Why You Should Think About Carvana Differently Now
For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.
Carvana (CVNA) stock trades at 27.6 times earnings, compared with 23.0 for the S&P 500. Shareholders paying that premium need to understand what they are buying, and management has shifted its emphasis. From the fiscal Q3 2024 call through the fiscal Q4 2025 call in February 2026, the company gave a running count of how many of its 56 ADESA sites it had integrated. On the two calls since, executives have not given that tally. Management chose instead to stress a goal first announced alongside the Q1 2025 results.
Carvana Now Emphasizes A 3 Million Car Goal
During the fiscal Q2 2026 call on July 29, 2026, management laid out the case for a midterm goal: building what it calls a machine to sell 3 million cars a year by 2030 to 2035. Before setting that target, management pointed to the ADESA sites to demonstrate how Carvana could reach such a scale. During the fiscal Q4 2024 call on February 19, 2025, management said the company had integrated six of the 56 sites. It added that fully integrating all of them would give Carvana capacity for about 3 million retail units.
The sites remain a part of the plan. Management said on the latest call that Carvana has spent the last couple of years rapidly adding retail production capacity to ADESA locations and existing inspection centers, while just beginning work on a fresh build site. But the integrated site count is no longer what management emphasizes; the 3 million goal is.
When Carvana is a large share of what you own, what its management stops saying matters more. See how to protect a concentrated position.
How Far Has Carvana Come Toward 3 Million Cars?
Carvana sold 197,325 retail units in fiscal Q2 2026, up 38% from a year earlier. That represents about an 82% increase over the 108,651 vehicles it sold in fiscal Q3 2024, when management said it had integrated five of the 56 sites. Revenue over the last twelve months reached $25.1 billion, up 54% from the prior twelve months. In the latest quarter alone, revenue rose 52% to $7.38 billion, and management said revenue outpaced unit growth. It cited three main reasons: how the company books some cars bought from a large retail marketplace partner, higher industry-wide prices, and a shift toward newer, more expensive cars.
Management now measures progress by how far Carvana still has to grow. When the company announced the goal alongside its Q1 2025 results, Carvana needed to reach about six times its scale. Five quarters later, management said the business needs to grow to under four times. For a shareholder, the question is how fast Carvana closes that gap.
Is Carvana’s Shift Reassuring For Shareholders?
The results look reassuring in the two regions where Carvana added the most capacity. Management said inventory in those regions grew 57% and sales grew 54% in fiscal Q2 2026.
The concern centers on inventory for the company as a whole. Management said on the same call that inventory has undergrown sales over the last several months, a headwind for the overall business. When inventory falls short, management added, that shows up as lower sales or lower economics.
Management expects retail units sold to rise in fiscal Q3 2026 from fiscal Q2. That count is the number to watch when Carvana reports, an event expected on or around October 28, 2026.
Is Too Much Of Your Wealth Riding On One Stock?
What Carvana’s management talks about has changed, and holders are left to work out why. When one position grows into a large part of your wealth, a sharp fall can hurt your whole plan, and selling to spread the money out can bring a large tax bill. Our partner advisory firm offers a free strategy review of ways to protect a concentrated position and unwind it with less tax.
Request A Free Strategy Review
Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.