What Ten Years Of VYM Did To $1 Million
Today’s big story: Could Anthropic Stock Fall 25%?
$1 million put in VYM, the Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF, at the Nov 18, 2016 close was worth $2,945,829 at Wednesday’s close. That assumes every dividend was reinvested. It works out to 11.4% a year. An ETF, or exchange-traded fund, is a basket of stocks that trades like a single share.
Many investors see dividend funds as the safe, boring choice when tech stocks wobble. This piece looks at the ride, not just the end value. VYM had 4 falls of 10% or more in ten years. QQQ, the fund that tracks the Nasdaq-100 index, had 13. Yet in 2020, VYM fell further than QQQ and took longer to recover.
The cash was steady too. If you spent the dividends, you would now hold $2,175,790 in shares. You would also have collected $422,311 in cash along the way. The yearly cash rose from $33,020 in the first 12 months to $50,048 in the latest 12 months.
How bad was VYM’s worst fall?
The worst fall came in 2020. From Jan 17 to Mar 23, 2020, VYM lost 35.2% with dividends reinvested. Counting from that peak, it needed 241 trading days to get back to its old high. QQQ lost 28.6% in its own 2020 fall. It was back at its high 73 trading days after its peak.
A fall that deep, followed by a wait that long, tests any holder’s patience. Holding on is easier when your portfolio falls less than the market. For every dollar its benchmark lost, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio lost about 81 cents on average. See the HQ record.
At the Mar 23, 2020 low, the $1 million in VYM was worth $926,763. Only two closes in ten years were below the starting $1 million. At QQQ’s low that March, its $1 million was still worth $1,485,004. QQQ had simply built a bigger cushion first.
The table shows all four of VYM’s falls of 10% or more, with dividends reinvested.
| Fall | Peak to low | Size of fall | Trading days from peak to old high |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2018 | Jan 26 to Dec 24, 2018 | -16.2% | 304 |
| 2020 | Jan 17 to Mar 23, 2020 | -35.2% | 241 |
| 2022 | Apr 20 to Sep 30, 2022 | -15.8% | 155 |
| 2025 | Feb 19 to Apr 8, 2025 | -14.5% | 90 |
Source: Trefis analysis of Intrinio adjusted daily closes over the ten years to Wednesday’s close. A fall runs from a record close to the lowest close before that record is regained. Recovery is the first close at or above the old record. Days are trading days, counted from the peak.
Only 2020 was a big fall. The 2018 fall was about as deep as the 2022 one. Counting price only, without dividends, the 2022 fall started earlier and lasted much longer. VYM’s share price peaked on Jan 12, 2022 and took 529 trading days to regain that high. The dividends paid along the way shortened the wait.
When did VYM hold up better than QQQ?
In 2022, the dividend fund did its job. VYM fell 15.8% and was back at its high in 155 trading days. QQQ fell 35.1% and needed 494 trading days. Over calendar 2022, VYM returned -0.43% while QQQ returned -32.6%.
The same pattern shows up now. QQQ set a record close on Oct 6, 2026. Since then it has fallen 13.2%. VYM moved 0.90% over the same weeks. VYM closed at $159.79 on Wednesday, 4.3% below its Aug 13 record closing price.
The year 2020 cut the other way. VYM returned 1.1% in calendar 2020. QQQ returned 48.6%. A dividend fund cushioned one bad year and lagged badly in another.
How much cash did VYM pay each year?
The yearly cash kept rising, even in the bad years. The figures below are on the starting $1 million. Each dividend counts in the year of its ex-date, the cut-off date for getting it.
- In 2017 it paid $32,695.
- In 2020, the year of the worst fall, it paid $39,571.
- In 2022 it paid $44,278.
- In 2025 it paid $47,669.
So far in 2026 it has paid $37,147, and the December dividend is not yet declared. The latest 12 months of income equal 2.3% of Wednesday’s closing price. On the 2016 cost, the same income is 5.0% a year. The yearly cash grew 51.6% from the first 12 months to the latest.
What did VYM give up against QQQ and SCHD?
The calm came at a price. QQQ’s $1 million grew to $6,024,248. That is $3,078,420 more than VYM’s. QQQ compounded at 19.7% a year. SPY, the S&P 500 fund, turned $1 million into $3,913,213.
SCHD, the Schwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF, is the closest peer. It turned $1 million into $3,427,228, or 13.1% a year. Its latest 12 months of cash on the starting $1 million was $74,372. But SCHD took 493 trading days from its peak to recover from its 2022 fall.
What did VYM’s ride mean for its owners?
This piece is part of our series on stock-and-bond portfolios, which looks at how real portfolios rode out the past decade. If you hold an index fund for growth, read next: Is Your VOO Fund Secretly An AI Bet?
Our read: VYM gave steady, rising cash and mostly smaller falls. It did not protect you every time. In 2020 it fell harder than QQQ and took longer to come back. Owners got a calmer ride most years, and paid for it with less growth.
No single fund in this comparison won on growth, income and calm at once. We have an approach to that trade-off we are proud of, and we know some readers have built better ones.
Found A Better Strategy? We’d Love To Learn.
Ours is the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio: 30 quality stocks in equal weight. Since its September 2020 launch it has returned more than 105%, ahead of a benchmark that combines the S&P 500, S&P MidCap and Russell 2000. If yours has done better, tell us about it. If not, come take a look.
For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.