Is Nvidia Stock Dead Money For A Year?

NVDAYTD-18.9%SPYYTD+7.9%QQQYTD+7.7%
Analyze NVDA →

Today’s big story: Could Anthropic Stock Fall 25%?

The AI trade has had a hard five months. The VanEck chip fund (SMH) is down 31% from its June 22 high. Nvidia is down 37% from its October high. The Nasdaq 100 is down 13% from its Oct 6 high.

The worry now is not a dip. It is a lost year, or dead money: a stock that goes nowhere while everything else moves. We checked every fall this size since 2003, what set the dead years apart, and what to watch now. The dated events ahead are in our series hub, What 1 Big Trigger Could Make Nvidia Stock Jump By Dec 31?

Here is the short answer. Since 2003, the chip fund has fallen 30% from a record high four times. It was higher a year later all four times, by a median of 60%. The exception is 2008. That January the fund was 30% below its 2007 high, and a year later it was 38% lower. Nvidia’s dead years in 2008 and 2022 came when its buyers stopped spending. Today they are spending 87% more than a year ago.

Nvidia is already 37% below its high, and the record says a dead year is possible. Holding on through a year like that is the hard part. Holding on is easier when your portfolio falls less than the market. For every dollar its benchmark lost, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio lost about 81 cents on average. See the HQ record.

Image from Pixabay

How Often Did A Fall Like This Become Dead Money?

For Nvidia, two times in eight. Since 2003, Nvidia has first closed 35% below its high eight earlier times. Twice it was lower a year later. It was down 31% a year after August 2003 and 68% a year after January 2008. Its first 30% fall, in January 2022, also went badly. A year later it was still 11% lower.

The chip fund’s 2008 fall is not one of its four, because its 2007 high was not a record. It is still the case to remember. The fund was 30% below that high in January 2008 and 38% lower a year later.

After a fall of Higher 12 months later Median change, 12 months later
Chip fund 30%+ 4 of 4 +60%
Nvidia 35%+ 6 of 8 +35%
Nasdaq 100 12%+ 12 of 14 +25%

Source: Trefis, prices 2003 through Nov 18, adjusted for dividends. Each row starts at the first close at or past the fall from a prior record high.

Recoveries often came after another drop. In the year after these falls, the typical further drop was 35% for Nvidia and 10% for the chip fund.

What Made 2008 And 2022 Different?

The buyers stopped buying. In 2008, a recession cut demand for chips. In 2022, demand for gaming and crypto-mining chips collapsed just as interest rates jumped. Both times, Nvidia’s sales fell.

Today the buyers are spending far more. Look at their capital spending, the money they put into long-lasting assets such as data centers. Over the last year, Amazon spent $215 billion and Alphabet $160 billion. Microsoft spent $136 billion and Meta $104 billion. Together that is 87% more than a year earlier. The fear is not that they have stopped. It is whether they can keep paying.

How Will You Know Which One This Is?

We see three signals, in this order.

First, Oracle is expected to report on Dec 14. Among the biggest buyers, it spends the most against its cash. Its capital spending is up 176%, and its stock is down 65%.

Second, Big Tech gives its 2027 spending plans in late January and early February. Plans that rise again would point to a recovery. Flat plans would point to a long pause.

Third, watch interest rates. The 3-month T-bill, a short-term US government loan, now yields 4.34%. In January it yielded 3.65%.

So What Should A Long-Term Investor Do?

In our view, plan for both outcomes rather than bet on one. The record says a recovery is likelier than a dead year, but often after another drop. If a dead year would force you to sell, the position is too big. If not, the record favors patience.

We weigh the income choice in Dividend Stocks Or AI Stocks: Which Fits Now?

In 2008 and 2022, Nvidia was lower a year later because its buyers stopped spending. Today they are spending 87% more. Watch the spending, not the stock price.

Those spending signals arrive between mid-December and early February. If you plan to wait for them before you buy, your cash can earn something in the meantime.

Waiting To Buy Nvidia? Why Let Your Cash Sit Idle?

The right price can take months. Meanwhile, the Trefis Income Solution pays a dividend yield about 3x the S&P 500’s, from 50 stocks with at least 10 straight years of dividends. Why not choose a better approach?

See If It Fits Your Plan

For education, not a recommendation to buy or sell.

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.