Why Is Everyone Ignoring Fair Isaac Stock’s High Cash Yield?

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.

Fair Isaac (FICO) stock yields 6.0% in free cash flow, compared with 4.3% for the median S&P 500 company. Such a high yield usually points to a bargain, or to a company whose sales investors expect to shrink. Shares of Fair Isaac lost 54.6% over the past year. So why are buyers paying so little for Fair Isaac’s cash? The reason becomes easier to judge once you understand how the company makes its cash.

What Fair Isaac’s Cash Yield Means For You

As a Fair Isaac shareholder, you own a slice of the free cash the business produces, regardless of whether it is paid out. Cash retained by the company still belongs to its owners. When investors recognize it, they tend to pay more for the shares, more so when the cash is growing.

How Fair Isaac Makes Its Cash

Fair Isaac earns its money in two businesses: Scores, which sells the FICO Score to lenders, and Software, which sells the FICO Platform and other software. Operating margin reached 52.1% over the twelve months to June 2026, up from 45.9% a year earlier. The company spent only 4.1% of its operating cash flow on capital spending, and free cash flow came to 40.1% of revenue.

Free cash flow reached $961 million, up from $446 million three years earlier, and was higher at each June in between. Total debt, though, doubled to $5.6 billion at the end of June 2026, from $2.8 billion a year earlier. The company spent $3.59 billion buying back its own shares over that year. Management said a $1.5 billion term loan taken in June paid for an accelerated buyback. Net debt, or what the company owes minus its cash, equals 33.2% of its market value, so part of the cash must serve lenders before it is the owners’. On market value plus net debt, the yield is 4.5%. Operating income covered interest expense by 6.7 times over the same twelve months.

Fair Isaac’s sales were not yet falling. Revenue grew 24.1% over the twelve months to June 2026, compared with 16.7% a year earlier.

Why Investors Worry About Fair Isaac’s Mortgage Scores

Investors appear to worry about Fair Isaac’s mortgage scores. The director of the Federal Housing Finance Agency said on September 29, 2026, that the mortgage pricing grid was being simplified and that VantageScore, another credit score, was being incorporated. Fair Isaac stock fell 27% that day.

Mortgage origination revenues made up 62% of Scores revenue in fiscal Q3 2026, management said. These revenues rose 97% from a year earlier, while mortgage volumes grew only by a low single digit. Management credited the growth in scores sold to businesses mainly to a higher price per mortgage score. Fair Isaac’s share price appears to assume that a simpler grid incorporating VantageScore will leave the company selling fewer mortgage scores, or selling them for less.

None of this shows in reported results yet. Management raised its fiscal 2026 revenue forecast to $2.53 billion in July, two months before the announcement, and said it was not seeing volume loss from lenders’ choice of score. The company’s new direct license program for mortgage scores was then still waiting on certification from one of the government-sponsored enterprises, or GSEs.

What To Watch At Fair Isaac’s Next Report

Fair Isaac’s owners still need to know whether free cash flow keeps growing now that the mortgage pricing grid is being simplified, and whether that cash keeps covering a debt load that doubled in a year. The company is expected to report its next results in November 2026. It will be the first report since the company said on October 6 that it would cut about 15% of its workforce. Free cash flow and total debt in that report, and in the reports after it, are the figures to watch.

What Would Another Fall In Fair Isaac Do To Your Plan?

A fall hurts most when one stock is a large part of what you own, and selling it to spread the risk can bring a large tax bill. Our partner advisory firm offers a free strategy review of ways to put a floor under a large position and unwind it with less tax.

Request A Free Strategy Review

Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.