Is Your VOO 60/40 Carrying Too Much Stock Risk?

VOOYTD+5.8%SPYYTD+5.8%QQQYTD+5.4%
Analyze VOO →

Today’s big story: Will 2027 Be A 2022 Repeat For Stocks?

Stocks had three strong years. VOO, the Vanguard S&P 500 fund, returned 26.3%, 25.0% and 17.8% in 2023, 2024 and 2025, with dividends reinvested. Then stocks turned. VOO lost 5.3% in November through the Nov 19 close. It ended Thursday, Nov 19, 8.1% below its Oct 6 record.

Here is the answer for a $1 million mix of 60% stocks and 40% bonds that nobody touched. Started three years ago in VOO and BND, the Vanguard bond fund, it is now 68.7% stocks. Started five years ago, it is 71.4% stocks. The owner chose 60%. The market chose the rest.

The usual advice in a fall is to stay calm and stay diversified. This article looks at something quieter. It looks at drift, the way a mix moves away from its target as one part grows faster.

How far has the untouched mix drifted?

The three-year portfolio is worth $1,440,185 at Thursday’s close. Getting it back to 60/40 means moving $125,754 from VOO to BND. The five-year portfolio would need $156,326 moved.

The drift was larger at the top. On Oct 6, when VOO set its record, the five-year portfolio was 73.4% stocks. Since then it has lost 5.5%. A portfolio reset to 60/40 that day lost 4.2%. On this portfolio, that reset would have saved $19,022.

The five-year VOO and BND mix went into this fall 73.4% in stocks, not the 60% its owner picked. If that money is your retirement savings, every extra point in stocks is more of the drop you have to sit through. The Trefis Income Solution fell less than the S&P 500 in each of the 9 big sell-offs since 2018, and it pays a dividend yield about 3 times the S&P 500’s. See how it held up.

Did bonds cushion this month’s fall?

Not in November. BND slipped 0.55% in November through Thursday, so bonds fell with stocks this month.

Bonds did help when measured from the top. Since the Oct 6 stock record, BND has gained 1.6%. VOO fell 2.0% on Thursday alone. BND rose 0.06% the same day.

What did resetting at past tops save?

We checked every S&P 500 fall of 20% or more since Dec 1998. For each one, we took a $1 million 60/40 set three years before the top and never re-balanced. We compared it with the same money reset to 60/40 on the day of the top. No one can pick that day in advance, so these savings show what a perfectly timed reset did. The table shows how each one fared down to the low. The last row adds the 2022 fall in QQQ, which topped on Dec 27, 2021.

Fall (top to low) Stocks at the top, untouched Untouched mix fell Reset mix fell Saved by the reset
Oct 2007 to Mar 2009 66.6% 34.1% 30% $54,971
Feb 2020 to Mar 2020 66.7% 23% 20.8% $29,453
Jan 2022 to Oct 2022 73.1% 21.8% 20.5% $22,115
Dec 2021 to Nov 2022, QQQ and BND 77.7% 30.9% 27.5% $70,328

Source: Trefis analysis of Intrinio adjusted closing prices, with dividends reinvested. Stocks are SPY, or QQQ in the last row. Bonds are AGG for 2007-09 and BND after. Each mix started at 60/40 three years before the top.

The result is plain. In all 3 S&P 500 falls with bond data, the untouched mix fell more than the reset one. The saving ranged from $22,115 to $54,971 per $1 million. The 2000-02 fall, when SPY lost 47.5%, cannot be tested. Our price data has no bond fund before AGG’s first day in Sep 2003.

Does a tech-heavy mix drift further?

Today, it does not drift much further. A 60/40 in QQQ, the Nasdaq-100 fund, and BND started three years ago is 69.4% stocks. Started five years ago, it is 71.5% stocks. That is close to the VOO version.

The gap shows at tops. Into the 2022 top, the QQQ mix had drifted to 77.7% stocks. Resetting it that day saved $70,328 by the low. Single stocks inside these funds can swing far more. Nvidia has lost 39.0% since its Oct 6 record close.

Does re-balancing always leave you with more money?

No. Over the long run, letting stocks run has paid more. A $1 million SPY and AGG mix started at the end of 2003 shows it. Reset every year-end, it is worth $5,589,175 today. Never reset, it is worth $6,628,586, with stocks grown to 88.2%.

The worst fall was about the same for both. The yearly-reset mix fell 33.6% at its worst, and the untouched one fell 34.0%. At the Mar 9, 2009 low, the two were level, within $534 of each other. In 2022, a 60/40 VOO and BND mix still fell 16.1%. For what a repeat would mean, see Will 2027 Be A 2022 Repeat For Stocks?

Our read: re-balancing does not add return. It keeps the risk you chose. A 60/40 owner whose mix is now 68.7% stocks carries more risk than planned.

What can an owner of a stock and bond mix do this week?

  • Check your own stock share against your target, using Thursday’s close.
  • Send new savings or bond income to the bond side first, which narrows the gap without selling.
  • If you sell stocks to reset, know that in a taxable account a sale can bring a tax bill. A tax adviser can help with that.

The risk of resetting is plain too. If stocks rebound fast, the reset mix gains less than the untouched one. This piece is part of our series on whether the classic stock and bond mix still works.

On Oct 6, the record close gave no warning of the fall that followed. A mix you reset on a schedule does not need you to see the next one coming. It keeps you near the risk you chose, though in our yearly test its worst fall was about the same as the untouched mix.

Stop Guessing. Start Positioning.

No one can predict surprises like this one. The Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio doesn’t try: it holds 30 quality stocks in equal weight, so no single surprise decides your result. Come see how it works.

See How HQ Works

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.