Is Steel Dynamics Stock Cheap At 17 Times Earnings?

STLDYTD+34.2%SPYYTD+9.4%XLBYTD+15.0%
Analyze STLD →

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.

Steel Dynamics (STLD) stock trades at 16.5 times earnings, compared with 22.0 for the median S&P 500 company, even though the steelmaker’s latest results look strong. With the shares down 9.5% over the past three months, Steel Dynamics is either a sound business on sale or a fairly priced one whose profits have swung sharply before. How strong is the business behind that lower multiple?

Image from Pixabay

Steel Dynamics Earns Far More Than A Year Ago

Steel Dynamics earned $1.96 billion over the four quarters to September 30, 2026, up from $1.13 billion in the twelve months before. The company’s operating margin widened by 3.8 percentage points to 12.4% over the same stretch. Steel Operations, the core segment, generated $13.4 billion of the company’s $18.2 billion of revenue in fiscal 2025. Management said the steel mills ran at 92% of capacity in fiscal Q3 2026, compared with an estimated 80% for the domestic industry.

The company is also returning cash. Management said on the October 20 call that Steel Dynamics had bought back $591 million of its stock during 2026. On November 9, 2026, the board authorized another $3.0 billion of buybacks, representing about 9% of the company’s market value at the latest close.

How Far Have Steel Dynamics’ Profits Swung Before?

Steel Dynamics’ profits have swung a long way, and buyers appear wary of that history. The company earned $4.32 billion on a 27.6% operating margin in the twelve months to September 2022, yet the stock traded at just 3.0 times those earnings. Sales then fell in the twelve months to September of 2023, 2024 and 2025. By the last of those periods, net income was about three quarters lower.

The latest year runs well above that record. Sales grew 26.0% in the twelve months to September 2026, after falling 7.7% and then 1.5% in the two twelve-month periods before. Management credited higher realized steel pricing and record steel shipments for the rise in operating income from the second quarter to the third. Even so, Steel Dynamics’ operating margin remains below the 18.9% of the median S&P 500 company, and the price appears to assume that growth this far above its recent record will not last.

Is Steel Dynamics’ Aluminum Mill Paying Off Yet?

Not yet. Aluminum Operations, the second business Steel Dynamics is building, is still small, with $474 million of revenue in fiscal 2025. That business posted an operating loss of $26 million in fiscal Q3 2026, 21% smaller than in the second quarter.

Management said a coolant problem in the hot strip mill cut output and yields for several weeks, and that the problem has been resolved. The hot strip mill had run at 75% in October up to the call, and management still expects 90% by the end of the year. Management also said an operating profit from aluminum is unlikely for the second half of 2026 as a whole, and expects one from the first quarter of 2027 onward.

What A Buyer Is Betting On At This Price

Buying Steel Dynamics now is mostly a bet that its steel profits hold up longer than they did after 2022, with the aluminum mill as a smaller second bet. Management says about 80% of its flat-rolled steel sells on contract prices that trail the market by about two months, and it expects strong market conditions to lift fourth-quarter results and 2027. The measures to watch in the fiscal Q4 2026 report, expected in January 2027, are the steel business’s operating income and the aluminum loss.

Profits that have swung this far before put a large single holding at risk, so an owner of a big position is better off planning a way out while results are still strong.

Too Much Riding On One Stock?

If Steel Dynamics is a big part of your wealth, so are its risk and its tax bill. What’s your exit plan? Our partner advisory firm offers a free 30-minute strategy review covering a floor under losses and a lower-tax way out.

Map My Exit Options

Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.