$1 Million In Stocks And Bonds: Worth It?

VOOYTD+8.0%SPYYTD+7.9%QQQYTD+7.7%
Analyze VOO →

Today’s big story: Could Anthropic Stock Fall 25%?

Bonds have had a rough five years. AGG, a big fund of U.S. investment-grade bonds, lost 1.2% in the five years to Wednesday’s close, with dividends counted. That record raises a fair question: is the 60/40 mix of stocks and bonds broken?

This article looks at the mix over a full 20 years instead. Put $1,000,000 into 60% stocks and 40% bonds on Nov 17, 2006. It was worth $4,542,092 at the Nov 18, 2026 close. That is 7.9% a year, with dividends reinvested. The 2008 crash was fully healed by Nov 3, 2010. The 2022 fall was healed by Jan 29, 2024.

Stocks alone made more money. The same $1,000,000 in SPY, a fund that tracks the S&P 500, grew to $7,494,750. So the bonds cost $2,952,658 over the 20 years. What they bought was a calmer ride. The two crashes show how much calm, and when it failed.

How did the stock-and-bond mix hold up in 2008?

From its record close on Oct 9, 2007, the mix fell 33.7% to its low on Mar 9, 2009. Stocks alone fell 55.2% over the same dates. The mix was back at its old high on Nov 3, 2010. Stocks alone took until Aug 16, 2012. That is 652 days longer.

The bonds did the work. AGG gained 8.3% in calendar 2008. SPY lost 36.8% that year. The mix lost 19.1%.

In 2008 the bond half turned a 55.2% fall into a 33.7% fall. Falling less in a crash matters most when you live on what your money pays. The Trefis Income Solution pays a dividend yield about 3x the S&P 500’s, and it lost less than the S&P 500 in all 9 big selloffs since 2018. See the metrics.

Why did the bonds help so little in 2022?

In 2022 the bonds fell with the stocks, as interest rates rose fast. AGG lost 13.0% in calendar 2022. SPY lost 18.2%. The mix lost 16.1%.

From its record on Dec 27, 2021, the mix fell 20.9%. Stocks alone fell 24.5% from their Jan 3, 2022 record. The gap was only 3.6 percentage points.

The mix then took 763 days to get back to its record. That was 54 days longer than stocks alone. Stocks were back on Dec 13, 2023. The mix was back on Jan 29, 2024.

The bond fund itself has not healed. AGG fell 18.4% from its Aug 4, 2020 record. At Wednesday’s close it was still 3.4% below that record.

Was 2022 the rule or the exception?

Over 20 years the mix had five falls of 10% or more. Stocks alone had a fall of 10% or more in each of the same five spells. The table below sets those five falls side by side.

Fall began Mix fall SPY fall Mix days to record SPY days to record
Oct 2007 -33.7% -55.2% 1,121 1,773
Sep 2018 -11.5% -19.3% 182 204
Feb 2020 -21.3% -33.7% 152 173
Dec 2021 / Jan 2022 -20.9% -24.5% 763 709
Feb 2025 -11.1% -18.8% 113 127

Source: Trefis analysis of Intrinio daily prices for SPY and AGG, Nov 17, 2006 to Nov 18, 2026. The mix is 60% SPY and 40% AGG. It is set back to that split once a year in November. Dividends are reinvested. A fall runs from a record close to the low. Days are calendar days from the record close to the first close back at or above it.

The mix fell less in all five falls. It got back to its record sooner in four of the five. 2022 is the one exception.

The daily ride was calmer too. The mix’s swings, measured as yearly volatility, came to 11.6%. SPY’s came to 19.5%.

Do VOO and BND tell the same story?

Many investors build this mix with Vanguard’s VOO and BND. Both are too young for a 20-year test. BND’s first row on our platform is Apr 10, 2007. VOO’s is Sep 9, 2010. So SPY and AGG stand in for them here.

A check with the Vanguard funds from Nov 18, 2010 gives the same 2022 picture. A VOO and BND mix fell 20.9% from Dec 27, 2021 to Oct 14, 2022. It was back at its record on Jan 29, 2024, the same day as the stand-ins. BND lost 1.2% over the last five years, about the same as AGG.

Did re-balancing once a year pay off?

Our test set the mix back to 60/40 once a year. That means selling some of whichever side rose and buying the other. It counts no taxes and no trading costs.

Left alone after the first day, the mix would be worth $5,209,158. Its worst fall was 31.3%, against 33.7% for the re-balanced mix. Over this period, re-balancing cost money. Our read: its value is that the mix stays at the split you chose, which this test does not score.

So is the stock-and-bond mix broken?

The five-year bond loss is real. Yet the mix still made 36.3% over those five years. SPY gained 66.2% in that time.

Over the 19 full calendar years from 2007 to 2025, the mix lost money in 3. SPY also lost money in 3. The mix’s worst year was 2008, with a 19.1% loss.

Our read: the bonds cost $2,952,658 of growth. In return, the mix fell less in each of its five big falls. It healed sooner in all of them but 2022. This piece is part of our storyline Is 60/40 Dead? For the bond side in a stock sell-off, see When SPY Falls 10%, Do Treasury Bonds Still Help? For a dividend fund’s ride, see What Ten Years Of VYM Did To $1 Million.

Nobody in 2006 knew that 2008 would favor bonds and 2022 would not. A mix set up ahead of time went through both without needing that forecast.

Stop Guessing. Start Positioning.

No one can predict surprises like this one. The Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio doesn’t try: it holds 30 quality stocks in equal weight, so no single surprise decides your result. Come see how it works.

See How HQ Works

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.