Dividend Stocks Or AI Stocks: Which Fits Now?
Today’s big story: Could Anthropic Stock Fall 25%?
The VanEck Semiconductor fund, a basket of chip stocks, is down 31% since its June 22 high. We call it the chip fund here. Over the same five months, two big dividend funds rose. Vanguard’s High Dividend Yield fund gained 1%. iShares’ Select Dividend fund gained 4%.
So should an investor with a few million dollars give up on the AI trade and live off dividends instead? Below we compare the two in the selloffs and over the full run. Then we show what each one is for. This piece is part of our series on the triggers that could revive the AI trade. The series starts with What 1 Big Trigger Could Make Nvidia Stock Jump By Dec 31?
The short answer: dividends protect, and AI grows. Neither is better on its own. What matters is how much of each your plan can live with.

How Did Dividends Do When AI Stocks Fell?
Better, in each selloff since 2018. In 2022, the chip fund fell 45% from peak to low. The Vanguard dividend fund fell 11%. In the 2025 tariff scare, the falls were 33% and 12%. The gap was small only in the 2020 crash, when everything fell together.
| Selloff, peak to low | Chip fund | Dividend fund |
|---|---|---|
| Late 2018 | -27% | -12% |
| 2020 crash | -34% | -32% |
| 2022 | -45% | -11% |
| 2025 tariffs | -33% | -12% |
| 2026, Jun 22 to now | -31% | +1% |
Chip fund: VanEck Semiconductor (SMH). Dividend fund: Vanguard High Dividend Yield (VYM). Peak-to-low dates are the chip fund’s. Closes are adjusted for dividends. Source: Trefis, prices through Nov 18.
The dividend fund fell less than the chip fund in each of these selloffs. If smaller drops matter to you, dividend stocks are worth a look. The Trefis Income Solution holds 50 dividend stocks yielding about 3x the S&P 500, each with at least 10 straight years of dividends. It lost less than the S&P 500 in all 9 big selloffs since 2018. See the Income Solution.
And Over The Full Run?
Here the AI trade wins by a wide margin. Over five years, the chip fund is up 205%. The Vanguard dividend fund is up 68%, about what the S&P 500 made (66%). Over ten years, the chip fund is up 1,356%, against 195% for the dividend fund.
That is the cost of the protection. In the good years, dividends fall far behind.
So What Is Each One For?
Dividends pay you cash while you wait. A 3% yield on $2 million is $60,000 a year, whatever the market does. The chip fund pays almost nothing. But it has grown many times faster, for those who held on through its falls.
So the decision is about size. Say 20% of a $2 million portfolio sat in the chip fund in 2022. Its fall would have cost about $181,000. At 10%, the cost would have been about $91,000.
In our view, size the AI part so a fall like 2022’s 45% is a loss you can live with. Let the dividend part pay the bills in the meantime.
What Would Change The Answer?
The AI trade’s next twelve months. If Big Tech keeps raising its spending plans, the chip side could recover. It did after most past falls, though not in 2008. If that spending stalls, dividends may keep winning.
Dividends protect, and AI grows. In every AI selloff since 2018, dividends fell less. Over five years, AI made three times as much.
So you do not have to pick one side. In our view, a plan that holds both, with each part sized so it cannot sink you, beats a bet on either.
Growth Or Income? You Can Have Both.
Most portfolios settle for one. The Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio for growth: more than 105% since September 2020. The Trefis Income Solution for a dividend yield about 3x the S&P 500’s. What’s better? We’d be glad to show you both.
See The HQ Portfolio or See The Income Solution
For education, not a recommendation to buy or sell.
For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.