INTU Down 60%: Is Intuit’s Proven Price Floor About To Break?

The software giant behind TurboTax has fallen back to a price floor that has launched major rallies before, but a new crack in its business model is testing investors’ faith.

Intuit (INTU), the company behind QuickBooks and TurboTax, has seen its stock slide back to a familiar battleground. Shares now trade inside a support zone between $281.51 and $311.15, a price area where buyers have decisively stepped in on three separate occasions. After a punishing twelve-month return of -61%, the stock is testing a level that has historically marked a bottom. The question every investor is asking is a simple one: with the business facing new pressures, will buyers defend this floor a fourth time?

Three Times Before, This Price Zone Marked A Turning Point

History makes a strong case for the bulls. Each of the last three visits to this price zone ended the same way: with a significant rally. The bounces weren’t small; across those episodes, the stock delivered an average peak gain of 71%, though the time to reach that peak ranged from about seven weeks to nearly five years. The first defense in May 2020 led to a 10.7% gain over the next two months. The second, just two months later, sparked a 24% rally in 50 days. The third, in September 2020, was the start of a 178% climb that played out over nearly five years, a far longer runway than the swift rebounds seen in the earlier instances.

This pattern is why the level commands attention. It’s a historical marker where selling pressure has previously exhausted itself, and demand has returned with force. But a floor is only as strong as the business standing on it.

Is Intuit Arriving Weaker This Time?

On the surface, Intuit arrives with formidable strength. Revenue over the last twelve months grew 15.1%, and its operating margin is a healthy 28%. Management points to powerful growth engines, noting that its “Assisted tax, money, portfolio and mid-market, all growing north of 30%.”  The company’s strategic push into higher-value services is working, with expectations for TurboTax Live customers to grow 38% this year. This is a core part of the bull case, and some see the recent stock decline as an opportunity to own a powerful cash generator.

But this visit to the floor comes with a serious catch. Management is “constructively dissatisfied” with performance in its do-it-yourself tax segment. The company admits it “lost on price” among the most price-sensitive filers, a critical crack in its foundation. Beyond this internal issue, the total IRS filers are expected to edge down by approximately 30 basis points this season. Compounding this, revenue from its Mailchimp acquisition was “down slightly versus a year ago.” In response to these pressures, Intuit is taking decisive action, reducing its full-time workforce by 17% to become a “faster, leaner and more focused company.”

What Decides It: The TurboTax Live Engine vs. The DIY Drag

A support level is a rhyme, not a law. The historical pattern provides a reason to watch, but the business reality will decide the outcome. The standoff at Intuit is between its proven, high-growth engines and the clear weakness at the low end of its core tax business.

Ultimately, the floor will hold only if investors believe the company’s strategic pivot can more than offset the drag from its legacy DIY segment. The single most important condition to watch is the performance of the assisted tax business. Management expects “TurboTax Live revenue to grow 36% this year.” Hitting or exceeding that target would prove the new growth engine is powerful enough to carry the company forward. Falling short would suggest the cracks in the floor are real.

If pullbacks to defensible levels are your kind of setup, our Buy the Dip screen ranks the dips where the underlying business still holds up.

And for anyone who would rather own the whole group than one company’s story, a software ETF like IGV owns the whole group. That way no single company’s next surprise decides the outcome.

INTU Has Fallen 68% From A Peak

A support level is a pattern rather than a promise, and betting heavily on it is where the risk hides. INTU itself has fallen 68% from a peak within the past five years, and a fall like that lands very differently when one position carries too much of your wealth. Knowing what a repeat would do to your net worth is exactly what the Trefis Wealth team computes, with the same rules-based systematic discipline that runs our High Quality Portfolio. Request a free vulnerability audit of your biggest positions.