Nvidia Stock Looks Cheap On Profit. On Cash, Less So

NVDAYTD-16.4%SPYYTD+8.2%QQQYTD+7.3%
Analyze NVDA →

Today’s big story: Could Nvidia Stock Fall 50%? Follow The Cash

More on the AI trade: our AI storyline page collects our pieces on AI stocks.

Buying a stock is buying a share of a business’s future. A multiple is just the price tag: how many dollars you pay for each dollar the business brings in over a year. A rental house that earns $20,000 a year and sells for $400,000 costs 20 times its rent. Nvidia, at Monday’s close of $156.14 (down 4.1% on the day), cost about $3.79 trillion. Over the year to July it had $303.0 billion of sales, $192.9 billion of profit and $127.0 billion of free cash flow, the cash left after capital spending. So you pay $12.50 per dollar of sales, $19.70 per dollar of profit, and $29.90 per dollar of free cash.

Image from Pixabay

Three Examples That Explain 20 Years

The stock rose while getting cheaper. At the end of 2021 investors paid $91 for each dollar of Nvidia’s profit. Since then the price is up 5.3 times, but profit is up 23.5 times, so the multiple fell to $19.70. When profit grows faster than the price, a stock gets cheaper while it climbs.

At the lows, investors paid for cash, not hope. At the December 2018 low, Nvidia cost $16.90 per dollar of profit and $23.40 per dollar of free cash. At the October 2022 low: $36.50 and $45.10. Those are the floors of Nvidia’s two most recent sell-offs, set in two very different moods.

Profit and cash usually tell the same story. Now they don’t. For most of Nvidia’s history the two multiples sat close together, because cash tracked profit. Today the cash price is 52% above the profit price, the widest such gap since 2010. Why: the last year’s profit includes $30.6 billion of gains on investments and a $51.9 billion rise in money owed by customers and in inventory, which held back cash. More in Could Nvidia Stock Fall 50%? Follow The Cash.

If you are waiting for tonight’s numbers before you buy, your cash doesn’t have to sit idle. The Trefis Income Solution holds 50 dividend stocks, each with at least 10 straight years of dividends, and its dividend yield is about 3x the S&P 500’s. See what it pays.

The Full Record

Year end Per $1 of sales Per $1 of profit Per $1 of free cash
2006 $5.10 $37.90 $29.60
2008 $1.10 $12.20 $52.60
2010 $2.50 $42.20 $42.50
2012 $1.90 $15.30 $12.80
2014 $2.40 $19.20 $15.90
2016 $11.40 $58.10 $52.70
2017 $13.50 $47.10 $46.10
2018 $6.70 $17.80 $24.60
2019 $14.50 $60.30 $39.90
2020 $22.30 $86.00 $77.80
2021 $30.80 $91.00 $104.30
2022 $12.80 $61.30 $75.60
2023 $27.50 $65.40 $70.50
2024 $29.40 $52.70 $58.80
2025 $24.40 $46.00 $59.10
Nov 16, 2026 $12.50 $19.70 $29.90

Market value (close × diluted shares) over the trailing four quarters already reported on that date, so no figure uses information investors didn’t have yet. Free cash = operating cash flow minus capital spending.

Two things stand out. The multiples move far more than the business: the price per dollar of sales went from $30.80 to $12.80 in one year, 2022, while sales grew. And the cheapest years on profit, 2008, 2012 and 2018, were times of fear, not of bad businesses; each was followed by a multi-year rise.

What Is The Other Possibility?

That cash catches up, and Nvidia is as cheap as its profit multiple says. If the third quarter Nvidia reports after today’s close shows operating cash back near profit, the cash multiple falls toward the profit multiple, and $19.70 per dollar of profit would be close to the 2018 floor. How the stock did after every past cash gap: Nvidia’s Cash Fell Far Short Of Its Profit 11 Times Before.

Which Price Will Investors Pay?

A multiple is a price for a story. On profit, Nvidia costs $19.70 a dollar, less than at any month-end since early 2019. On cash, it costs $29.90. They can’t both be the bargain. Tonight’s cash line decides which price is the real one.

Whichever price wins, it is worth asking whether your own approach depends on calling that right.

Found A Better Strategy? We’d Love To Learn.

Ours is the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio: 30 quality stocks in equal weight. Since its September 2020 launch it has returned more than 105%, ahead of a benchmark that combines the S&P 500, S&P MidCap and Russell 2000. If yours has done better, tell us about it. If not, come take a look.

See The HQ Portfolio

For education, not a recommendation to buy or sell.

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.