Tariff Refunds Are About A Fifth Of Target’s Guidance

TGTYTD+75.7%SPYYTD+7.9%XLPYTD+19.6%
Analyze TGT →

Today’s big story: Could Anthropic Stock Fall 25%?

Target reported its third quarter on Wednesday. The stock rose 4.0% to $165.93. The common view is that its turnaround is working. Sales rose 7.1%. Comparable sales grew 5.6%, led by more shopper traffic. Target also raised its 2026 earnings guidance to $10.65 to $11.40 a share.

This article looks at how much of that guidance comes from tariff refunds. The answer is about a fifth. Target has booked $2.14 a share of refunds so far this year. That is 19.4% of the midpoint of its new guidance. The guidance assumes no further refunds.

That leaves 2027 with a gap to fill. With no refunds next year, Target’s underlying earnings would have to grow 24.1% just to match the 2026 midpoint. The refunds are repayments of tariffs charged under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, or IEEPA. Target booked $1.3 billion of them in the first nine months, as a cut to its cost of goods.

shopping cart
Image from Pixabay

How much of Target’s quarter came from refunds?

Earnings per share, or EPS, is profit divided by the number of shares. Target earned $2.65 a share in the third quarter. The CFO said refunds of about $300 million added about $0.50 of that. That is 18.9% of the quarter’s EPS. For the first nine months, refunds were 25.3% of EPS.

Without the refunds, the 2026 guidance midpoint drops to $8.89 a share. That is below fiscal 2023’s $8.94. It is roughly level with fiscal 2024’s $8.86.

About a fifth of Target’s 2026 earnings guidance, $2.14 a share, comes from tariff refunds that are not expected to repeat. If the stock gives back part of its 87.4% climb in a year when they stop, that is a fall you would have to sit through. When the market has fallen, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio has lost about 81 cents for every $1 its benchmark lost, on average. See the HQ record.

Is Target’s business growing without the refunds?

Yes, by Target’s own measures. This is the strongest point against the worry in this article. Excluding refunds, Q3 operating income was $1,371 million. Operating income is profit from running the stores, before interest and tax. That was 23.6% above last year’s adjusted figure. Adjusted figures leave out one-time items.

The basis matters here. Excluding refunds, Q3 adjusted EPS rose 21%, and GAAP EPS rose 42%. GAAP is the standard accounting rulebook. Over nine months, EPS without refunds rose 23.4% against last year’s adjusted figure. Against last year’s GAAP figure, it rose only 8.4%.

The CFO expects the 2026 operating margin without refunds to be about 0.5 points above last year’s adjusted rate. Margin is operating income as a share of sales. Target also raised its 2026 sales growth outlook to around 6%. The guidance implies fourth-quarter EPS of about $2.56 with no refunds. That would be 11.1% above the $2.30 of a year earlier.

How does 2026 compare with Target’s past earnings?

The table below sets the 2026 guidance, with and without refunds, against Target’s annual EPS since fiscal 2020.

Fiscal year Diluted EPS
2020 $8.64
2021 $14.10
2022 $5.98
2023 $8.94
2024 $8.86
2025 $8.13
2026 guidance midpoint $11.03
2026 midpoint without refunds $8.89

Source: Morningstar annual income statements on the Trefis platform, and Target’s 2026 guidance. Past years are GAAP diluted EPS. Target’s 2026 guidance is the same on a GAAP and adjusted basis. The refund figure is the $2.14 a share Target has booked this year.

With refunds, 2026 would be Target’s best year since fiscal 2021’s $14.10. Without them, it is 9.3% above fiscal 2025’s GAAP EPS. That is real growth. But it is not a record.

What does 2027 need to do?

If no refunds arrive in 2027, flat underlying earnings would show up as a 19.4% drop in reported EPS. Analysts already expect a step down. The analyst consensus for fiscal 2027 was $9.70 a share at Wednesday’s close. That is 12.0% below the 2026 guidance midpoint. It is also 9.2% above the midpoint without refunds.

The price-to-earnings ratio, or P/E, is the share price divided by EPS. At Wednesday’s close, Target traded at 15.1 times its 2026 guidance midpoint. On guidance without refunds, the P/E is 18.7. On the 2027 consensus, it is 17.1. Target also plans $5 billion to $6 billion of capital spending in 2027, compared with about $5 billion this year.

How do Lowe’s, TJX and Walmart treat tariff refunds?

Three other big retailers got the same kind of refund or planned for it. Each treats it differently.

  • Lowe’s booked about $250 million of IEEPA refunds in Q3, worth $0.34 of adjusted EPS. It plans to reinvest all of it and calls the refund neutral for the year.
  • TJX Companies leaves refunds out of its adjusted results. Its full-year adjusted guidance of $5.17 to $5.20 a share assumes no further refunds.
  • Walmart said in May that its guidance assumes no IEEPA refunds. It reports today, Thursday, Nov 19.

Target is the one of these four that keeps refunds already booked inside its headline guidance. On Wednesday, Lowe’s stock rose 1.1% and TJX rose 8.0%.

What could make the 2027 gap smaller?

Two things could shrink it. More refunds could arrive, though Target’s guidance assumes none. Or underlying earnings could keep growing at close to the 23.6% pace of Q3 operating income without refunds. That is near the 24.1% needed to match 2026, so any drop would be small. If growth slows toward the 8.4% GAAP pace, the drop in reported EPS gets harder to avoid.

The same question sits behind the downside case for this stock. For that view, see How Much Could You Lose In Target Stock?

Our read: Target’s business is improving, but about a fifth of this year’s earnings came from refunds that are not expected to repeat. After an 87.4% climb in a year, that is a good reason to decide now how much of your money should ride on one retailer, and how you would sell some.

Too Much Riding On One Stock?

If Target is a big part of your wealth, so are its risk and its tax bill. What’s your exit plan? Our partner advisory firm offers a free 30-minute strategy review covering a floor under losses and a lower-tax way out.

Map My Exit Options

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.