ServiceNow’s Cash Yield Trails The 10-Year Treasury
Today’s big story: Could Nvidia Stock Fall 50%? Follow The Cash
After a rough autumn, several large software stocks look cheap on a popular measure: free-cash-flow yield, the cash a business produced over the past year divided by its stock market value. ServiceNow, trading 42.7% under its peak of the past year, shows a yield of 4.6% at Monday’s close. Salesforce shows 8.6%.
Mostly, they are not as cheap as that number says. The yield counts the cash, but not the shares these companies hand employees as pay, and that pay is a real cost to owners: every new share takes a slice of future cash. Subtract stock-based pay and ServiceNow’s yield falls to 2.4%. Atlassian’s drops from 4.4% to 0.15%, because its stock pay equalled 96.7% of its free cash flow over the past four quarters. Cloudflare and Snowflake turn negative, at -0.23% and -0.45%.
Of the seven names we checked, only Salesforce still yields more than the 10-year Treasury after the adjustment: 6.5% against the 5.1% the Treasury paid on Monday. ServiceNow’s headline yield was already below that Treasury rate before stock pay was counted.
The Cost The Headline Yield Leaves Out
Our free cash flow here is operating cash flow minus capital spending, as reported by Morningstar, summed over the last four quarters. For Salesforce, CrowdStrike and Snowflake those four quarters end July 31, 2026; for the others they end Sept 30, 2026. Stock pay is the figure each company adds back in its cash flow statement.
That add-back is the whole issue. Operating cash flow adds stock pay back because no cash leaves the company when it issues shares to staff. But owners still pay, in one of two ways: their stake gets diluted, or the company spends cash buying shares back to stop that from happening. Either way, the headline yield overstates the cash left for people who own the stock.
| Stock | FCF yield | After stock pay | Stock pay as % of FCF | Share count, 1 year |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Salesforce | 8.6% | 6.5% | 24.2% | -13.8% |
| ServiceNow | 4.6% | 2.4% | 48.9% | -0.3% |
| Atlassian | 4.4% | 0.15% | 96.7% | -4.2% |
| Datadog | 1.8% | 0.40% | 77.5% | +3% |
| Snowflake | 1.2% | -0.45% | 137.6% | +4% |
| CrowdStrike | 0.67% | 0.13% | 80.8% | +2% |
| Cloudflare | 0.31% | -0.23% | 175.6% | +2.3% |
ServiceNow Spends Cash Just To Stand Still
ServiceNow is where the gap matters most, because of the seven it has fallen furthest this year: down 35.1%. Over the four quarters to Sept 30, it spent $2.8 billion buying back stock, more than the $2.3 billion it paid in stock. Yet its share count fell only 0.3%. In plain terms, the buyback cash mostly kept the share count where it was rather than shrinking it. Its debt also exceeded its cash and short-term investments by $3.8 billion at the end of September.
Our Nov 3 piece, Is ServiceNow Stock Really Expensive?, looked at how stock pay changes ServiceNow’s earnings multiple. The cash view points the same way: once stock pay is counted, the price looks less like a bargain than the drop suggests.
The label “sold off” also needs care for the faster growers. CrowdStrike is up 90.5% this year and Cloudflare 48.9%; they are down from October highs, with CrowdStrike 20.0% below its best close of the past year. Their headline yields were thin before any adjustment, and their share counts rose over the year.
The Best Case For Buying Anyway
The strongest counter-argument deserves a fair hearing. Stock pay uses no cash, and buybacks can offset it. Salesforce shows this at scale: it spent $35.1 billion on buybacks over four quarters and cut its share count by 13.8%. Its debt exceeded its cash and short-term investments by $30.3 billion at July 31, so that shrinking share count came alongside a sizable debt load.
Growth is the other half of the case. In the latest quarter, revenue rose 39.2% at Cloudflare, 35.2% at Datadog, 35.1% at Snowflake, 23.7% at Atlassian and 20.5% at ServiceNow, each against the same quarter a year earlier. These yields use past cash flow. If cash flow keeps growing faster than stock pay, the owner yield rises over time, and a buyer who trusts that growth may accept a thin yield today. We think that is a fair bet for some investors, but it is a bet on growth, not a purchase of cash at a discount.
The Test To Watch
The number to track is stock pay as a share of free cash flow. If it falls in the coming quarters, from 96.7% at Atlassian or 48.9% at ServiceNow, the adjusted yields rise and the cheap label starts to earn itself. If it stays put, the headline yield keeps overstating what owners get.
What a reader can do this week: before trusting any software stock’s cash yield, subtract stock pay from free cash flow and divide by market value, then set the result next to the 10-year Treasury rate. We ran the same cash test on HubSpot. For Salesforce, the one name that passes, the next question is what could go wrong after its latest quarter.
The idea underneath is simple: a yield is only as good as the costs it counts. On a day like Monday, when the S&P 500 fell 1.9%, a yield that still holds up after every cost is the kind that lets you stay put without watching every tick, and that calm is what growing wealth steadily is built on.
What If You Could Grow Wealth And Still Sleep At Night?
ServiceNow is 43% below its highest close of the past year. How has that felt? The Trefis Income Solution pays a dividend yield about 3x the S&P 500’s, and in backtests it lost less than the S&P 500 in all 9 big selloffs since 2018.
For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.