Which Gives You More Of A Packaging Rebound, Smurfit WestRock Or Amcor?

SWYTD+3.9%SPYYTD+5.8%XLBYTD+10.4%
Analyze SW →

Today’s big story: Will 2027 Be A 2022 Repeat For Stocks?

Smurfit WestRock (SW) and Amcor (AMCR) both expect higher profit in 2027, once their prices catch up with rising energy costs. They get there in different ways. Smurfit WestRock makes paper and has to win higher prices for it from buyers. Amcor passes higher resin costs straight through to the customers who buy its packaging, but its energy and distribution costs take longer to pass on. Are paper prices covering Smurfit WestRock’s energy bill yet?

Image from Pixabay

Smurfit WestRock Is Still Catching Up On Energy Costs

Smurfit WestRock now expects adjusted EBITDA of about $4.7 billion for 2026, down from the $5.0 billion it expected in July. Adjusted EBITDA is a profit measure taken before interest, tax and depreciation. Management said on the October 28 call that energy alone would cost about $700 million more in 2026 than a year earlier.

Smurfit WestRock expects energy alone to cost it about $700 million more in 2026. If you hold the stock until its prices catch up, cash coming in from the rest of your savings makes that wait easier. The Trefis Income Solution pays a dividend yield about 3 times the S&P 500’s, from 50 companies that have paid dividends for at least 10 years in a row. See what it pays.

The price rises are coming, but slowly. Smurfit WestRock has been sold out in North America for months, leaving orders from April and May still to fill. Its price increases on most paper grades reach customers with the normal time lag. Its paper bag and sack business is also growing very strongly.

Smurfit WestRock’s results show the catch-up under way, but not finished. Its operating margin rose quarter by quarter from 4.0% in fiscal Q1 2026 to 6.3% in fiscal Q3. That is still below the 7.6% it earned in fiscal Q3 2025.

Amcor Has Put A Date On Its Catch-Up

Amcor’s catch-up is still a forecast, but it comes with a date. Amcor lowered its adjusted EPS outlook for the current transition period to $1.75 a share at the midpoint, from $1.85. Management said on the November 4 call that cost cuts and price rises should catch up with inflation by the end of the December quarter. Smurfit WestRock gave no such date. It said it had not yet done its 2027 budgets, though its management still said its numbers would be significantly better.

Amcor’s fully recyclable polypropylene cups, lids and containers are winning new quick-service restaurant customers. Its cash flow has further to go. The company posted a free cash outflow of $820 million in the September quarter, and it expects about $800 million to flow back in the December quarter. Its leverage, debt measured against earnings, stood at 3.76 times at the end of September. Amcor aims for about 3 times by the end of calendar 2027.

How Amcor And Smurfit WestRock Compare Head To Head

Smurfit WestRock trails Amcor on most head-to-head measures. Amcor trades at 18.1 times earnings, against 42.8 for Smurfit WestRock. In the twelve months to September 2026, Amcor’s operating margin was 9.1%, against 5.4% for Smurfit WestRock. Amcor’s revenue grew 37.3% in that time, against 1.1%, but most of that jump came from its purchase of Berry, not from selling more. In its latest quarter, Amcor’s revenue grew 7%, on volume growth of 1% and the pass-through of raw material costs.

Smurfit WestRock’s high P/E reflects how little profit it keeps from its sales. Valued on sales, Smurfit WestRock is the cheaper stock at 0.643 times, compared with 0.821 for Amcor. Smurfit WestRock also carries less debt, measuring 69.4% of its market value versus 79.9% for Amcor.

If Smurfit WestRock’s paper prices keep lagging its costs, you are paying a high multiple for a small profit. If Amcor’s cash does not come back, you hold the company with more debt for longer.

Amcor Leads On Most Measures For Now

On today’s figures, Amcor leads on more of these measures. Smurfit WestRock carries less debt and is cheaper on sales. Amcor has set the end of the December quarter for catching up with its costs. Smurfit WestRock is still chasing its energy bill with paper prices. So Amcor’s rebound is the one with a date, while Smurfit WestRock’s waits on those prices catching up.

Smurfit WestRock is expected to report in February 2027. That report will show where its operating margin stands after its rise through fiscal Q3 2026.

Choosing between these two is one way to bet on a packaging rebound. We have settled on our own way of picking stocks, and we know a reader may have found a sharper one.

Found A Better Strategy? We’d Love To Learn.

Ours is the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio: 30 quality stocks in equal weight. Since its September 2020 launch it has returned more than 105%, ahead of a benchmark that combines the S&P 500, S&P MidCap and Russell 2000. If yours has done better, tell us about it. If not, come take a look.

See The HQ Portfolio

Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.