What Are American Airlines Stock Bears Missing?
For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.
American Airlines (AAL) stock returned -2.2% over the past year, against 11.7% for the S&P 500. The bears have a fair case, since the airline lost $481 million over the four quarters to September 30, 2026. The premium cabin may be what bears are missing, and American keeps adding seats there through new deliveries and retrofits. So a loss-making airline is adding more of its priciest seats. How much of American’s ticket revenue do those seats bring in?

Premium Seats Earn About Half Of American’s Ticket Revenue
Management said on its October 22, 2026 call that premium generates roughly half of American’s ticket revenue while taking up only about 30% of its seats. With a minority of seats earning half the ticket money, a premium seat brings in more, on average, than a seat in the main cabin.
In fiscal Q3 2026 the gap widened. Premium unit revenue rose 18.5% from a year earlier and beat the main cabin by more than 4 points, management said. Unit revenue rose across every cabin, the main cabin included, just more slowly.
The airline is also adding more of those seats. Management said its retrofit programs cover more than 200 aircraft across its 777, A320 and A319 fleets over the next three years.
Can American’s Revenue Growth Keep Up With Fuel?
Not in profit terms, so far. American’s revenue grew 19.3% from a year earlier in fiscal Q3 2026, but management said higher fuel added $1.9 billion to costs in that quarter and more than offset that strength in profit terms. In dollars, revenue still rose about $2.6 billion, to $16.3 billion from $13.7 billion, more than the fuel increase, so other costs rose as well. The operating margin slipped to 0.8% in fiscal Q3 2026, from 1.2% in the same quarter a year earlier.
That is the bears’ worry, and premium seats answer only part of it. They lift American’s revenue, but they do nothing about the price of jet fuel.
Management expects the fourth quarter to repeat the pattern, guiding to fourth-quarter revenue growth of 19.5% to 22.5% from a year earlier. It also expects fuel expense in that quarter to be about $2.8 billion higher than a year ago. Management said it expects meaningful margin expansion once fuel prices stabilize, but that is a forecast rather than a result.
How Much Debt Is American Carrying?
American carried $37.2 billion of total debt at the end of September 2026. That debt equals 426.3% of the company’s market value, compared with 19.6% for the S&P 500.
Management said on the October call that while the company could try different transactions to improve its debt levels, the real key to improving leverage is earnings. Premium seats lift revenue, yet the airline still lost money over its last four quarters.
American’s premium seats are still earning more than the main cabin, and the airline keeps adding them. Its revenue growth has not yet kept pace with its rising costs. American is expected to report in January 2027, and its fourth-quarter fuel expense against its revenue growth is the comparison to watch.
Not Sure American Airlines Is Worth It At This Price?
You don’t have to bet on one stock to earn. The Trefis Income Solution owns 50 companies chosen to keep paying dividends, each with at least 10 straight years of dividends, yielding about 3x the S&P 500.
Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.