pay up despite weak cash?

Amazon.com’s cash looks far weaker. Over the four quarters to September, it had negative free cash flow of 5.88 cents per dollar of sales. That is below every one of its last 10 years. Its spending took 94.5% of its operating cash last year. Still, investors pay only 20.1 times this year’s estimated earnings for Amazon.com, because its earnings have jumped this year. On its last four reported quarters, its P/E is already 20.8. For Walmart they pay 43.6 times this year’s estimate.

We think there is a fair case for Walmart, too. Its extra spending is building the online and advertising businesses that grew this quarter. If that spending eases, cash could recover toward its old level. One caution on the numbers: Walmart’s P/E went from 46.7 to 46.2 between Wednesday and Thursday. That change reflects only the price move. Morningstar has not yet added the new quarter’s earnings.

Does the report-day move tell holders much?

History says not much. Across the 31 Walmart reports from February 2019 to August 2026, the stock rose on 15 report days and fell on 16. In 19 of the 31, or 61%, the next 20 trading days moved the same way as the report day. On the four earlier report days when SPY fell more than 1%, Walmart beat SPY on three.

The wider question is whether the market faces another year like 2022. Our piece Will 2027 Be A 2022 Repeat For Stocks? looks at that. For the next dates to watch, see Which Dates Could Move Walmart Stock Most?

What would change the picture?

Our read: Walmart’s growth story held up this quarter, but its cash has not kept pace with its price. If free cash flow climbs back toward about 2.6 cents per dollar of sales, the high price looks easier to defend. If it stays near 1.84 cents, the price rests mostly on faith in the digital business.

The stock is up 13.1% this year and sits 6.5% below its 52-week high. When much of a gain rests on a price the cash does not yet back, it helps to decide ahead of time when you would sell some, and how.

Too Much Riding On One Stock?

If Walmart is a big part of your wealth, so are its risk and its tax bill. What’s your exit plan? Our partner advisory firm offers a free 30-minute strategy review covering a floor under losses and a lower-tax way out.

Map My Exit Options

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.