Nike’s Extra $5 Billion Still Leaves Sales Below 2024

NKEYTD-42.2%SPYYTD+8.2%XLYYTD-1.3%
Analyze NKE →

Nike stock fell 6.3% on Tuesday and closed at $35.85. The S&P 500 slipped 1.0% the same day. So Nike did 5.3 percentage points worse than the market. The drop came on the day Nike held its first investor day in nine years.

The headline news was a plan for 2031. Nike set three targets for fiscal 2031. It aims for about $5 billion of added revenue on top of fiscal 2027. It targets operating margins of 12% to 14% and adjusted earnings per share of $3.00 to $3.50. Nike also kept its guidance for this year. It still expects revenue to decline in the high single digits in fiscal 2027. Most coverage has focused on the targets. This article looks at margins and price, measured against Nike’s own record.

Here is our answer to why the stock fell. Start from analysts’ average revenue estimate for fiscal 2027 and add Nike’s $5 billion. That gives about $47.8 billion of sales in fiscal 2031. It is 6.9% less than Nike sold in fiscal 2024. Even if the plan works, fiscal 2031 sales would stay below fiscal 2024 sales. We think that is the plainest reading of Tuesday. This is mainly a plan to rebuild profit margins, not to return sales to their old high.

A Profit Plan More Than A Sales Plan

That implied $47.8 billion is also 8.3% below analysts’ average revenue estimate for fiscal 2031. Those estimates may not reflect the plan yet.

The profit side carries more weight. Nike expects its cost program, called Pace, to save about $2.5 billion a year by fiscal 2031. Margins of 12% to 14% on $47.8 billion of sales would mean operating profit of about $5.7 billion to $6.7 billion. Nike’s peak operating profit, in fiscal 2021, was $6.9 billion. That comparison mixes Nike’s own margin definition with standard accounting figures, so treat it as a rough guide.

Is The Margin Target A Stretch For Nike?

Not by much, given Nike’s history. From fiscal 2016 to fiscal 2026, Nike’s operating margin was 12% or higher in 7 of 11 years. Operating margin is the share of sales left after running costs. It averaged 11.8% over that period.

The problem is the starting point. In the 12 months to Aug 31, 2026, Nike’s operating margin was 8.2%. Reaching the low end of the target takes 3.8 more percentage points. Nike measures its target its own way, so the gap is approximate. For fiscal 2027, Nike guides to an adjusted operating margin of about 6%. So the climb may start from even lower.

Gross margin is the share of sales left after the cost of making the goods. Nike names gross margin expansion as one of the drivers of its target. Over the last 12 months it was 43.1%. From fiscal 2016 to fiscal 2026 it ranged from 42.7% to 46.2%. So it sits close to the bottom of its own range. Revenue in the three months to August fell 4.3% from a year earlier.

Fiscal year end Operating margin Price to sales
2019 12.2% 3.19x
2021 15.6% 4.93x
2023 11.5% 3.23x
2024 12.3% 2.83x
2025 8.0% 1.95x
2026 8.2% 1.48x
Now (last 12 months) 8.2% 1.16x

How Much Is Already In The Price?

By one simple measure, the price already reflects a lot of the bad news. Price to sales compares a company’s market value with its yearly revenue. Nike now trades at 1.2 times its sales. That is below every fiscal year end shown in the table. Over those years the figure ranged from 1.5 times to 4.9 times. The stock is about 41% lower than a year ago. It sits 45.7% below its 52-week high.

Earnings tell a split story. At Tuesday’s close, Nike trades at 28.7 times the midpoint of its fiscal 2027 earnings guidance. It trades at 11.0 times the midpoint of its fiscal 2031 target. We think the price reflects the long wait more than doubt about the end point.

Lululemon is a useful check. Its operating margin over the last 12 months was 17.8%, and its gross margin was 56.1%. Those are far above Nike’s. Yet Lululemon trades at 1.1 times sales, a little below Nike. A low sales multiple alone does not prove a stock is cheap.

There is a bull case in the numbers too. The $3.25 midpoint of Nike’s 2031 earnings target is 11.7% above analysts’ average estimate for that year. If Nike hits it, the stock looks cheap on those earnings. But that midpoint is still 12.9% below the $3.73 per share Nike earned in fiscal 2024. That comparison sets an adjusted target against a standard accounting result.

What A Nike Owner Can Watch

A falling price tells you what other investors think. A change in the business tells you about the company. Owners should judge Nike by the business, not the price. Our Nov 5 look, What Is Really Behind Nike Stock’s Run?, found that part of Nike’s sales decline is planned. Tuesday’s guidance keeps that decline going through fiscal 2027.

The number to watch is gross margin. If it climbs off 43.1% in the next few quarterly reports, the margin plan has a base. If it stays near the bottom of its range, the 12% goal gets harder. For how Nike’s price compares with its peers, see whether you are overpaying for Nike versus its rivals.

Nike’s owners are now asked to wait years for margins to come back, and the stock has already fallen hard on the way. That kind of wait is easier to sit through when the rest of what you own does not drop as far as the market does.

Could You Hold On Through The Next Fall?

Holding on is easier when your portfolio falls less than the market. For every dollar its benchmark lost, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio lost about 81 cents on average, holding 30 quality stocks in equal weight.

See How HQ Held Up

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.