Does Gold Protect You When Stocks Fall?
Today’s big story: Will 2027 Be A 2022 Repeat For Stocks?
$1 million put in GLD, the SPDR Gold Shares fund, at the Nov 17, 2006 close was worth $5,425,380 at the Nov 19, 2026 close. That is a gain of 8.8% a year over 20 years. The same money in SPY, a fund that tracks the S&P 500, did better with dividends reinvested. It grew to $7,347,667.
Many investors see gold as the place to hide when stocks fall. The record shows it is not a reliable one. In the 17 falls of 10% or more in the S&P 500 since GLD began trading in Nov 2004, gold rose in 9 and fell in 8. In the five deepest falls, of 20% or more, it rose only once.
This week, gold fell along with stocks. GLD fell 1.8% on Thursday, Nov 19, after a 3.2% drop on Wednesday. The S&P 500 fell 2.0% on Thursday. Our data does not show why gold fell.

How did gold compare with stocks since 2006?
GLD has never paid a distribution, so its price return is its whole return. On price alone, gold beat the stock fund. SPY without dividends turned $1 million into $5,098,063.
Dividends put the stock fund ahead. With them, SPY grew 10.5% a year, against gold’s 8.8%.
The peak came this year. At GLD’s record close on Jan 29, 2026, the 2006 holding was worth $8,026,870. GLD now sits 32.4% below that record.
The $1 million GLD holding has shrunk from $8,026,870 in January to $5,425,380 now. If gold is meant to be the steady part of your savings, that is a hard drop to sit through. The Trefis Income Solution fell less than the S&P 500 in each of the 9 big sell-offs since 2018, and it pays a dividend yield about 3 times the S&P 500’s. See how it held up.
Did gold rise when stocks fell?
The table lists all 17 S&P 500 falls of 10% or more since GLD began. It adds GLD and BND, a broad U.S. bond fund, over the same dates.
| S&P 500 fall | S&P 500 | GLD | BND |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 2007 to Mar 2008 | -18.64% | +31.17% | +4.37% |
| May to Oct 2008 | -36.97% | -6.90% | -7.93% |
| Oct 13 to 27, 2008 | -15.39% | -11.96% | +1.14% |
| Nov 4 to 20, 2008 | -25.19% | -2.69% | +0.98% |
| Jan to Mar 2009 | -27.62% | +6.39% | -1.76% |
| Apr to Jul 2010 | -15.99% | +4.68% | +3.18% |
| Apr to Oct 2011 | -19.39% | +5.64% | +5.43% |
| May to Aug 2015 | -12.35% | -5.64% | +0.17% |
| Nov 2015 to Feb 2016 | -13.31% | +11.29% | +1.88% |
| Jan to Feb 2018 | -10.16% | -2.41% | -1.06% |
| Sep to Dec 2018 | -19.78% | +5.03% | +1.33% |
| Feb to Mar 2020 | -33.92% | -3.62% | -1.43% |
| Jan to Mar 2022 | -13.05% | +13.77% | -3.37% |
| Mar to Jun 2022 | -20.83% | -3.60% | -5.72% |
| Aug to Oct 2022 | -16.91% | -5.70% | -6.90% |
| Jul to Oct 2023 | -10.28% | +2.08% | -4.34% |
| Feb to Apr 2025 | -18.90% | +1.61% | +0.84% |
Source: Trefis analysis of Intrinio daily closes, Nov 18, 2004 to Nov 19, 2026. A fall runs from an S&P 500 peak close to its lowest close before the index rises 10% off that low. Only falls of 10% or more count. GLD uses closes. BND uses closes with distributions reinvested.
Gold’s best stretch came in the first fall. From Oct 2007 to Mar 2008, GLD gained 31.2% while the S&P 500 lost 18.6%. Its worst came over two weeks in Oct 2008. GLD fell 12.0% as the index fell 15.4%.
The typical move was small. GLD’s median move across the 17 falls was a gain of 1.6%. In the 2020 crash and in spring 2022, gold fell along with stocks.
Bonds did no better on the count. BND also rose in 9 of the 17 falls. In 2022, BND fell in all three falls, while GLD rose in one and fell in two. Our piece “Will 2027 Be A 2022 Repeat For Stocks?” looks at the stock side of that year.
Does the count change if falls start at record highs?
Measured from S&P 500 record closes, there were 7 falls of 10% or more since Nov 2004. GLD rose in 4 of them. Across the whole 2007 to 2009 bear market, the long slide in stocks, it gained 23.9%.
On either count, gold rose in a little over half of the stock falls.
How bad was gold’s own worst fall?
Gold has deep falls of its own. GLD dropped 45.6% from its Aug 22, 2011 close to its Dec 17, 2015 close. $1 million put in at that 2011 high was worth about $544,450 at the low.
The wait was longer than the fall. GLD did not close back above its 2011 high until Jul 29, 2020. That is 8.9 years under water, meaning below the old high. SPY’s worst fall was deeper, at 55.2% with dividends from Oct 2007 to Mar 2009. But SPY was back above its high by Aug 2012.
Gold swings hard from year to year. GLD rose 63.7% in 2025. It is down 15.4% in 2026 through Nov 19. It fell in 6 of the 21 full calendar years from 2005 to 2025. Its worst year was 2013, when it fell 28.3%.
Is gold rising in the current stock slide?
No. The S&P 500 closed 8.2% below its Oct 6 record on Nov 19. That is not yet a 10% fall. GLD fell 12.3% over the same span. BND rose 1.6%.
What does this mean for a portfolio that holds gold?
Our read: gold paid off over 20 years, but it was not a reliable shield in stock falls. It turned $1 million into $5,425,380. It rose in only about half of the big stock falls, and it had a 45.6% fall of its own.
We think gold works best as a separate source of returns, not as a promise of gains when stocks drop. This piece is part of our series on mixing stocks, bonds and other assets. How much gold to hold is its own question. Our earlier piece answers how much gold a portfolio should own.
Gold climbed in some stock falls and dropped in others, and the record gave no clue ahead of time which one was coming. A mix that holds up without anyone calling the next surprise is the sturdier plan.
Stop Guessing. Start Positioning.
No one can predict surprises like this one. The Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio doesn’t try: it holds 30 quality stocks in equal weight, so no single surprise decides your result. Come see how it works.
For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.