Why GM Stock’s Gains Under Barra Outran Its Profit
Today’s big story: Could Anthropic Stock Fall 25%?
General Motors may be heading for a new CEO. The Wall Street Journal reported on Tuesday, Nov 17, that GM is seeking outside candidates to succeed Mary Barra. GM itself has not announced a succession. Its stock fell 2.3% on Wednesday to close at $82.13.
This article looks back at what her years as CEO paid shareholders, per share. From the Jan 14, 2014 close, at the start of her years as CEO, GM stock returned 177% with dividends reinvested. That is 8.3% a year.
Much of that gain per share came from a shrinking share count, not from bigger profits. GM’s net income to common shareholders was 15.6% lower in 2025 than in 2013. Yet its earnings per share, or EPS, rose 37.4%. EPS is profit divided by the number of shares. The diluted share count, which includes shares that options could add, fell 41.9%. GM’s 2013 diluted EPS used a slightly higher profit figure than net income to common, so these three changes do not divide exactly.
How did GM stock do against Ford, Tesla and the S&P 500?
GM beat its old rival Ford but trailed the market and Tesla. A dollar in GM on Jan 14, 2014 grew to $2.77 by Wednesday. The same dollar in the SPY fund, which tracks the S&P 500, grew to $4.92. The index returned 13.2% a year.
GM owners earned 8.3% a year against the index’s 13.2%. Over a long hold, what an owner earns also depends on staying invested through the drops. Holding on is easier when your portfolio falls less than the market. For every dollar its benchmark lost, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio lost about 81 cents on average. See the HQ record.
The table below shows the total return of each stock over the same window, with dividends reinvested.
| Stock | Total return since January 2014 | Per year |
|---|---|---|
| General Motors | 177% | 8.26% |
| Ford Motor | 33.7% | 2.29% |
| Tesla | 3,469.1% | 32.09% |
| S&P 500 (SPY) | 391.9% | 13.21% |
Source: Trefis analysis of Intrinio closing prices. Returns run from the Jan 14, 2014 close to the Nov 18, 2026 close. Dividends are reinvested. Tesla paid no dividends.
Ford Motor returned 33.7%, about a fifth of GM’s gain. Tesla returned 3,469.1%. Tesla was a very different bet on growth, so we set it aside here. For the head-to-head with Ford, see Ford Or GM Stock? The S&P 500 Beat Both.
How much of GM’s per-share gain came from buybacks?
A buyback is when a company uses its cash to buy its own shares. Fewer shares means each one gets a larger slice of profit. GM spent $40.7 billion on buybacks from 2014 to 2025. That equals 52.2% of its net income to common over those years.
Most of that money went out late in her tenure. GM spent 59.5% of the total in 2023 to 2025. Morningstar shows no buyback figure for 2020 and 2021, so the total above leaves those two years out. Barra said on the Oct 20 earnings call that GM has cut its fully diluted shares by 37% since 2023.
A simple test shows the effect. Take GM’s 2025 net income to common and spread it over the 2013 share count. That gives about $1.90 a share. GM reported diluted EPS of $3.27. The gap is what the smaller share count did.
Profit did grow in strong years. In 2023, net income to common was 165.8% above 2013. EPS that year was 207.6% higher. So the buybacks added to real profit growth in 2023. In 2025 they cushioned a weaker year.
Ford took a different path in recent years. Over the five years from 2020 to 2025, its diluted share count rose 0.15%. GM’s fell 32.5% over the same years.
Is GM still shrinking its share count in 2026?
Yes, and at a fast pace. In the first nine months of 2026, net income to common rose 10.7% from a year earlier. Diluted EPS rose 19.6%. The diluted share count fell 7.3%.
GM bought back $5.3 billion of stock in the first nine months. The chief financial officer said another $1 billion in October took the 2026 total to $6.3 billion. On Oct 20, GM’s board approved a new $20 billion buyback program spread over several years. The CFO called it more than 25% of GM’s market value.
Can GM afford it? Morningstar’s free cash flow for GM was negative in every year from 2014 to 2024. It turned positive in 2025, at $1.77 billion. That figure counts GM Financial’s purchases of cars it leases out as spending. GM uses a different measure, adjusted automotive free cash flow. It guides that measure to $11.5 billion to $12.5 billion for 2026. For what GM is worth on future earnings, see Why GM Looks Far Cheaper Than Tesla On 2030.
What does this mean for a GM owner now?
Our read: Barra’s years paid shareholders mostly through a smaller share count. Total profit in 2025 was below 2013. Profit per share was well above it. That is a real return to owners, but it is not the same as a bigger business.
The next CEO inherits a $20 billion buyback program. If profit grows, buybacks multiply that growth per share. If profit stalls, the risk is that buybacks carry more of the load. Watch net income to common, not only EPS, in the next few reports.
GM had a clear plan for its cash, and it lifted profit per share. Even so, a plain index fund did better over the same years. Every strategy deserves that test, ours included, and we are always glad to hear of a better one.
Found A Better Strategy? We’d Love To Learn.
Ours is the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio: 30 quality stocks in equal weight. Since its September 2020 launch it has returned more than 105%, ahead of a benchmark that combines the S&P 500, S&P MidCap and Russell 2000. If yours has done better, tell us about it. If not, come take a look.
For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.