Risky Nvidia Is Cheaper Than ‘Safe’ Walmart
Everyone knows the cast: Nvidia is the AI growth stock, and Walmart and Costco are the safe places to hide. Nvidia reports today, Tuesday, Nov 17, with its results call set for 2 p.m. Going in, the labels have swapped on one count that matters: price against next year’s earnings.
Yes, Nvidia is now far cheaper than Walmart on next year’s earnings. At Monday’s close of $156.14, Nvidia traded at 9.9 times analysts’ average estimate for its fiscal year ending January 2028. Walmart, on its matching year, traded at 39.8 times. That makes Walmart’s multiple 4.0 times Nvidia’s. Costco sat at 44.4 times its fiscal 2028 estimate.
The gap is not a rounding error. For Nvidia to carry Walmart’s multiple at Monday’s price, its fiscal 2028 earnings would have to come in 75.1% below the consensus. Even on the single lowest analyst estimate, Nvidia trades at 11.2 times.

Three Stocks, Two Stories
This is part of the larger AI story, where the market is deciding how much to pay for AI spending that may or may not last. Here is how the three stocks lined up at Monday’s close.
| Stock | P/E, current year | P/E, next year | Expected EPS growth | 2026 move |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nvidia | 16.8 | 9.9 | +69.4% | -16.3% |
| Walmart | 44.5 | 39.8 | +11.7% | +15.3% |
| Costco | 48.8 | 44.4 | +10.0% | +29.2% |
Walmart’s fiscal year ends in January, like Nvidia’s; Costco’s ends in August. Analysts’ averages come from one consensus feed that does not say whether the figures are GAAP or adjusted.
The two retailers are priced for steady earnings growth next year, 11.7% for Walmart and 10.0% for Costco, and investors have paid up for that calm. Costco closed Monday at its highest close in a year, and Walmart sat just 4.3% below its own.
Nvidia is the mirror image. Monday’s close was its lowest in 251 trading sessions, roughly a year, and 34.7% below its October 6 high close. It fell 4.1% on Monday alone, while the S&P 500 dropped 1.9%.
Why The Multiple Is So Low
A low multiple is not a bargain by itself. Nvidia’s 9.9 times rests on analysts expecting earnings per share to jump 69.4% from this fiscal year to next, from $9.30 to $15.75. The market is simply refusing to pay much for that forecast.
One reason is plain. On Nov 12, Nvidia announced that Jensen Huang had resigned as CEO, with CFO Colette Kress named interim CEO. The stock has fallen 10.1% from its Nov 11 close since then. The estimates in the table are a snapshot at Monday’s close, and we think some analysts may not yet have reworked their numbers for a change this large.
The business itself has not slowed in the reported numbers. Revenue for the quarter ended July 26 was $96.2 billion, up 105.9% from a year earlier. The company guided revenue for the quarter it reports today to $108.0 billion at the midpoint, with a gross margin of 73.5% to 74.5%. If the results and next quarter’s guide hold near that, the denominator in the P/E may stay where it is; if they fall short, the “cheap” multiple can rise overnight without the price moving at all.
It is also fair to check the comparison on numbers that have already happened. On GAAP earnings over the last four reported quarters, Nvidia traded at 19.7 times and Walmart at 46.4 times. Costco traded at 53.6 times its last fiscal year’s GAAP earnings. Those are measured differently from the forward figures, but they point the same way: Nvidia is the cheaper stock per dollar of profit, on past results and on forecasts.
Nvidia Has Been Here Before
Nvidia has traded this far below a high before. After its November 2021 peak, the slide did not stop at a third: from there it fell another 49.7% before bottoming in October 2022. That episode is not this one: today’s drop comes with a leadership change at the top and a business whose latest quarterly revenue more than doubled. It is a reminder that a stock down a third can still fall a lot further, not a forecast that it will. Our recent look at whether Nvidia stock is about to rebound goes deeper on its past recoveries.
What You Can Do Before The Numbers
- Compare, don’t chase. Put the forward P/E of what you already own next to these three. If you hold Walmart or Costco at 39.8 times and 44.4 times next year’s earnings, you are paying more for each dollar of expected profit than Nvidia costs, in exchange for steadier growth.
- Set your price first. If you want Nvidia, decide the price at which you would add before the report, and stick to it. The results can move both the price and the earnings estimates at once.
- Know the risk you are buying. The cheap multiple holds only if the 69.4% earnings growth mostly shows up. A deep cut in estimates is what would change this answer.
For the other side of the trade, see what needs to be true to buy Walmart stock now and what Costco stock bulls are not worried about.
The idea underneath is simple: the stock everyone calls risky is the cheap one, and the stocks everyone calls safe are the expensive ones. Cheap does not mean calm, and calm does not mean cheap, so what most of us really want is a way to keep growing our money without losing sleep over every report like today’s.
What If You Could Grow Wealth And Still Sleep At Night?
NVIDIA is 35% below its highest close of the past year. How has that felt? The Trefis Income Solution pays a dividend yield about 3x the S&P 500’s, and in backtests it lost less than the S&P 500 in all 9 big selloffs since 2018.
For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.