Why Micron’s Cheap P/E Has Often Meant A Peak

MUYTD+149.8%SPYYTD+8.2%QQQYTD+7.3%
Analyze MU →

Today’s big story: Anthropic IPO: Priced For 2031, Or 2036?

Micron Technology (MU) closed at $712.42 on Tuesday, Nov 17. That is 9.6 times its fiscal 2026 earnings per share. The common view is that a memory chip maker at a single-digit price-to-earnings ratio, or P/E, looks cheap. This article asks a different question. What has a P/E under 10 meant for Micron in the past?

The short answer is that it has more often marked an earnings peak than a bargain. We checked every month-end since January 1999. Some months had a P/E under 10 while earnings per share for the last four quarters were higher than a year earlier, as they are now. The median price return over the next year from those months was a loss of 13.2%. The stock was higher a year later in only 17 of 48 such months. Other low-P/E months came after earnings had already fallen. From those, the median return was a gain of 18.7%. The stock rose in 15 of those 16 months.

Our Nov 17 piece, Should You Buy Micron Stock At Under Ten Times Earnings?, found Micron at 9.6 times earnings, against 22.0 times for the median S&P 500 company. The next question is whether that low P/E has been a good signal before. On Micron’s own record, a low P/E on fast-rising earnings has usually been the market pricing a peak. Nothing in the price has changed that picture since. Micron slipped 0.9% on Tuesday, and its P/E is still under 10.

memory chip
Image from Pixabay

Why A Low P/E Can Be A Warning

A P/E divides the share price by the last year’s earnings per share. For most companies a low number means the stock is cheap. Memory chips are different. Micron’s profit swings with chip prices. It ran an operating loss in fiscal 2023. In fiscal 2026 its operating margin was 74.6%.

When profit is near a high, the price can look cheap against it. Investors may be pricing the lower earnings they expect once the cycle turns. Micron’s fiscal 2026 earnings per share were $74.33. That is 9.8 times the $7.59 of fiscal 2025. That jump puts Micron firmly in the rising-earnings group.

Six Episodes, Four Losses

Back-to-back months share most of their one-year windows, so counting by episode is fairer. We treat each run of back-to-back month-ends under 10 times earnings as one episode. Micron has had six before now. Its P/E did not fall under 10 at any month-end until July 2010.

Five of the six episodes began while earnings were higher than a year earlier. In five of the six, earnings a year later were lower than at the start. The stock was lower a year after the first month in four of the six.

Episode start Months in episode Return a year later EPS at start, then a year later
Jul 2010 12 +1.2% $1.47, then $0.59
Sep 2011 1 +18.7% $0.59, then -$0.94
Jul 2014 1 -39.4% $3.10, then $3.00
Jan 2015 15 -62.3% $3.09, then $1.81
Nov 2017 26 -9.0% $4.32, then $11.52
Apr 2022 9 -5.6% $7.95, then $1.39

The worst case came in 2015. The stock fell 62.3% in the year after January 2015. Earnings per share dropped from $3.09 to $1.81 over that year.

The Year Rising Profit Did Not Help

The 2017 episode is the one bulls should study. From the end of November 2017, earnings per share rose from $4.32 to $11.52 over the next year. The stock still fell 9.0% over that year. All eight under-10 month-ends from November 2017 to June 2018 were lower a year later. In that episode the P/E fell as low as 2.8 times.

So rising earnings did not save the stock. Investors priced the next downturn before it showed up in reported profit. One caution applies. Sorting months by the next year’s earnings uses figures nobody knew at the time. Sorting by earnings known at the time, as in our opening figures, is the fairer test for today.

The Strongest Case For Buying

Nothing in the reported numbers yet shows a turn. Micron guided first-quarter fiscal 2027 earnings per share to $37.84. That is 15.1% above the fourth quarter of fiscal 2026. It guided revenue for the quarter to $61.5 billion. Analysts’ average estimate for fiscal 2027 earnings per share is $175.61. That is 136.3% above fiscal 2026. On that estimate the stock trades at 4.1 times earnings.

If those estimates hold, today’s price could look low in hindsight. The record also has limits. Six episodes is a small sample. Most of the 64 low-P/E months come from two long runs, starting in January 2015 and November 2017. So the record is a base rate, not a forecast. Still, in the year after November 2017, the stock fell while earnings more than doubled.

What This Means For Holders

The stock has already moved a long way. Even after its recent drop, it is up 194.4% from a year earlier. It now sits 41.3% below its June 25 closing high. It lost 18.9% in the month to Nov 17. A gain that large can leave Micron as a big share of a portfolio.

We think the history argues for caution, not panic. A new buyer at under 10 times earnings is betting that this cycle is different. In four of the six past episodes, the stock was lower a year later. An owner with a large gain can decide now what would make them sell. One test is the company’s next guidance. If Micron guides earnings lower, the pattern from past peaks would be in play. If guidance keeps rising, the bull case stays alive. This is education, not personal advice.

What to ask next:

Micron’s gain was large and fast. Its own history says a low P/E is not an all-clear. When one stock carries that much of a portfolio, it pays to plan the exit before the market forces the choice.

Too Much Riding On One Stock?

If Micron Technology is a big part of your wealth, so are its risk and its tax bill. What’s your exit plan? Our partner advisory firm offers a free 30-minute strategy review covering a floor under losses and a lower-tax way out.

Map My Exit Options

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.