Is Carvana Stock Paying You Enough For The Swings?
For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.
If you own Carvana (CVNA), the online used-car retailer, or are considering buying the stock after its 31.3% jump in the five sessions to November 4, 2026, the shares likely sit alongside investments that already track the broader market. A stock that moves this hard changes how far your entire portfolio rises and falls each day. So has the stock earned enough to make those swings worth holding?
Carvana Paid Less Per Swing Than The S&P 500
No, not over the past five years. In the five years to November 4, 2026, Carvana stock returned 5.4% a year, compared with 11.9% a year for the S&P 500. Its annual volatility over those years, which measures how widely a stock’s price swings in a typical year, was 112.4%, compared with 17.0% for the index.
When dividing each return by its volatility, Carvana stock earned 0.048 points of yearly return for each point of swing, compared with 0.7 for the S&P 500. The index therefore paid its holders far more than Carvana did for every bit of movement they experienced.
How Far Does Carvana Move With The S&P 500?
On the average day the S&P 500 rose in the year to November 4, 2026, Carvana climbed about 2.4 times as far, gaining $156 on a $10,000 holding. On the average day the index fell, Carvana again dropped more than twice as far, and the same holding lost $142.
Carvana’s beta, which tracks how far the stock moves for each 1% move in the index, was 2.15 over that year. Its volatility for the year was 61.7%, compared with 12.9% for the S&P 500. Carvana therefore adds to the market risk you already carry rather than steadying it. Some of its moves are its own, however. Its daily moves lined up with the index’s only loosely, showing a correlation of 0.45, where 1 means the two always move together.
Will Carvana Keep Moving This Much?
The stock may continue to move this much while Carvana is still chasing a goal far beyond what it sells today. Management said on the October 28, 2026 call that the company is building toward 3 million units a year, compared with a run rate of 870,000 now. Revenue grew 42.4% from a year earlier to $8.04 billion in the third quarter of fiscal 2026. Management says growth is limited mainly by how fast the company can scale its supply chain, and it is still investing in its reconditioning centers to raise production.
Carvana’s profits are also recent. The company posted an operating loss in the twelve months to September 30, 2023, and an 8.7% operating margin in the twelve months to September 30, 2026. A company still this far from its own goal is a bet still being proven.
If Carvana moves as it did over the past year, the money you hold in it will on average rise more than twice as far as the index on an up day and fall more than twice as far on a down day, though any single day can still go the other way. If you already own other car retailers, Carvana’s daily moves over the past year tracked theirs less closely than they tracked the S&P 500, with correlations of 0.23 to 0.38 against 0.45. Carvana is expected to report its next results in February 2027. Retail units sold, the measure of its progress toward that 3 million goal, is the number to watch.
Now You Know Carvana. Here Is A Better Way To Invest
Before you decide on CVNA, consider owning 30 quality companies instead of one. The Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio has returned 105% since its September 2020 launch, ahead of a benchmark that combines the S&P 500, S&P MidCap and Russell 2000.
Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.