Should ADP Stock Holders Look At Paychex Instead?
For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.
Automatic Data Processing (ADP) and Paychex are bought for the same thing: payroll and HR services, plus the interest they earn on funds they hold for clients. The two diverge on how they grow. ADP is adding AI tools and taking Lyric HCM into Europe, while Paychex bought Paycor and is moving clients into its PEO business. So what did each company forecast for the year at its latest report?

ADP Raised Its Forecast While Paychex Held Steady
On October 28, ADP lifted its fiscal 2027 revenue growth forecast to about 6%, up from 5.5% in July. Management also raised its forecast for client funds interest revenue by $50 million, bringing the range to $1.59 billion to $1.61 billion.
Paychex, which reported on September 23, kept its fiscal 2027 forecast for total revenue growth at 5% to 6%. Inside that total, it raised its forecast for PEO and Insurance Solutions to growth of 7% to 8%, up from its earlier forecast. Part of that strength is clients moving within Paychex: management said a client that upgrades into the PEO brings in about 3.5 times the revenue, and that revenue shifts out of its Management Solutions segment.
So the two updates are different kinds of news. ADP raised the outlook for the whole company, while Paychex raised its forecast for one segment and kept the total unchanged.
What Are ADP And Paychex Spending To Grow?
Both companies are paying for AI. ADP kept its forecast for adjusted EBIT margin expansion, management’s own measure, at 70 to 90 basis points for fiscal 2027, and said it has plenty to invest in, from AI to cloud infrastructure and its global offerings. ADP’s AI service platform reached 60% of its service staff by the end of its first fiscal quarter, up from 48% at the end of fiscal 2026.
Paychex has also stepped up its spending. Management said its AI investment in fiscal 2027 is five times its fiscal 2026 level. Even so, Paychex’s operating margin rose to 38.0% in the quarter ended August 2026, from 35.2% a year earlier. Paychex has so far paid for its AI push without giving up margin.
How Do ADP And Paychex Compare Head To Head?
Paychex comes out ahead on price and profit. Its shares trade at 23.2 times its last twelve months of earnings, compared with 27.5 times for ADP. Paychex also kept 39.2% of its twelve-month revenue as operating profit, against 26.5% at ADP.
Paychex’s revenue grew 14.0% over its last twelve months, against 6.5% at ADP, but that lead comes from earlier quarters. Paychex’s growth has slowed each quarter since the one ended February 2026. In the quarter ended August 2026, it grew 5.9%, against 6.1% for ADP in the quarter ended September 2026.
ADP comes out ahead on its balance sheet and its forecasts. ADP’s debt equals 4.2% of its market value, against 11.0% at Paychex. At their latest reports, ADP raised more of its main revenue and earnings forecasts than Paychex did.
Which Company Comes Out Ahead, And On What?
Paychex leads on more of these measures: a lower multiple, a wider operating margin, and faster twelve-month growth. ADP leads on lighter debt and a forecast that is moving up. For an ADP holder, Paychex offers more operating profit per dollar of sales at a lower price. However, its growth lead sits in quarters already behind it, while ADP’s outlook is the one rising.
The result that could tip this balance is Paychex’s revenue growth for its fiscal second quarter, which management expects at about 4% and which Paychex is expected to report in December 2026.
Splitting the measures this way is our own approach to choosing between two businesses this alike, and we would gladly hear from anyone who has found a better one.
Found A Better Strategy? We’d Love To Learn.
Ours is the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio: 30 quality stocks in equal weight. Since its September 2020 launch it has returned more than 105%, ahead of a benchmark that combines the S&P 500, S&P MidCap and Russell 2000. If yours has done better, tell us about it. If not, come take a look.
Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.