Should You Buy Nutrien Stock For Its Cash?

NTRYTD+14.9%SPYYTD+8.2%XLBYTD+13.5%
Analyze NTR →

Today’s big story: Anthropic IPO: Priced For 2031, Or 2036?

Over the twelve months to September 30, 2026, Nutrien (NTR) generated free cash flow equal to 6.3% of its market value. That compares with 4.3% for the median S&P 500 company. A cash yield this high usually means one of two things. Either the business is on sale, or the market expects it to shrink. So what is that cash actually worth to you as an owner?

Image from Pixabay

What Nutrien’s Cash Yield Gives You As An Owner

Shareholders essentially own a slice of the free cash a business produces. This is the money left after a company pays to run and maintain its operations. It counts whether or not the company pays it out. Cash retained by the company still belongs to its owners. When the market recognizes that cash, the share price tends to follow. This is most true when the cash grows.

Nutrien owes a lot, though, and its debt affects what that cash is worth to you. Its net debt is its borrowings minus its cash. That net debt equals 40% of its market value. Measured against market value plus net debt, Nutrien’s free cash flow equals 4.5%.

How Nutrien Makes Its Cash, And What It Owes

Nutrien mines potash and manufactures nitrogen and phosphate fertilizer. The company also operates a Retail business that sells products and agronomic advice to growers. Retail is the largest segment. It brought in $17.6 billion of the company’s $26.9 billion revenue in fiscal 2025.

Revenue grew 6.2% over the latest twelve months compared with a year earlier. Profit on those sales improved too. The operating margin reached 14.2%, up from 11.1% two years before. Capital spending consumed half of the $4.18 billion that Nutrien generated from operations.

That left Nutrien with $2.09 billion of free cash flow. That was close to the $2.13 billion of a year earlier. It was below the $2.75 billion for the twelve months to September 2023. Operating income covered interest expense 5.3 times. So Nutrien pays its interest with room to spare. Rising sales and margins with steady cash look more like a business on sale than a shrinking one. But the cash has not grown.

Why Investors Doubt Nutrien’s Cash

Investors’ doubts center on two parts of Nutrien: its largest business and its weakest segment. Retail revenue slipped 1.2% in fiscal 2025. On its November 5, 2026 earnings call, management lowered its full-year 2026 guidance for Retail adjusted EBITDA. That is the company’s own profit measure. The new range is $1.72 billion to $1.85 billion. Management attributed the cut to a deliberate pullback from sales in Brazil and a shorter plant health season in North America.

Phosphate is weaker still. It earned $8 million of adjusted EBITDA in the third quarter of 2026. Management blamed elevated sulfur costs. Nutrien will shut its White Springs facility in the second quarter of 2027 as the mine nears the end of its economic reserves. Separately, management expects to reduce net debt by the end of 2026. Nutrien trades at 15 times earnings, against 22 for the S&P 500. That price appears to assume these weak spots will hold back the cash for some time.

What To Watch In Nutrien’s Cash And Debt

Two questions remain open. Can free cash flow, flat over the past year, start to grow again? And can Nutrien bring down its net debt? Management said it will lay out its next phase of growth at an Investor Day later in November 2026. Twelve-month free cash flow and net debt in Nutrien’s fourth-quarter report are the figures to watch.

One weak season in Brazil or one aging mine can dent a single company’s cash. That holds even for a company that produces as much cash as Nutrien. Spreading your income across many sources can bring in more of it with smaller drops.

More Income. Smaller Drops.

Is your portfolio paying you enough? The Trefis Income Solution holds 50 dividend stocks yielding about 3x the S&P 500, each with at least 10 straight years of dividends. In backtests, it lost less than the S&P 500 in all 9 big selloffs since 2018. Why not choose a better approach?

See The Income Solution

Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.