Barrick Grows Faster Than Its Gold Peers. Why Is It The Cheapest?

BYTD-14.8%SPYYTD+9.4%XLBYTD+15.0%
Analyze B →

Today’s big story: Could Nvidia Stock Fall 50%? Follow The Cash

Think of the gold coin a parent kept in a drawer for bad times. On Thursday, the day Nvidia announced its CEO had resigned and AI cloud stocks sank, that coin lost value too. The gold fund GLD fell 2.8% and long Treasuries (TLT) 1.5%, while the dividend fund SCHD slipped only 0.2%. Both havens had been sliding with the hot inflation report, as we wrote in S&P 500 Down On Hot CPI. Sell Or Hold?

The gold miners fell harder than gold. From the Nov 6 close to Monday, Agnico Eagle lost 10.8%, Barrick 10.0% and Newmont 8.8%, about twice as far as gold itself, which fell about 5%. The dividend fund rose 2%: cash flow was the cushion. That cushion is the idea behind the Trefis Income Solution, dividend stocks yielding about three times the S&P 500: see the Income Solution.

Barrick is the oddity among the miners. Analysts expect its sales to grow 14% in 2027, the fastest of the four biggest US-listed gold companies, yet it trades at 2.8 times sales, the cheapest. Newmont sells 23% more and is valued 93% higher.

Company Price ÷ sales Sales growth expected, 2027
Barrick 2.8x +14%
Newmont 4.4x +7%
Agnico Eagle 5.7x +3%
Wheaton (streamer) 16.6x +12%

Source: Trefis, prices through Nov 16; sales over the last four reported quarters; consensus revenue 2027 vs 2026. Wheaton buys future metal rather than mining it, so it always looks expensive on sales.

Image from Pixabay

Why Is Barrick So Cheap?

Not because the mines earn less. Barrick’s latest quarter matched Newmont’s 50% operating margin, on faster sales growth, 22% against 15%:

Q3 2026 Sales vs Q3 2025 Operating margin
Barrick +22% 50%
Newmont +15% 50%
Agnico Eagle +17% 56%

Company-reported revenue and operating income, Morningstar via Trefis.

The discount is about where Barrick digs, and a change at the top. In its Nov 9 release Barrick reported all-in costs per ounce up from both the prior quarter and a year earlier. Its big Mali mine is back under its control and ramping up, but it is paying royalties and penalties backdated under Mali’s newer mining code, and its Reko Diq copper project in Pakistan is “under review,” with spending cut. Its CEO of nearly seven years stepped down in September 2025, and an RBC analyst has said Barrick has long traded below the value of its parts, partly because of that country risk (Mining.com). Agnico Eagle, with mines in Canada, Australia, Finland and Mexico, gets the premium.

Where Do You Hide When The Havens Fall?

On Thursday the two classic havens fell together: gold 2.8% and long Treasuries 1.5%. This year the cushion has been dividend stocks, up 33.9% in 2026 while gold fell 11.0%.

Holding Thursday 2026 to Nov 16
Gold (GLD) −2.8% −11.0%
Long Treasuries (TLT) −1.5% −5.4%
Utilities (XLU) 0.0% +5.5%
Dividend stocks (SCHD) −0.2% +33.9%

Source: Trefis, prices through Nov 16. Thursday: close vs Nov 11 close; 2026: total return. GLD rose 63.7% in 2025.

Against rising rates, this year’s cushion has been cash flow, not metal. Gold still earns its place as a sized hedge. A miner is something else: a leveraged bet on the gold price, with a country and a cost line attached.

What If The Discount Is Wrong?

That is the other real possibility. Only six analysts’ 2027 forecasts sit behind Barrick’s growth number, against 12 for Newmont, and its third-quarter sales were 4% below the second’s. If Mali settles down and Barrick lists its North American mines separately, as it has planned, the gap could close on its own.

Barrick is cheap for a reason you can name: the countries, the costs and a new CEO, not the gold. Watch the Dec. 15 PPI report and Barrick’s costs per ounce next quarter.

What Should You Ask Next?

  • When gold and bonds fall together, what has held up in past years?
  • Would Barrick’s North American mines trade at Agnico Eagle’s multiple?
  • How much of your portfolio is really a bet on the gold price?

Is Your Hedge Really A Hedge?

On Thursday gold, Treasuries and the miners fell together, and the dividend fund slipped 0.2%. A hedge is only a hedge if it holds on the day you need it. Barrick may be a bargain, but it is a stock with a country attached, not a shelter.

If you still want Barrick, waiting for the costs and the countries to settle down makes sense, but the money set aside for it does not have to sit doing nothing in the meantime.

Waiting To Buy Barrick? Why Let Your Cash Sit Idle?

The right price can take months. Meanwhile, the Trefis Income Solution pays a dividend yield about 3x the S&P 500’s, from 50 stocks with at least 10 straight years of dividends. Why not choose a better approach?

See If It Fits Your Plan

For education, not a recommendation to buy or sell.

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.