What Would A Short Seller Say About Workday?
Today’s big story: Could Anthropic Stock Fall 25%?
If you own Workday (WDAY), the stock returned -21.1% over the past year, against 11.0% for the S&P 500. A short seller, someone betting a stock will fall, would say Workday’s growth was slowing long before the AI pricing shift that management points to.
On the August 27, 2026 call, management said many new AI products are paid for as customers use them, through flex credits. The company expects their revenue to show only “months or a year down the road.” That is a comforting story, and a short seller would test it. So is a slow payoff from AI really what is holding Workday back?
Workday shares trailed the S&P 500 by 32.1 percentage points over the past year. If much of your savings sits in this one stock, that fall comes out of your own money while you wait for AI revenue. When the market has fallen, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio has lost about 81 cents for every $1 its benchmark lost, on average. See the HQ record.

Workday’s Growth Slowed Before Its AI Pricing Shift
Workday’s revenue grew 21.4% in the four quarters to July 2022. Growth then eased to 18.4% a year later and 17.1% the year after. Revenue growth slipped to 13.9% in the four quarters to July 2025, and to 13.3% in the four quarters to July 2026. Management itself calls the flex credit model new to Workday, yet growth has eased every year since 2022.
Rivals raise a second question. Measured over each company’s own latest four quarters, ServiceNow grew revenue 21.8%. Workday did grow faster than Automatic Data Processing, Paycom Software and Paylocity, whose growth ranged from 6.5% to 10.6%. Only one of the four peers is ahead, but it is far ahead.
Management Forecasts Slower Subscription Growth At Workday
Workday’s own forecast points the same way. Subscription revenue grew 14% in fiscal Q2 2027, and management expects about 12% growth in fiscal Q3. The company’s early target for fiscal 2028 is about 11%.
Management was also open about where new business comes from. Total subscription backlog, the revenue customers have signed for but Workday has yet to report, rose 8% from a year earlier. Management said a shift toward bookings from existing customers, rather than new ones, weighed on that growth. In plain words, more of Workday’s new contracts come from companies it already serves.
Workday Spent More On Buybacks Than Free Cash Flow
Over the four quarters to July 2026, Workday bought back $5.23 billion of its shares. The company produced $2.84 billion of free cash flow in that time. Cash and short-term investments fell to $3.4 billion, from $8.19 billion a year earlier. Buybacks topped free cash flow by $2.39 billion, which covers only part of that fall. Most of the rest went to buying other companies, about $2.08 billion over the same four quarters.
Then, on October 21, 2026, Workday priced $2.5 billion of senior notes, a form of long-term borrowing. That borrowing came after July. Workday ended July with far less cash than a year earlier, and since then it has added new bonds it must pay back.
What Owners Of Workday Still Have Going For Them
Workday is far more profitable than it was. Its operating margin reached 12.0% over the four quarters to July 2026, up from 8.6% a year earlier. That was its highest twelve-month margin at any of the 40 quarter ends since fiscal 2017.
AI sales are growing fast too. Management said yearly recurring revenue from its AI products reached nearly $600 million, up more than 200% from a year earlier. And on June 30, 2026, the shares were valued at 3.0 times sales, the lowest reading over that same span. The shares have since risen 45% from the June 30 close. At the November 18, 2026 close, they were valued at 4.3 times sales, so that low is now behind them.
Management’s AI pricing point explains part of its caution about fiscal 2028. It does not explain growth that has eased every year since 2022, or a rival growing faster. Workday is expected to report fiscal Q3 2027 results on November 24, 2026. That report will show how subscription revenue growth compares with management’s guide.
One quarter’s report can swing a stock like Workday sharply, and no one can time it. Spreading your money across steady businesses can help it grow without that worry keeping you up at night.
What If You Could Grow Wealth And Still Sleep At Night?
Workday is 24% below its highest close of the past year. How has that felt? The Trefis Income Solution pays a dividend yield about 3x the S&P 500’s, and it lost less than the S&P 500 in all 9 big selloffs since 2018.
Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.