How Did IBM Stock Leave Cognizant Behind?
Today’s big story: Could Anthropic Stock Fall 25%?
Two companies in the same industry grew their sales at about the same pace over the last three years. Yet over the five years to November 2026, one stock rose 135.7% and the other fell 21.9%. International Business Machines (IBM) delivered the gain, while Cognizant Technology Solutions (CTSH) suffered the decline. So where do you think the gap came from: faster growth, bigger profits, or investors paying more?

Who Has Beaten Cognizant Over Five Years?
Among companies whose three-year sales growth was close to Cognizant’s, one stands out: IBM. Its stock beat Cognizant’s by a wide margin. Across the whole industry, Cognizant stock landed near the middle, beating 16 of the 30 companies in its industry over those five years.
Cognizant stock sits 157.6 points behind IBM’s over five years. If much of your savings is in Cognizant, that is a long stretch of falling behind to keep sitting through. In a free 30-minute review, our partner advisory firm can show you ways to limit your loss if the stock falls further and to sell with a smaller tax bill. Book the free review.
The gap between the two stocks built up over three and five years, not over the past year.
| Company | Sales growth, 3-year average | P/E | 1-year | 3-year | 5-year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cognizant Technology Solutions (CTSH) | 4.1% | 10.1x | -17.3% | -11.6% | -21.9% |
| International Business Machines (IBM) | 4.5% | 19.3x | -19.0% | 63.2% | 135.7% |
Total return to 2026-11-18, including dividends. Companies in IT Consulting & Other Services whose sales grew within 4 points of CTSH’s. P/E: latest close over the last four quarters’ earnings per share.
Cognizant’s five-year fall was close to its industry’s middle. The median stock in the industry fell 22.6% over the same five years, so IBM is the one that stands out.
Did IBM Grow Faster Than Cognizant?
Over the last three years, only a little. IBM’s sales grew 4.5% a year on average, against 4.1% for Cognizant. That is about the same pace.
The two businesses also sell different things. IBM sells software such as Red Hat, consulting, and the servers and storage that big clients use to run their key work. Cognizant sells technology services. Its Health Sciences business and its Financial Services business each brought in about 30% of its 2025 sales.
Where Did The Gap Come From?
The gap came from both bigger profits and what investors pay for them. From the four quarters to September 2021 to the four quarters to September 2026, IBM’s earnings per share rose 121.7%, against 54.8% for Cognizant. These are figures as first reported, and IBM’s are not like for like. Its 2021 figure still included Kyndryl, the business it spun off in November 2021.
Cognizant’s operating margin rose 1.8 points over the same five years. That helped its profit per share grow faster than its sales. Net income rose 37.1%, and the share count fell 14.4%, so each share got more of the profit. The share count compares fiscal Q3 2021 with fiscal Q3 2026 only, so these two figures do not combine exactly into the rise in earnings per share.
Investors also pay much less for each dollar of Cognizant’s profit. Cognizant traded at 21.0 times earnings in 2021 and trades at 10.6 times today. IBM’s multiple fell less, from 26.3 times in 2021 to 19.5 times today. So IBM stock came out ahead of Cognizant on both counts. Its profit per share grew faster, and investors cut its multiple by less. The 2021 multiples are priced on September 30, 2021, before that spinoff. The returns run from November 2021, after it, and include dividends. So these figures show why IBM pulled ahead, not the exact size of each return.
What To Watch In Cognizant’s Next Report
On the fiscal Q3 2026 call, management said Cognizant’s adjusted operating margin rose from a year earlier for the seventh quarter in a row. This margin leaves out some costs. The gains came from holding prices, new AI services, and more work done offshore.
Cognizant is expected to report its fiscal Q4 2026 results in February 2027. That report will show how its operating margin compares with a year earlier.
Two companies with about the same sales growth over the last three years gave their shareholders a very different five years. Spreading your money across many strong companies means you do not have to pick the right one.
Why Own One Leader When You Can Own 30?
If you like finding quality companies like Cognizant Technology Solutions, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio holds 30 of them in equal weight, and has returned more than 105% since its September 2020 launch. You’re welcome to look inside.
Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.