Pricey Walmart Stock Falls More Often, Not Harder

WMTYTD+15.2%SPYYTD+8.2%XLPYTD+20.0%
Analyze WMT →

Walmart reports its third quarter tomorrow, Thursday, Nov 19, before the market opens. Most previews will ask what its holiday outlook says about the shopper. This article asks a narrower question. Does Walmart stock fall harder on report day when it starts out expensive?

The short answer is no, not harder. But it has fallen more often when it starts at 40 times earnings or more. Across 31 reports since Feb 2019, the link between the starting price-to-earnings multiple and the report-day move is close to zero. The biggest fall, 11.4% in May 2022, came at 30.4 times earnings, in the middle of the range. Yet the last three reports all started above 40 times earnings, and the stock fell after each one.

That matters now. Walmart closed at $127.52 on Tuesday. That is 46.0 times its earnings over the past four quarters. Only three past reports started at a higher multiple.

shopping cart
Image from Pixabay

How We Measured Each Report Day

The price-to-earnings multiple, or P/E, is the share price divided by a year of earnings per share. We used earnings per share under standard accounting rules, called GAAP, for the four quarters before each report. The report-day move runs from the close before the release to the close on report day. Walmart released all 31 reports before the market opened. Prices before the stock split on Feb 26, 2024 are divided by three.

Over the whole record, the stock fell on 16 report days and rose on 15. The average move in either direction was 3.9%. Up or down has been close to an even split.

Three Groups, Sorted By Starting Multiple

We sorted the 31 reports by starting P/E and cut them into three groups. The table shows how each group did.

Starting P/E Reports Falls Average move Average fall Worst day
21.3x to 29.4x 10 5 0.70% -2.31% -6.48%
29.5x to 40.1x 10 5 -0.35% -6.18% -11.38%
40.2x to 57.5x 11 6 -1.04% -3.79% -7.27%

August 2026 started at 40.1 times, so it falls in the middle group. The middle group had the deepest average fall, 6.2%. It includes the worst day, in May 2022. The most expensive group fell 3.8% on an average down day. By this cut, expensive starts did not produce bigger drops.

The difference shows up in the average move. The cheapest group gained 0.7% on an average report day. The most expensive group lost 1.0%. A split at 40 times earnings, which also takes in August 2026, points the same way. Reports at 40 times or more averaged a 1.7% loss. Reports below that line averaged a 0.7% gain. Above the line, the stock fell on 7 of 12 report days. Below it, the stock fell on 9 of 19.

That second cut also makes the falls look a little larger at high multiples. The average fall was 4.6% at 40 times or more and 3.7% below it. So the size of the falls depends on where you draw the line. The direction of the average move does not.

Why The 2026 Reports Stand Out

Walmart started each of its three 2026 reports above 40 times earnings. It fell 1.4% in February, 7.3% in May and 9.2% in August. The August report-day close was $103.84. Since then the stock has climbed 22.8% to Tuesday’s close. It now sits 5.4% below its 52-week closing high.

Over the same stretch, four-quarter earnings per share slipped from $2.85 to $2.77. So the higher multiple comes from the price, not from profit. On analysts’ estimates for this fiscal year, Walmart trades at 44.1 times expected earnings. Those estimates are usually on an adjusted basis that leaves out some one-off items. On either basis, the multiple is high for Walmart. An earlier piece looked at what in last quarter’s earnings may not repeat. For how that multiple compares with a fast grower, see why Nvidia is cheaper than Walmart.

What Weakens The Pattern

Three things argue against reading too much into it. First, GAAP earnings swing with one-off items. Before the Feb 2019 report, a quarterly loss cut four-quarter earnings to $0.58 a share. That pushed the starting multiple up to 57.5 times.

Second, the sample is small. Only 12 reports started at 40 times or more. A few big days can move those averages.

Third, expensive starts have also rallied. Walmart rose 4.0% in Feb 2022 from 46.7 times. It rose 3.0% in Nov 2024 from 43.7 times. The November report has gone both ways lately. The stock rose 6.5% in 2022 and fell 8.1% in 2023. It then rose again in 2024 and 6.5% in 2025.

What A Holder Can Do Before Thursday

The options market prices a move of about 6.9% either way through Friday. That figure comes from the $128 call and put that expire on Nov 20. Their combined price was $8.80, using the midpoint of the bid and ask at Tuesday’s close. It covers three trading days, with the report included. For scale, the May and August report days alone moved 7.3% and 9.2%.

If a fall of that size this week would force you to sell, the position may be too large. If you want to buy, the record gives no edge on direction. Splitting a purchase between this week and the weeks after the report spreads that risk. Our calendar of the dates that could move Walmart most shows the other events worth watching.

Other retailers set the backdrop. Target reported earlier today, Wednesday, Nov 18, before the open. Before its report, it traded at 16.6 times its four-quarter GAAP earnings. Costco trades at 53.5 times on the same basis. Our piece “Walmart Or Amazon: Which Is The Tech Stock Now?” asks a related question about what kind of company investors think they are buying.

The idea underneath is simple. A high price doesn’t decide which way a report day goes. Since 2019, it has tilted the average report day toward a loss. We would rather plan for both outcomes than guess one report day. That is the approach we stand behind. If you handle report days better, we want to hear how.

Found A Better Strategy? We’d Love To Learn.

Ours is the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio: 30 quality stocks in equal weight. Since its September 2020 launch it has returned more than 105%, ahead of a benchmark that combines the S&P 500, S&P MidCap and Russell 2000. If yours has done better, tell us about it. If not, come take a look.

See The HQ Portfolio

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.