Walmart Or Amazon: Which Is The Tech Stock Now?

WMTYTD+15.2%SPYYTD+8.2%XLPYTD+20.0%
Analyze WMT →

Today’s big story: Anthropic IPO: Priced For 2031, Or 2036?

Walmart reports quarterly results on Thursday, Nov 19, before the market opens. The results come out at 7 a.m. ET. Investors will read them for what shoppers bought, what they paid, and whether they will keep spending through the holidays.

The bigger story is the stock’s price. At Tuesday’s close, investors paid 46 times Walmart’s profit over the last year. For Amazon, they paid 21 times. This measure is the trailing price-to-earnings ratio, or P/E: the share price divided by the last four quarters’ profit per share. On it, the grocer is priced like a tech company, and the tech company like a grocer.

Image from Pixabay

Is Walmart Growing Like A Tech Company?

No, and that is the puzzle. Walmart’s sales grew 5.9% in its latest quarter from a year earlier. Amazon’s grew 12.1%. Amazon also keeps more of each sale. Over the last four quarters, it kept 13.1 cents of every sales dollar as operating profit, the profit from running the business. Walmart kept 4.4 cents.

So Walmart’s 46 times buys a slower business with thinner margins than Amazon’s. Among the four stocks below, only Costco costs more, at 53 times. Target costs 17 times.

Stock P/E Sales growth Operating margin
Walmart 46 +5.9% 4.4%
Amazon 21 +12.1% 13.1%
Costco 53 +11.1% 3.9%
Target 17 +5.3% 5.6%

P/E on the last four quarters’ profit at the Nov 17 close. Sales growth: latest quarter vs the same quarter a year earlier. Operating margin: last four quarters. Source: Trefis, prices through Nov 17; Morningstar financials.

Walmart’s 46 times is a growth price for a business growing slower than Amazon’s. Most portfolios settle for growth or for income. The Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio is built for growth: more than 105% since September 2020. The Trefis Income Solution is built for income, with a dividend yield about 3x the S&P 500’s. We’d be glad to show you both: see the HQ Portfolio or see the Income Solution.

Two caveats. First, Amazon’s 21 times flatters it. In the quarter to June, Amazon booked $62.6 billion of profit on $27.5 billion of operating income. The gap came from outside its operations. Measured against operating income, Walmart still costs 31.4 times and Amazon 26.7 times.

Second, the forward P/E uses analysts’ estimates of next year’s profit. On that basis, Walmart costs about 40 times and Amazon 24 times. Analysts also expect Amazon’s sales to grow about 15% a year through 2030. For Walmart, they expect about 4%.

What Is The Market Paying For?

Investors are paying for the direction of Walmart’s margin, not its level. Its operating margin was 5.0% in the July quarter, up from 4.1% a year earlier. That rise was helped by tariff refunds Walmart says it will put back into prices. Delivery, advertising and membership fees are making the grocer look more like a platform.

Investors have rewarded that. Walmart is up 25% in 12 months, with dividends, and sits 5% below its high. Amazon is up 11% and sits 9% below its high.

The shopper still matters. For one example, see Tyson Stock Jumped 9%. Is Beef Still Raising Your Grocery Bill? But Walmart’s stock price now depends more on the platform story.

What Happens When Walmart Reports At This Price?

It usually falls on the day. Walmart has reported 19 times since February 2022 with a full year of earnings behind each report. Its six reports at the highest P/Es, 39 times earnings or more, all came in the last two years. The stock fell on five of those six report days. Across all six, it fell 3.7% on average.

Report P/E before Report day 3 months after
Feb 2025 42 −6.5% −0.3%
Aug 2025 41 −4.5% +2.7%
Nov 2025 40 +6.5% +18.6%
Feb 2026 49 −1.4% +5.2%
May 2026 49 −7.3% −14.3%
Aug 2026 42 −9.2% +23.1%

P/E before: prior-day close ÷ last four quarters of reported adjusted earnings per share. Report day: close vs prior close. 3 months after: about 63 trading days from the report-day close (Aug 2026: to Nov 17), dividends included. Source: Trefis, prices through Nov 17; earnings per share from FMP.

At lower P/Es, the record flips. In the other 13 reports, the stock rose on 9 report days. Across all 13, it rose 1.2% on average. In our view, a high price leaves no room for a quarter that is only good.

On the adjusted earnings used in the table, Walmart’s P/E today is about 45. That is inside the table’s range. Four of those six reports were followed by a drop of more than 4% on the day. On that record, a drop that size on Thursday would not be unusual.

The record is just as clear on what came next. Three months after those six reports, the stock was up 5.8% on average. After the 9.2% drop in August, it gained 23.1%. The big exception was May. After a 7.3% drop on the day, the stock fell another 14.3% over three months.

What Would Change The Picture?

In our view, two things would justify the price. The margin would keep climbing toward Amazon’s, and sales growth would speed up. Then the stock could rise on the day, as it did in November 2025.

If the margin stalls near 4%, the P/E would rest on a story the numbers no longer support. That would look like May.

By the market’s price, Walmart is the tech stock now. By the business, Amazon still is. Both are large, profitable companies, and which one the market favors can change with one report. Owning a group of quality companies means you do not have to pick the winner.

Why Own One Leader When You Can Own 30?

If you like finding quality companies like Walmart and Amazon, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio holds 30 of them in equal weight, and has returned more than 105% since its September 2020 launch. You’re welcome to look inside.

See The HQ Portfolio

For education, not a recommendation to buy or sell.

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.