Ford Or GM Stock? The S&P 500 Beat Both

FYTD-9.5%SPYYTD+8.2%XLYYTD-1.3%
Analyze F →

Today’s big story: Anthropic IPO: Priced For 2031, Or 2036?

Our Nov 17 piece, Ford Stock’s $4 Billion EV Problem, found that Ford expects its electric vehicle unit to lose about $4 billion in 2026. The next question is the one a car-stock buyer asks. Should you own Ford or General Motors?

The short answer is GM. Since the Jan 14, 2014 close, GM returned 183.5% with dividends reinvested. Ford returned 34.4%. So $1,000 in GM grew to $2,835, while $1,000 in Ford grew to $1,344. Over 2014 to 2025, GM also returned $58.4 billion to its owners through buybacks and dividends. Ford returned $33.7 billion. But neither stock beat the S&P 500. The index fund SPY returned 393.4% over the same stretch.

GM is in the news this week for another reason. On Tuesday, the Wall Street Journal reported that GM is weighing outside candidates to succeed CEO Mary Barra. Reuters reported that GM hired an executive search firm to find a possible successor. A Journal piece the same day said GM has become leaner and more profitable under Barra. Most coverage focuses on that story. This article asks whether that leaner GM actually paid its owners more, and what it means for a buyer now.

stock market
Image from Pixabay

GM Shrank Its Share Count. Ford Paid Dividends.

The two companies sent cash back in different ways. GM spent $40.7 billion buying back its own stock over 2014 to 2025. It paid $17.8 billion in dividends. Ford spent only $4.0 billion on buybacks. Most of its cash, $29.7 billion, went out as dividends.

The buybacks show up in the share count. GM’s average diluted share count fell 42.3% from 2014 to 2025. Ford’s fell 1.6%. Fewer shares mean each remaining share owns a bigger slice of the profit. That helps explain why GM’s stock rose 110.0% on price alone, while Ford’s fell 30.9%.

One measure does not work here. Long-run free cash flow, the cash left after spending on plants and equipment, is reported on a basis that mixes in each company’s lending arm. The totals for GM and Ford are not comparable, so we leave them out. For cash, we use each company’s own 2026 guidance below.

The Gap Is Still There Today

The pattern did not stop in 2025. Over the last four reported quarters, GM returned cash equal to 12.6% of its market value. Ford returned 6.0%. GM also announced a new $20 billion buyback plan on Oct 20. It said that was more than 25% of its market value at the time.

GM appears to have the cash to fund that plan. GM raised its 2026 outlook for adjusted automotive free cash flow to $11.5 billion to $12.5 billion. The midpoint equals 16.8% of its market value at Tuesday’s close. Ford kept its own 2026 adjusted free cash flow outlook at $6 billion to $7 billion. That midpoint equals 14.3% of Ford’s market value. The two companies define this figure differently, so the gap is a guide, not an exact match.

Measure GM Ford
Total return since Jan 14, 2014 183.5% 34.4%
Cash returned, 2014-2025 $58.4 billion $33.7 billion
Change in diluted shares, 2014-2025 -42.3% -1.6%
Price to 2026 earnings estimate 6.2 times 6.0 times
Price to 2027 earnings estimate 5.6 times 6.1 times

The price tags are close. GM trades at 6.2 times analysts’ average 2026 earnings estimate. Ford trades at 6.0 times. The difference shows up in 2027. On 2027 estimates, GM’s multiple falls to 5.6 times, because analysts expect its earnings to rise. Ford’s rises to 6.1 times, because its 2027 estimate is a little lower.

The Case For Ford

Ford still has real points in its favor. Its dividends over the last four quarters equal 5.3% of its market value. GM’s equal 1.7%. An owner who wants income gets more of it from Ford. Our look at whether to buy Ford for its cash makes that case in full.

Ford’s stock is also further below its peak. It closed 34.8% below its 52-week high on Tuesday. GM closed 10.3% below its own. Ford lost 7.8% over the past year with dividends reinvested. GM gained 24.8%. If Ford’s electric vehicle losses shrink, we think the stock has more room to recover than GM. Ford posted a 2025 net loss of $8.2 billion, so the bar for improvement is low.

GM carries its own risk. The current leadership set GM’s buyback pace. The board is now weighing who should replace the CEO. The Journal said the next CEO faces technology challenges in China and beyond. A new chief could choose to spend cash differently. Our piece on the one number GM holders should watch covers the cost pressure on its 2026 and 2027 profit.

What A Buyer Can Do This Week

For a buyer choosing one of the two, the facts point to GM. It paid owners more, it is buying back more stock now, and its earnings estimate rises into 2027. The risk is the CEO change. Watch whether a new leader keeps the $20 billion buyback plan on pace.

An income buyer may still prefer Ford for its higher dividend. That owner should accept that Ford’s electric vehicle losses could keep weighing on the stock.

The bigger lesson is in the comparison with the index. GM beat Ford by 149.1 percentage points since 2014. Yet it trailed the S&P 500 fund by 209.9 percentage points. Picking the better of two carmakers still left an owner far behind the broad market. That is a good reason to hold a group of strong companies rather than bet everything on one.

Why Own One Leader When You Can Own 30?

If you like finding quality companies like Ford Motor, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio holds 30 of them in equal weight, and has returned more than 105% since its September 2020 launch. You’re welcome to look inside.

See The HQ Portfolio

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.