Should You Be Worried About Meta Stock?
For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.
Meta Platforms (META) grew revenue 26% from a year earlier in its September quarter, to $64.6 billion. Yet its operating income fell 37% from the same quarter a year earlier. The apps were not the weak spot, with 3.64 billion people using them each day. Something other than weak sales cost Meta that profit, and the bill may not be finished. So what turned a 26% rise in sales into a fall in profit, and is it over?

Meta Is Paying Billions Over Legal Cases
The answer sits in the courts. Meta booked a $9.9 billion charge in the September quarter for its August 2026 agreement with attorneys general in several states. Management said on the October 21, 2026 call that without that charge, operating income would have risen 11% from a year earlier.
The courts have not finished with Meta. A jury in Santa Fe found Meta liable for misleading New Mexico’s citizens about how it safeguards and collects user data, and the presiding judge subsequently ordered Meta to pay $25 billion in civil penalties, a ruling Meta plans to appeal. Management also said Meta has a number of youth-related trials scheduled in the coming months in the United States, and that active legal and regulatory matters could significantly impact its business and financial results. So the threat is not one settled bill but a run of cases still to come.
How Much Of Meta Do These Cases Touch?
The New Mexico case is about how Meta handles its users’ data, and the apps that hold that data bring in nearly all of Meta’s sales: 98.9% of its fiscal 2025 revenue came from its Family of Apps segment, home to Facebook and Instagram. That segment is still growing fast. Its sales rose 22.4% to $199 billion in fiscal 2025, and climbed another 26% from a year earlier in the September quarter.
Against that, the bills are large. The New Mexico penalty alone equals about a third of the $75.2 billion Meta earned over the twelve months to September 2026.
Meta stock has already come down from its peak. At $641.69 on November 13, 2026, the shares were 17.5% below their September 24 high. It trades at 21.8 times earnings, about the S&P 500’s 21.9. Yet over the past three years Meta’s revenue grew an average of 24.0% a year, against 6.5% for the S&P 500, so Meta is valued at about the market’s multiple despite that faster growth.
Meta’s Legal Risk Is Still Unfolding
For a holder, the legal threat looks real and is not over. It arrives as large, separate bills, while the apps behind nearly all of Meta’s sales keep growing. Management still expects 2026 operating income to come in above 2025’s once the September-quarter legal charge is left out, a forecast for the full year rather than a result. It is not clear whether that forecast counts the New Mexico penalty. The youth-related trials set for the coming months are the next cases to land.
Meta’s legal-related costs, which management named among the main reasons its expenses grew, are the figure to watch when Meta reports again, expected in January 2027.
Is One Stock Too Big A Part Of Your Portfolio?
A fall in any one stock hurts most when that position carries too much weight. Bring that question to a free 30-minute call with our partner advisory firm, by phone or video, with no obligation.
Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.