2-Year Bets on Hikes. Fed Funds Higher 6 Months Later: 5 of 16
For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.
The 2-year Treasury yield rose 0.40 percentage points in one week, from 4.46% on Nov. 5 to 4.86% on Nov. 12. That left it 0.98 percentage points above the effective fed funds rate, a gap wider than on 96% of days in the past 20 years. Since the 2-year roughly tracks the policy rate investors expect over two years, plus some term premium, that gap is mostly a bet on more than one hike. History says to hold it loosely: after past jumps like this, fed funds were higher six months later in only 5 of 16 cases.
What The 2-Year Did Next, And What The Fed Did
Since 1990 there have been 16 earlier weeks when the 2-year rose 0.35 percentage points or more, spaced at least 180 days apart. That is a small sample, so read what follows as odds, not a forecast.
Three months after the jump, the 2-year was higher in 10 of 16 cases, with a median change of 0.3 percentage points. By six months the edge was gone: it was higher in 8 of 16, with a median change of minus 0.1 percentage point.
Fed funds mostly did not follow. They were higher three months later in 7 of 16 cases and six months later in only 5 of 16, with a median six-month change of minus 0.2 percentage points.
The two outcomes are tied together. In the five cases where fed funds were higher six months on (1994, 2000, 2023 and twice in 2022), the 2-year was also higher six months on in four. In the 11 cases where fed funds were not higher, the 2-year was lower six months on in seven. Six months out, the 2-year’s gain has held mainly when fed funds actually rose.
And when the Fed delivered, it did so early. In all five of those cases, fed funds were already at least 0.2 percentage points higher after three months. In none of the other 11 had they risen by even 0.1 percentage point at that mark.
The Market Is Betting On A Fed That Wins
Other prices say traders expect hikes to work, not inflation to run away. The 5-year, 5-year forward inflation expectation fell from 2.33% on Oct. 13 to 2.18% on Nov. 13. The gap between the 10-year and 2-year yields narrowed from 0.48 percentage points on Aug. 13 to 0.27 on Nov. 13. That is what pricing a tighter Fed and lower inflation later looks like.
Why This Time Could Be One Of The Five
The case for the market is real. Core PCE inflation, the Fed’s own gauge, was 3.12% in the year to September, up from 2.82% a year earlier, and it has been at or above 3% in most months of 2026. September’s average fed funds rate minus core PCE, the real policy rate, was only 0.63 percentage points: not much restraint for inflation above 3%.
The labor market shows no strain that would hold the Fed back. Unemployment was 4.1% in October, and the Sahm-style gap (the 3-month average of unemployment minus its low of the prior year, where 0.5 or more has marked past recessions) was zero. Wage growth was 3.12% in the year to October, matching core PCE’s September pace.
The base rate also mixes cycles. In seven of the 11 cases where fed funds were not higher six months on, they were lower by about 0.5 percentage points or more, as in 2001 and 2008: those jumps came ahead of Fed cuts. On Nov. 14, the Fed’s Collins said gradual rate hikes are the best way to manage economic risks. And the 3-month bill yield was 0.44 percentage points above fed funds on Nov. 12, a 98th-percentile gap, so bills price a move soon.
Put together, the base rate is that fed funds were higher six months after a jump in 5 of 16 cases. This time differs only if rising core PCE and an unstrained labor market push the Fed to act, which is exactly what the 2-year is pricing. Until fed funds move, history makes the hikes less certain than a 0.98 percentage point gap suggests.
Who Is Exposed Either Way
| Holding | If the market is right (fed funds rise) | If the base rate holds (fed funds do not rise) |
|---|---|---|
| Money-market funds and short-term Treasuries (SHY) | Cash yields climb with fed funds; short bonds already held take further small price losses | Cash yields stay near today’s fed funds; short bonds gain if the 2-year falls back, as it did in seven of the 11 past cases without a Fed rise |
| Homebuilders | The homebuilder ETF ITB fell 2.61% in the week to Nov. 13 as hike bets rose; that pressure stays | The pressure from hike bets fades |
| Regional banks (KRE) | Higher short-term funding costs while the 10-year to 2-year gap is only 0.27 percentage points | Funding pressure eases and the flat curve has room to steepen |
What Will Settle It
The Fed meets on Dec. 9. History’s tell is speed: in every past case where fed funds were higher six months after a jump, they were already up by the three-month mark, which this time falls in mid-February. A hike by then would put today with the five early-move cases, when the 2-year kept its gains in four. No move would put it with the misses, after which the 2-year was lower six months on in seven of 11. A core PCE reading above September’s 3.12% would strengthen the market’s case. And as long as the 3-month bill stays about 0.44 percentage points above fed funds, bills are still pricing a hike soon.
How Would Your Portfolio Handle A Shock Like This?
Macro shocks do not announce themselves, and the time to look at a portfolio is before the next one, not after. Our Boston-based partner firm Empirical Asset Management, an SEC-registered investment adviser, offers a free portfolio review for investors with $1 million or more. It covers how your portfolio would have fared in 2008 and 2022, and any concentrated positions.
Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.