Is Casey’s Stock Paying You Enough For The Swings?
Investors holding Casey’s General Stores (CASY), one of the leading convenience store chains in the United States, alongside an S&P 500 index fund watched the company’s shares rise 7.4% in the five sessions ending October 19, 2026, while the index fell 1.5%. A single stock moving with that kind of momentum alters the balance of a portfolio, so investors want to be paid for its swings. Have those swings left you better paid than the index?
Casey’s Has Paid You Better Than The S&P 500
Yes. Casey’s generated an annualized return of 30.3% including dividends over the five years ending October 19, 2026, outpacing the 12.7% return of the S&P 500. The stock experienced an annual volatility of 29.4% over those five years, a measure of how far its price tends to swing in a year, compared with 17.0% for the index.
The company’s return per unit of volatility, calculated by dividing the annual return by the annual volatility, was 1.03, against 0.747 for the S&P 500. This metric shows the return earned for each point of price fluctuation, indicating that shareholders received better compensation for the extra swings at Casey’s than an index holder did.
Swings like this test every retirement plan. If your advisor recently retired, it is a good moment for a free second opinion from our partner firm.
How Has Casey’s Moved On The Market’s Days?
Casey’s shares rose on the market’s average day in either direction over the year ending October 19, 2026. The S&P 500 rose 0.638% on its average up day, a scenario where a $10,000 holding in Casey’s increased by about $10.30. When the index experienced its average down day with a fall of 0.592%, that same Casey’s investment still gained about $12.20.
Its swings were still wide, as Casey’s annual volatility over the past year reached 37.7%, compared with 12.7% for the index. The company recorded a beta of -0.11, measuring how far it moves for each 1% move in the index, so the direction of the S&P 500 offered little guidance on where Casey’s would go. Daily price actions were close to unrelated, registering a correlation of -0.04 on a scale where 1 indicates assets moving in lockstep. Casey’s shares experienced their own distinct fluctuations, but the stock did not compound existing market risk.
What Casey’s Business Says About The Swings Ahead
Swings resembling the price action of the past year appear likely to continue, because Casey’s fuel profits vary daily and the company is still integrating an acquisition. Management described fuel margins in fiscal Q1 2027 as volatile, with some days in the 60s of cents per gallon and others in the 30s. The company posted a fuel margin of $0.478 per gallon for the quarter, and management stated the August figure was in the low $0.40s.
Casey’s is also remodeling the Cefco stores it took over in the Fikes acquisition, a project management expects to run through the fiscal year. Sales inside the stores are steadier, with inside same-store sales rising 3.2% in fiscal Q1 2027, led by prepared food. The company’s next earnings report, expected on or around December 7, 2026, will detail its fuel margin for fiscal Q2 2027.
If the past year’s pattern holds, the market’s direction on its next up day or down day will say little about where Casey’s goes, because its swings have not followed the index. Investors already holding other fuel retailers maintain a double exposure to fuel profits, and the swings at Casey’s compound that bet rather than steady it. Casey’s fuel margin per gallon is the measure to watch at that December report.
Your Advisor Retired? Get A Second Opinion Before You Settle
A single stock like Casey’s General Stores can swing a portfolio in ways the index doesn’t. When the advisor who built your plan moves on, it is a natural moment to ask whether the plan still fits the life you have now. Our partner advisory firm offers a free review of your holdings, fees and income plan.
Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.