Own Costco? Watch Walmart’s Report On Thursday

WMTYTD+15.2%SPYYTD+8.2%XLPYTD+20.0%
Analyze WMT →

Walmart reports its third quarter tomorrow, Thursday, Nov 19, before the market opens. Walmart’s options priced a move of about 6.9% either way through Friday. Walmart is often read as a gauge of the US shopper. This piece asks a narrower question. Which rival stocks have actually moved with Walmart on its report days?

The answer is Costco, not Target. Costco closed the same way as Walmart on 49 of Walmart’s 67 report days since February 2010. Walmart rose or fell 5% or more on 16 of those days. Costco moved the same way on all 16. It also matched Walmart on 11 of the last 12 report days.

Target is the weaker link. It closed with Walmart on 59.7% of report days. On an ordinary trading day it does so 65.3% of the time. So Walmart’s report days make the link weaker, not stronger. That still holds when we leave out the days when Target’s own report landed at the same time.

retail checkout
Image from Pixabay

Four Rivals On Walmart’s Report Days

For each report, we compared every stock’s close with its prior close. “Same way” means both closed up or both closed down. A stock’s normal day is the median size of its daily move over the prior 250 trading days. The figures are price only and leave out dividends.

Stock Same way on report days Same way on ordinary days Same way on 16 big days Report-day move vs normal day
Costco 73.1% 71.3% 16 1.2 times
Kroger 76.1% 62.6% 14 1.4 times
Target 59.7% 65.3% 13 1.4 times

Kroger shows the biggest jump over its everyday link. It moves with Walmart 13.5 percentage points more often on report days than on ordinary days. But much of that fades once the market’s own move is taken out. Measured against the S&P 500, Kroger matched Walmart on 64.2% of report days. Costco held at 73.1% on the same test.

Amazon shows no link at all. It closed with Walmart on 17 of 31 report days since 2019. The correlation of their report-day moves is about zero.

The rivals’ moves are modest. Their report-day move was a median 1.2 to 1.4 times their normal day. Walmart’s own move was a median 5.0 times its normal day.

Target Split From Walmart On Two Recent Big Days

Walmart’s recent big days show the split plainly. On May 21, 2026, Walmart fell 7.3%. Costco fell 2.2% that day, but Target rose 3.1%. On Nov 20, 2025, Walmart rose 6.5%. Costco rose 0.30%, while Target fell 2.8%. On Aug 20, 2026, Walmart fell 9.2% and Costco fell 2.5%.

A separate piece explains why Pricey Walmart Stock Falls More Often, Not Harder. An earlier piece looked at what in Walmart’s last quarter may not repeat.

What Is Different This Time

  • Target was scheduled to report on Wednesday, Nov 18, before the open, a day before Walmart. The outcome is not in our data. Its own news gets priced first.
  • Costco and Kroger are not on the earnings calendar for Nov 17 to 24. None of their reports has fallen on a Walmart report day or the day after.
  • Both have run up since Walmart’s last report on Aug 20. Kroger is up 25.9% and Costco 18.9%. Walmart is up 22.8% and Target 0.81%.
  • Costco’s report-day rate is barely above its everyday 71.3%. Its link with Walmart is mostly everyday co-movement. That link has held firm on big days.

For a Costco owner, the record says a sharp Walmart move has usually come with a Costco move the same way. That Costco move has been smaller. This is a pattern, not a forecast for tomorrow. If Walmart moves sharply and Costco does not follow, the pattern has weakened. For the market’s wider moves this week, see our AI storyline. A separate piece asked whether Walmart stock adds to the market risk you already carry.

A pattern from 67 reports is still only a pattern. We built our own approach on records like this one, and we would gladly hear about a better one.

Found A Better Strategy? We’d Love To Learn.

Ours is the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio: 30 quality stocks in equal weight. Since its September 2020 launch it has returned more than 105%, ahead of a benchmark that combines the S&P 500, S&P MidCap and Russell 2000. If yours has done better, tell us about it. If not, come take a look.

See The HQ Portfolio

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.