Nvidia’s Cash Fell Far Short Of Its Profit 11 Times Before. What Did The Stock Do?

NVDAYTD-16.1%SPYYTD+9.4%QQQYTD+8.1%
Analyze NVDA →

Today’s big story: Could Nvidia Stock Fall 50%? Follow The Cash

More on the AI trade: our AI storyline page collects our pieces on AI stocks.

A smoke alarm that goes off is not a fire. But you don’t ignore it either. For Nvidia investors the alarm is cash: in the quarter to July, its operations brought in $24.1 billion against $59.7 billion of profit, 40%. Here is every time since 2006 that a quarter’s operating cash came in under 65% of a positive profit, and what the stock did from that report.

Report Cash ÷ profit Lowest, next 12 mo 12 mo, Nvidia / S&P
May 2006 56% −23% +52% / +23%
Nov 2006 20% −22% +30% / +8%
Mar 2010 53% −49% +2% / +11%
May 2010 negative −30% +42% / +25%
Aug 2011 54% −6% +17% / +24%
May 2012 negative −9% +19% / +29%
May 2017 56% 0% +81% / +16%
Nov 2018 40% −37% +5% / +17%
Nov 2021 62% −65% −50% / −13%
Nov 2022 58% −9% +224% / +16%
Aug 2025 58% −9% +20% / +20%
Aug 2026 40% −26% so far open

Cash ÷ profit is for that quarter alone (three months). Close on the day the quarter’s 10-Q or 10-K was filed to the lowest close and to the close 12 months (252 trading days) later, with dividends; S&P 500 is SPY. “Negative”: operating cash below zero with a profit.

Image from Pixabay

What Does The Record Say?

The alarm meant a drop, not a collapse, most of the time. In the year after each of the 11 completed cases, Nvidia fell a median 22% from the report-day close at some point, and by 20% or more in 6 of 11.

The stock usually rose anyway. Twelve months later Nvidia was higher 10 times out of 11. But it beat the S&P 500 only 5 times: the gap cost it relative to the market more often than not.

The two closest matches both fell 20% or more. Today’s gap, 40% of profit with customers owing about 60 days of sales, has two twins in the record. November 2006 (20%, 61 days): down 22% before ending the year up 30%. November 2018 (40%, 63 days): down 37%, and a year later up 5% while the S&P gained 17%.

Both twins fell hard before they recovered, by 22% and 37%. Waiting out a drop like that is easier when the rest of your money falls less. In backtests, the Trefis Income Solution, 50 dividend stocks, lost less than the S&P 500 in all 9 big selloffs since 2018. See how it held up.

The worst case came at the top. In November 2021 the gap was milder, 62%, but the stock sat 3% below its high at 99 times profit. It fell 65%. In November 2022 the gap was wider, but the stock was already 54% off its high; a year later it was up 224%. The alarm matters most when the price assumes nothing will go wrong.

Where Is Nvidia On That Map Now?

Since its Aug 26 report-day close of $209.66, Nvidia is down 26%, to $156.14 at Monday’s close, after a 4.1% drop on the day: the median drop has already happened. The 2018 path from the same starting point bottoms near $132; the 2021 path near $74. The difference this time: in 2018 sales were about to shrink, while in July they grew 18% in a quarter. The full downside math is in Could Nvidia Stock Fall 50%? Follow The Cash.

What Is The Alarm Saying Now?

The same thing it said in November 2018, at the same reading, 40%. That time Nvidia fell another 37%, then regained its old high 14 months after the low. The longer record is in Nvidia’s 20 Years: 3 Lessons For Today.

A smoke alarm is not a fire. Nvidia’s record says this one usually means a drop and, a year later, a higher price. The drop is already here.

Whether the rest of that pattern holds this time is anyone’s guess, and your portfolio shouldn’t have to depend on the guess.

Stop Guessing. Start Positioning.

No one can predict surprises like this one. The Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio doesn’t try: it holds 30 quality stocks in equal weight, so no single surprise decides your result. Come see how it works.

See How HQ Works

For education, not a recommendation to buy or sell.

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.