Is Carvana Stock Really Expensive?

CVNAYTD-14.3%SPYYTD+11.5%XLYYTD+1.1%
Analyze CVNA →

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.

Carvana (CVNA) stock trades at 28.6 times its adjusted earnings over the last twelve months. Those earnings are counted as normalized net income plus stock-based pay after tax. That is a steep price for a used-car retailer that was posting a twelve-month loss three years ago. Yet Carvana’s revenue grew 50.3% over those twelve months, and its price can also be read against the profit forecast for fiscal 2026 and fiscal 2027. So what are you actually paying for the profit still to come?

Image from Pixabay

What You Pay For Carvana’s Forecast Profit

Carvana stock looks more expensive on the fiscal 2026 forecast than on trailing earnings, and cheaper on the fiscal 2027 forecast. At the November 13 close, the stock trades at 29.9 times the consensus forecast for fiscal 2026 profit, beside 28.6 times trailing earnings. The forecast is analysts’ average estimate, and it may not count profit the same way as the trailing figure. On the forecast for fiscal 2027, the same price is 21.7 times profit. Carvana has not yet started fiscal 2027, so that last multiple is a price on profit the company still has to earn.

What Carvana Has To Deliver For That Price

The consensus forecast has Carvana’s revenue growing 26.7% in fiscal 2027, to $37.6 billion. Forecast net income grows faster, by 38.0%, meaning the forecast assumes Carvana keeps more of each sale: a net margin of 6.4% in fiscal 2027, after 5.9% in fiscal 2026.

The revenue assumption does not run ahead of what Carvana has reported: Carvana grew revenue faster than that pace over the latest twelve months. Carvana’s net margin was 6.2% over the four quarters to September 2026, but only 3.6% in fiscal Q3 2026, below both forecast years. Part of the four-quarter profit came from outside its operations.

Where Carvana Could Fall Short Of The Forecast

The net margin is the likelier place for the consensus to miss. In fiscal Q4 2025, Carvana generated net income of $857 million on $424 million of operating income, indicating that part of its fiscal 2025 profit came from outside its operations. Its latest quarter also came in under the consensus, with earnings of $0.39 per share for fiscal Q3 2026 against an estimate of $0.47. If Carvana’s margin falls short, its fiscal 2027 profit will be lower than the forecast.

Sales growth is the second place. Management said on the October 28 call that Carvana’s growth is limited by how fast it can scale its supply chain, noting that the number of cars ready to buy on its website was growing much more slowly than sales. If its reconditioning centers cannot keep up, Carvana’s fiscal 2027 revenue will fall short of the consensus figure. Carvana is expected to report its fiscal Q4 2026 results in February 2027.

If Carvana delivers the consensus forecast, the forecast multiples are a fair picture of what you pay for Carvana stock. The likeliest shortfall is in the net margin. If it comes, Carvana stock is a riskier bet, because you would be paying for profit the company did not earn. Carvana’s net margin in that February report is the measure to watch.

Not Sure Carvana Is Worth It At This Price?

You don’t have to bet on one stock to earn. The Trefis Income Solution owns 50 dividend stocks that yield about 3x the S&P 500, each with at least 10 straight years of dividends.

See If It Fits Your Plan

Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.