Nvidia Stock At $155: Cheaper Than Its 2018 Low?

NVDAYTD-16.4%SPYYTD+8.2%QQQYTD+7.3%
Analyze NVDA →

Today’s big story: Anthropic IPO: Priced For 2031, Or 2036?

Two weeks ago we asked where a 2022-size chip-stock fall would take Nvidia. That 46% fall pointed to about $129 (Nvidia Stock To $129?).

On Tuesday the stock closed at $155.46. That is 35% below its October 6 peak of $239.24. After the close, Nvidia reported its biggest quarter yet: $65.3 billion of profit on $115.8 billion of sales. Is it cheap now? We check its own history, on profit and on cash.

Image from Pixabay

Is Nvidia Cheap?

On profit, yes, by its own history. In the four quarters through the October quarter reported Tuesday, Nvidia earned $226.3 billion, or $9.31 a share. At Tuesday’s close, the stock traded at 16.7 times that profit. This ratio is the P/E: the price divided by the last four quarters’ profit per share.

At its December 24, 2018 low, after the crypto-mining boom ended, investors paid 17.0 times. No month-end since August 2013 had a P/E this low.

How Often Has Nvidia Been This Cheap?

Rarely, and not lately. We looked at 287 month-ends since December 2002. Nvidia traded at 18 times its trailing profit or less in 42 of them. Only one came after July 2015: December 2018, at 17.8. The table shows where the stock stood 12 months later.

Month-ends at P/E 18 or less Lowest P/E Stock 12 months later
Jan 2003 (1) 17.5 +116%
Feb-Jun 2008 (5) 13.5 −61% to −40%
Jul 2008-Jan 2009 (7) 8.2 +13% to +131%
Aug 2011-Oct 2013 (26) 13.2 −23% to +48%
2015 (2) 17.8 +137% to +190%
Dec 2018 (1) 17.8 +77%
Nov 17, 2026 16.7 ?

P/E here is month-end price ÷ the last four reported quarters’ profit per share, Dec 2002 to Oct 2026. The 12-month changes include dividends. The Nov 17 row uses Tuesday’s close and the four quarters to Oct 2026. Source: Trefis, prices through Nov 17.

A low P/E was not a good signal on its own. After the 42 cheap month-ends, the stock was higher a year later 31 times, with a median gain of 22%. After the other 233, it was higher 182 times, with a median gain of 52%.

A low P/E has not been a buy signal on its own. If you are waiting for a better price, your cash does not have to sit idle. The Trefis Income Solution pays a dividend yield about 3x the S&P 500’s, from 50 stocks with at least 10 straight years of dividends. See what it pays.

What decided each year was what profit and cash did next. In February 2008, Nvidia traded at 16.4 times profit. Within a year, its trailing profit went from $0.80 billion to a small loss. The stock fell 61%.

After December 2018, trailing profit fell almost by half, to $2.41 billion by October 2019. Yet the stock rose 77%. In the four quarters before that low, cash had kept pace with profit. Operating cash, the cash the business brings in, was 90% of profit.

Why The Cash Says Something Different

Over the last four quarters, Nvidia beats its 2018 low on one measure only. That measure is profit: 16.7 times against 17.0.

Trailing four quarters Dec 24, 2018 low Nov 17, 2026 close
Price ÷ profit 17.0 16.7
Price ÷ free cash 23.4 25.3
Price ÷ sales 6.4 10.4
Operating cash ÷ profit 90% 70%

All figures are for the four quarters before each date, per diluted share. Price ÷ profit is the price divided by the last four quarters’ reported profit per share, including the October quarter reported Tuesday. Measured on market value instead, as in our earlier pieces, it is 16.9 in 2018 and 16.6 now. The 2018 figures are from Trefis company data. The 2026 figures use the October quarter from Nvidia’s 8-K filing plus Trefis company data for the three quarters before. Source: Trefis, prices through Nov 17.

Free cash is the cash left after capital spending. In every cheap stretch from 2011 to 2015, the free-cash multiple sat below the profit multiple. Today it is half again higher, at 25.3. That is because only 70% of profit arrived as cash. At the 2018 cash multiple, Nvidia would be about $144, 7% below Tuesday’s close.

What If The Profit Does Not Last?

Before the report, analysts expected profit of $13.67 a share over the next four quarters. Tuesday’s price is 11.4 times that forecast. In our view, a price that low says investors doubt the profit will last. That was the bet in 2008.

In 2008 the warning sign was falling profit. Today it is collection. Customers owe Nvidia $81.0 billion for chips already delivered. That equals 64 days of sales, a level seen before only during its worst falls (Why Do Nvidia’s Customers Owe It $81 Billion?).

After those 42 cheap month-ends, the stock fell 20% or more at some point in the next year 14 times. In our view, a move of 30% either way by November 2027 would not be surprising.

Two things would change the picture. One is cash back near the 2018 pace, when 90% of profit arrived as cash. The other is a second quarter with customers owing 60 or more days of sales. That would be the 2008 path.

How To Hold Nvidia Without Betting On It

In our view, the record argues for a set size, not a bet. Keep Nvidia inside a range you set in advance, say 3% to 6% of your portfolio. Count what you own through index funds too. Name your buying price now: $144, where Nvidia would be as cheap on cash as at its 2018 low.

Nvidia is cheaper on profit than at its 2018 low and dearer on cash. Its own history says the cash will decide which past case this becomes. Buy the profit only at a price that already allows for the cash.

No one knows yet which way the cash will go. A portfolio can be built so that a surprise in one stock does not decide your result.

Stop Guessing. Start Positioning.

No one can predict surprises like this one. The Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio doesn’t try: it holds 30 quality stocks in equal weight, so no single surprise decides your result. Come see how it works.

See How HQ Works

For education, not a recommendation to buy or sell.

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.