Own P&G Stock For Safety? Watch Bond Yields

PGYTD+23.3%SPYYTD+8.2%XLPYTD+20.0%
Analyze PG →

Procter & Gamble stock has worked as a hiding place since mid-August. In the 63 trading days to Tuesday’s close, P&G rose 20.0%. Over the same days the S&P 500 fell 5.2%. The chip fund SMH fell 22.6%. So yes, P&G still hedges a tech sell-off. But the hedge now comes with a second bet attached.

Most of the talk about staples is about how pricey they look. This article looks at what a P&G holder now owns. Our price data shows a stock whose daily moves now run against chips and with Treasury bonds. That is not the same as a neutral safe place.

The key number is how P&G moves with the 10-year Treasury yield. Correlation measures how closely the daily moves of two prices go together. It runs from one (always in step) to minus one (always opposite). Over the last 63 trading days, P&G’s correlation with daily moves in the 10-year yield was -0.45. That is lower than the average of every year from 2015 to 2025. In plain words, P&G now tends to rise when yields fall. It tends to fall when yields rise.

supermarket shelves
Image from Pixabay

The Staples Rally In One Table

The staples fund XLP closed at a record $92.60 on Monday, Nov 16. P&G itself is not at a record. It closed 4.4% below its Dec 2024 high. Still, over the last 63 trading days it rose more than any other staples name in the table below.

Fund or stock Move over the last 63 trading days
Procter & Gamble +20.0%
Costco +16.4%
Coca-Cola +13.6%
Walmart +11.5%
Staples fund XLP +8.0%
PepsiCo +2.7%
Treasury bond fund IEF -2.6%
S&P 500 -5.2%
Chip fund SMH -22.6%

All moves are price only. For more on Walmart, see Pricey Walmart Stock Falls More Often, Not Harder.

A Hedge Against Chips

Start with the part that works. XLP’s 63-day correlation with the chip fund was -0.50. P&G’s was -0.44. Both are below the average of every year from 2015 to 2025. Only 2.8% of XLP’s daily readings against chips since 2015 were lower.

The link to the wider market has faded too. P&G’s correlation with the S&P 500 was -0.06. Its yearly averages from 2015 to 2025 ran from +0.04 to +0.70. For now, P&G has been moving on its own path, away from tech.

The Bond Bet Inside The Hedge

Here is the part that is easy to miss. XLP’s correlation with daily moves in the 10-year yield was -0.44. That is below every yearly average from 2015 to 2025. IEF is a fund of Treasury bonds that mature in seven to ten years. XLP’s correlation with IEF was 0.45. That is higher than 98.6% of daily readings since 2015.

So staples now trade partly like bonds. A P&G holder owns a position that leans against tech and toward falling yields. If AI stocks recover while yields rise, we think both parts of that position could work against the holder at once.

This matters for anyone who also owns bonds for safety. The two holdings may now rise and fall on the same news. Our earlier piece asked whether dividend stocks are the new bonds. The correlation data says that, for staples right now, they partly are.

What 2022 Really Showed

The usual case for P&G points to 2022. In that calendar year P&G fell 7.3%. The S&P 500 fell 19.4%. P&G’s fall was less than half the market’s.

The path inside that year tells a different story. From its Jan 5 close to its Oct 11 close, P&G fell 24.3%. The S&P 500 fell 25.4% from its 2022 peak to its low. Measured that way, P&G fell almost as far as the market. That was also a year when bonds lost money. IEF fell 16.7% in 2022. We cover that year in whether your retirement portfolio is built for 2008 or for 2022.

The Case Against This View

The strongest counter is the last 63 trading days themselves. Over those days the bond fund IEF fell 2.6%, so bond prices fell and yields rose. P&G still rose 20.0%. So the bond leg has not hurt yet. But chips fell over the same days, so the test below has not happened yet.

Bonds also still help a stock portfolio today. SPY, a fund that tracks the S&P 500, had a 63-day correlation with IEF of -0.04. Its 2026 yearly average was +0.33. A reading near zero means bonds and stocks are not moving together right now.

And these readings swing a lot. XLP’s correlation with chips has ranged from -0.67 to 0.87 since 2015. Today’s pattern may not last.

Price is the last point. P&G trades at 25.9 times its reported fiscal 2026 earnings per share. On analysts’ average estimate for fiscal 2027, it is 24.6 times, though that estimate may use adjusted earnings. That is not a cheap price for a hiding place. For what the business did last quarter, see what P&G’s latest quarter changed for its stock.

What A P&G Holder Can Watch

The test that would prove this view wrong is simple. Watch for a stretch when chip stocks rally and yields rise together. If P&G holds up then, the bond bet is weaker than the data suggests. If P&G falls, the hidden bet is real.

A useful check is P&G’s correlation with the 10-year yield. Its yearly averages from 2015 to 2025 ran from -0.22 to +0.17. A move back into that range would mean the stock is shedding its bond-like behavior.

The idea underneath is plain. A safe place is only safe against the risk you are hiding from. P&G hides you from chips. It does not hide you from rising yields.

Finding a hedge that does not carry a second bet is hard. We have an approach we stand behind. If you have found a better one, we would like to hear it.

Found A Better Strategy? We’d Love To Learn.

Ours is the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio: 30 quality stocks in equal weight. Since its September 2020 launch it has returned more than 105%, ahead of a benchmark that combines the S&P 500, S&P MidCap and Russell 2000. If yours has done better, tell us about it. If not, come take a look.

See The HQ Portfolio

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.