Treasuries Are Starting to Hedge Stocks Again. It May Not Last
Today’s big story: Will 2027 Be A 2022 Repeat For Stocks?
Investors have long leaned on one simple rule. When stocks fall, Treasury bonds rise. That rule is why a 60/40 fund, with 60% in stocks and 40% in bonds, is meant to fall less than the stock market. Since 2022 the rule has mostly failed. In the past six weeks, bonds have started to rise on bad days for stocks again, at least on the shorter measures. Long Treasuries (TLT) returned 4.6% from Oct. 5 to Nov. 19. The S&P 500 ETF (SPY) lost about 8% over the same stretch. Both figures are total returns. The hedge may be coming back, but the same turn has reversed before, and the data do not yet show it will hold.
Long bonds gained while stocks fell over those six weeks. When one part of your savings rises as another sinks, a bad stretch is easier to sit through without selling near the bottom. The Trefis Income Solution fell less than the S&P 500 in each of the 9 big sell-offs since 2018, and it pays a dividend yield about 3 times the S&P 500’s. See how it held up.
When Bonds Did Their Job
Correlation measures how two prices move day to day. It runs from +1, when they always move together, to -1, when they always move in opposite directions. Zero means no link. For a hedge, you want a negative number.
For years, bonds delivered one. From 2015 through 2020, the 21-day correlation between the S&P 500 ETF and the long Treasury ETF averaged between -0.24 and -0.44 each year.
The 7- to 10-year Treasury ETF (IEF) told the same story. Its 63-day correlation with stocks averaged between -0.34 and -0.49 each year from 2015 to 2020. That pattern made bonds the default cushion in long-term portfolios.
How the Rule Broke, and How It Is Turning
The rule failed in 2022, when the 21-day correlation averaged 0.04. It has stayed above zero every year since. This year it has averaged 0.32, the highest of any year since 2015. The 63-day correlation, which covers about three months of trading, was 0.54 at the end of May. It was still 0.49 at the end of September. In those months, a bad day for stocks was often a bad day for bonds too.
By Nov. 19 the 63-day reading had fallen to 0.06, a drop of about 0.43 since the end of September. The 21-day reading is now -0.10. That is a weak link, but bonds have tilted toward rising on bad days for stocks.
The 10-year Treasury yield fell 0.26 percentage points, from 5.31% on Oct. 5 to 5.05% on Nov. 19. Falling yields lift bond prices.
But the main gauge has not flipped. The 63-day reading for long Treasuries is still above zero. It is higher than 82% of readings over the past 20 years. Only two gauges are below zero, and only just. The 21-day reading is -0.10. The 63-day reading for 7- to 10-year Treasuries is -0.02.
Why Bonds and Stocks Moved Together
When inflation is the main worry, rising yields hurt both halves of a portfolio. Higher yields push bond prices down. They also make future company profits worth less today, so stocks fall too. That was the story for most of the years since 2022.
When growth is the main worry, money leaves stocks and moves into Treasuries. Yields fall, bond prices rise, and the two move in opposite ways. The drop in the correlation since September fits a market that has shifted from fearing inflation to fearing a slowdown. But the data here show the drop, not the reason for it.
The counter-view is strong. Core PCE inflation, the Fed’s preferred gauge, was 3.1% in the year to September. Inflation that high leaves the Fed less room to cut rates if growth slows. If inflation fears return, the old pattern could come back fast. The last turn shows how. In October 2025 the 63-day correlation fell by 0.3 or more within a month, to -0.24. Within three months it had risen 0.4 points, and a year later it was back above zero. Long Treasuries lost 8.2% over that year.
Who Is Counting on the Hedge
The main users are 60/40 funds and target-date funds, which hold more bonds as savers near retirement. Both assume bonds will soften a stock sell-off. When that cushion works, investors may need less extra return to hold stocks, which supports stock prices. When it fails, both halves of the portfolio can fall at once.
History is mixed on whether a turn like this sticks. Since 2003, there were 12 cases in which the 63-day correlation fell by 0.3 or more in a month. The current turn is one of them. The reading fell from 0.49 at the end of September to 0.18 at the end of October.
In 8 of the 11 earlier cases, the correlation was higher six months later. A year later, the median change was zero. Long Treasuries were up a year later in 6 of the 11 cases. Their results ranged from a 20.4% loss to a 26.7% gain.
Eleven cases is a small sample. The study is also not split by inflation level, so it cannot say whether such drops hold with core inflation above 3%. A 60/40 holder should not yet assume the bond half will offset the stock half.
What Protects a Portfolio Without the Hedge
If the hedge fails again, portfolios that use long bonds as their main cushion are most exposed. Some protection does not depend on this link. Short-term Treasuries lose less when yields rise. Inflation-protected Treasuries pay more when prices run hot. Cash holds its value in a sell-off. The reading to watch is the 63-day correlation. If it falls below zero and stays there for several months, the old rule is back. If it climbs back above 0.3, where it ended six of this year’s first ten months, the hedge has failed again.
No one can know whether the next sell-off will come from inflation or from a slowdown. A portfolio does not have to depend on that guess.
Stop Guessing. Start Positioning.
No one can predict surprises like this one. The Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio doesn’t try: it holds 30 quality stocks in equal weight, so no single surprise decides your result. Come see how it works.
Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.