Why Netflix’s Fall Could Pay Off At Tax Time
Today’s big story: Could Anthropic Stock Fall 25%?
Netflix closed at $59.82 on Wednesday, Nov 18. That is 55.3% below its record close of June 30, 2025. Over the past year the stock fell 47.6%. In the same year SPY, a fund that tracks the S&P 500, rose 10.6% in price.
Most talk about Netflix asks whether it is cheap enough to buy. This article is for people who already own it in a taxable account. Should you sell before the year ends to book the loss for tax, or hold?
Our read: if you have gains this year to offset, booking the loss looks like the better choice on Netflix’s own record. The tax saving is known once you sell, though part of it may come back as tax later if you buy back at a lower price. The cost is about a month out of the stock, and in past falls that month went either way. Owners who paid a low price have less to gain from selling.
This article does not cover why the stock fell. For that question, see Why Netflix Stock Is At A One-Year Low.

How Did Netflix’s Past Big Falls End?
Netflix has had 6 completed falls of 40% or more since it listed in 2002. The current fall is the 7th, and it has not recovered. All 6 past falls got back to the old high. The wait from the low back to the high ran from 141 to 1,119 days. The median wait was 414 days.
Past Netflix falls took a median 414 days to get back to the high. Money that waits out a stretch like that can still earn an income. The Trefis Income Solution pays a dividend yield about 3x the S&P 500’s, and it lost less than the S&P 500 in all 9 big selloffs since 2018. See the metrics.
The table shows each past fall, its depth, its recovery time and the P/E at the low. The P/E, or price-to-earnings ratio, is the share price divided by the last twelve months of earnings per share.
| Fall | High to low | Date of the low | Days from low back to high | P/E at the low |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2002 | -70.8% | Oct 9, 2002 | 159 | Not meaningful (losses) |
| 2004-05 | -76.7% | Mar 24, 2005 | 1,119 | 30.1x |
| 2008 | -55.9% | Oct 27, 2008 | 141 | 16.5x |
| 2011-12 | -82% | Sep 25, 2012 | 350 | 28.0x |
| 2018 | -44.2% | Dec 24, 2018 | 478 | 83.8x |
| 2021-22 | -75.9% | May 11, 2022 | 832 | 15.1x |
| Current fall | -55.3% at the Nov 18 close | Not known yet | Not recovered | 17.3x at the Nov 18 close |
Source: Trefis analysis of Intrinio daily closes and Morningstar quarterly earnings. Prices are adjusted for stock splits. A fall runs from a record close to the first close back at that level. Days are calendar days. The P/E uses the four quarters of diluted earnings reported by the date of the low.
The most recent case went deep. Netflix fell 75.9% from its 2021 high to its 2022 low. It still closed back at the old high on Aug 20, 2024.
Today’s P/E of 17.3 is close to the 15.1 at the 2022 low and the 16.5 at the 2008 low. It is far below the 63.3 at the June 2025 record. But other lows came at 28.0, 30.1 and 83.8. So the stock looks cheap against some of its own history, not all of it.
How Much Further Did Netflix Fall After Halving?
In past falls, the first close at half the high was not the bottom. 5 of the 6 past falls went 50% or more below the high. From that first close, the stock fell a further 5.3% to 62.6% before the low. The median further fall was 51.3%.
A market-wide crash is a separate risk on top of this. For that case, see What Would A Real Market Crash Do To Netflix Stock After This Fall?
What Has The Wash-Sale Wait Cost In Past Falls?
The IRS defines a wash sale as selling stock at a loss and buying substantially identical stock within 30 days before or after the sale. So an owner who sells and wants Netflix back usually waits 31 days.
History gives no clear answer on that wait. In the 31 days after Netflix first closed 50% below a high, it rose in 3 of 5 past falls and fell in 2. The moves ran from a 22.4% fall in 2011 to a 17.2% gain in 2008.
A wider test uses every day the stock sat 50% or more below its record. There were 925 such days from 2002 to 2023. The price 31 days later was higher on 63.5% of them. The median change was a gain of 6.1%.
So the wait has leaned up, but only modestly. Measured from each past low, Netflix was higher 31 days later in all 6 falls, by 2.0% to 61.1%. Nobody knows the low until later.
What Is The Loss Worth In Tax?
This applies to a taxable account only. Check your own case with a tax adviser.
Take an owner who bought at the June 2025 record close. Selling at $59.82 books a loss of $74.09 a share. For tax year 2026, most net long-term capital gains are taxed at a maximum rate of 15% for most individual taxpayers. We use that rate here. At that rate, the loss offsets $11.11 of tax a share. That is 18.6% of today’s price.
An owner who paid $100 a share books a smaller loss of $40.18 a share. At 15%, it is worth $6.03 a share, or 10.1% of the price.
Some limits apply. Losses beyond your gains can cut other income by at most $3,000 a year ($1,500 if married filing separately). The rest carries forward to later years.
Selling also leaves you a lower cost if you buy back later. In our view, that often delays tax rather than removes it. The saving is clearest when the gains you offset would otherwise be taxed now.
Note: Wash-sale rules also apply across spouses and IRA accounts, and actual tax savings depend on your holding period, filing status, state taxes, and whether the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax applies.
How the Tax-Loss Math Varies by Cost Basis and Gain Profile
- A peak buyer with gains to offset gets tax value of 18.6% of the price. That is about three times the median 6.1% move in past 31-day windows.
- An owner who paid $100 gets tax value of 10.1% of the price. A rebound like the 17.2% of 2008 would have cost more than that.
- An owner with no gains to offset can use at most $3,000 a year against other income. For that owner, staying in the stock may matter more.
What would change this view? A clear sign the low is in would raise the cost of being out for a month. A smaller loss, or no taxable gains, would shrink the benefit.
Our read: historically, the immediate tax offset has often outweighed the median 31-day price move, though individual outcomes depend on market timing and personal tax circumstances. Either way, the wait may be long. Past falls took a median 414 days from the low to regain the high.
A wait that long is hard when one stock carries much of your money. It is easier when your whole portfolio falls less than the market does.
Could You Hold On Through The Next Fall?
Holding on is easier when your portfolio falls less than the market. For every dollar its benchmark lost, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio lost about 81 cents on average, holding 30 quality stocks in equal weight.
For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.