T-Bills At 4.3% Or Nvidia At A 3% Cash Yield Growing 76%?

NVDAYTD-16.1%SPYYTD+9.4%QQQYTD+8.1%
Analyze NVDA →

Today’s big story: Could Nvidia Stock Fall 50%? Follow The Cash

Here is the case the rest of this series hasn’t made. A 3-month Treasury bill yields 4.3% as of Monday, up from 4.0% a year ago: the US government’s promise to pay, as safe as money gets. Nvidia, at Monday’s close of $156.14, after a 4.1% drop on the day, is worth $3.79 trillion, and over the last year it produced $127.0 billion of free cash flow. That is a 3.3% cash yield, below the T-bill. But the T-bill’s 4.3% doesn’t grow. Nvidia’s free cash flow grew 76% in a year, on sales up 83%. Nvidia reports third-quarter results for fiscal 2027 after the close today; the figures here run to its July quarter.

Image from Pixabay

Why The Growth Case Is Strong

The yield grows into the price. If Nvidia’s free cash flow grows 40% a year for five years, about half last year’s pace, the cash it produces in year five would equal 18% of today’s price. At zero growth, it stays at 3.3%, below a T-bill, forever. The question is not today’s yield; it’s the growth.

The buyers are still spending. Microsoft, Amazon, Alphabet and Meta spent $615 billion on capital projects over their last four quarters, up 87% in a year, and their latest quarter was double the year before. Nvidia’s whole year of sales was about half that.

The comebacks are in the record. Since 2003, Nvidia has fallen 20% or more 15 times, counting this one. It regained its old high after all 14 earlier falls, typically within three months of the low, and in 13 of them it gained 50% or more within six months of the bottom. The three biggest falls and how long each took to heal are in Nvidia’s 20 Years: 3 Lessons For Today.

Every one of those comebacks started with a fall of 20% or more. Sitting through one is easier when the rest of your portfolio falls less than the market. For every dollar its benchmark lost, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio lost about 81 cents on average. See how HQ held up.

A 50% gain in six months has a data path. Analysts expect sales of about $695 billion next fiscal year. If 42% of that becomes free cash, as over the last year, and investors pay 20 times that cash, less than at any year-end after 2015, Nvidia would be worth about $5.8 trillion: $240 a share, 54% above Monday’s close.

Why The Safe Case Is Strong Too

Nobody buys at the low. From the first day Nvidia was 30% below its high, as it is now, the next six months were up in 5 of 8 past cases, and 50%-plus at some point in 4. But the stock fell a further 28% at the median first, and in 2008 a further 78%.

The buyers are stretching. Those four now put 91% of their operating cash into capital spending, up from 61% a year earlier; Amazon spent more than its operating cash. If they slow, Nvidia’s growth slows with them.

The cash isn’t keeping up with the profit. In the quarter to July, Nvidia turned 36% of its profit into free cash, and $51.9 billion of the last year’s profit sits in customers’ unpaid bills and inventory. The full downside, to as low as $80: Could Nvidia Stock Fall 50%? Follow The Cash.

Taxes favor the patient, not the T-bill. In a taxable account, T-bill interest is taxed as ordinary income in the year you collect it, though not by states or localities; Nvidia’s growth is taxed only when you sell, at long-term rates if you hold over a year. At the top 37% federal rate, a 4.3% T-bill keeps about 2.7%, less if the 3.8% investment income tax applies.

And there is a middle way. Between a T-bill’s fixed 4.3% and Nvidia’s growing 3.3%, dividend payers hand you cash every quarter, and qualified dividends are taxed at the lower long-term rates.

So Which Is The Better Deal?

Both, in the right size. Here is $1 million a year from now, with the rest in T-bills at 4.3%, in three outcomes for Nvidia.

In Nvidia Nvidia −50% Flat Nvidia +50%
0% $1.04M $1.04M $1.04M
10% $0.99M $1.04M $1.09M
25% $0.91M $1.03M $1.16M
50% $0.77M $1.02M $1.27M

Nvidia’s dividend ignored; T-bill rate 4.3% before tax (3-month yield, Nov 16).

At 10%, the worst case leaves you about 1% below where you started and the best case about 9% above: you sleep either way. At 50%, one company decides whether you lose almost a quarter or gain more than a quarter. Same stock, same news; the size is the decision.

And the choice doesn’t have to be the T-bill or Nvidia: money that grows and money that pays you can sit in the same plan.

Growth Or Income? You Can Have Both.

Most portfolios settle for one. The Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio for growth: more than 105% since September 2020. The Trefis Income Solution for a dividend yield about 3x the S&P 500’s. What’s better? We’d be glad to show you both.

See The HQ Portfolio or See The Income Solution

For education, not a recommendation to buy or sell.

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.