Cisco Is Cheaper, Arista Is The Better Business

CSCOYTD+25.0%SPYYTD+9.4%QQQYTD+8.1%
Analyze CSCO →

Today’s big story: Could Nvidia Stock Fall 50%? Follow The Cash

Cisco reported a record quarter on Thursday, Nov 12: revenue of $18.5 billion, up 24%, and non-GAAP earnings of $1.40 a share, up 40%. The stock then fell 6.2% on Friday and closed Monday, Nov 16, at $94.52. Arista, which did not report, fell harder over the same two sessions: down 9.5% against Cisco’s 7.3%.

So which is the better AI networking buy now? Our answer: Cisco is the better buy on price, and Arista is the better business. Cisco trades at 17.2 times the midpoint of its own fiscal 2027 non-GAAP earnings guidance. Arista trades at 30.9 times analysts’ average 2027 earnings estimate, about 1.8 times Cisco’s multiple. For that premium you get faster guided growth and a wider margin.

The surprise from Cisco’s call is that its AI line is now the bigger one. Cisco raised its fiscal 2027 target for AI infrastructure revenue from hyperscalers to $9 billion, from $7.5 billion a quarter earlier, more than double fiscal 2026. Arista’s own 2027 target for AI fabrics is about $7 billion, also a doubling. Cisco’s target is about 1.3 times Arista’s, though the two define AI revenue differently and their fiscal years differ.

Why Cisco’s AI number does not make it the faster grower

That AI target makes the cheaper stock look like the faster grower too. That holds for the hyperscaler AI line only. Cisco expects AI hyperscale revenue to be 12% of its total in fiscal 2027. The rest of the business grows more slowly, so the whole company’s guidance midpoint of $75.3 billion implies 18.9% growth over fiscal 2026. Arista’s first 2027 outlook is 38% to 40% growth, to about $18.5 billion, or 39.1% above its $13.3 billion 2026 guidance.

Margins point the same way. Cisco’s non-GAAP operating margin was 37.8% last quarter, and it expects about 36% for fiscal 2027. Arista’s operating margin was 49.1% on the company’s non-GAAP basis, and it guides about 49% for 2027. On a GAAP basis Arista’s quarter was still 44.9%.

Cisco also pays for its hardware boom in gross margin. Its non-GAAP gross margin fell to 65.6%, as more hardware in the mix and higher memory costs weighed on product margins. Arista’s gross margin slipped too, to 64%, as product costs rose.

Cisco (CSCO) Arista (ANET)
Close, Nov 16 $94.52 $187.02
Price / 2027 EPS 17.2x guidance 30.9x estimate
Guided 2027 revenue growth 18.9% 39.1%
2027 AI revenue target $9 billion about $7 billion
Latest non-GAAP operating margin 37.8% 49.1%
Below one-year high close 27.3% 13.7%

What the valuation gap leaves out

The valuation gap is smaller than it looks. Cisco’s fiscal 2027 ends in July 2027 and Arista’s ends in December 2027, so the comparison gives Arista five more months of growth. Cisco’s figure is also company guidance, while Arista’s is analysts’ estimate. On this year’s estimate, Arista trades at 42.8 times earnings.

Each stock carries its own risk. For Cisco, it is the margin squeeze from hardware and memory, and a stock that sits 27.3% below its June 4 high close even after the company raised its full-year revenue and earnings guidance. Our look at what moved Cisco stock after its results covers the drop after the report. For Arista, it is the premium itself, plus purchase commitments that rose to $11.4 billion from $9.7 billion and inventory that rose to $3.2 billion from $2.5 billion in one quarter. The stock is 13.7% below its Oct 9 high close; we looked at why Arista stock has been falling since its report.

Neither stock moved alone on Monday. The S&P 500 fell 1.9% that day, while Arista dropped 5.2% and Cisco 1.2%.

Name your price, then get paid to wait

If you prefer one of these but not at Monday’s close, the plain move is a limit order at the price you would pay. A cash-secured put does the same job and pays you while you wait; the cost is that you must buy if the stock falls below your strike, even far below it.

  • Cisco: the $85 put that expires on Jan 15, 2027 had a midpoint of the bid and ask of $2.02 at Monday’s close. The strike is 10.1% below the close; after the premium, your effective entry would be $82.98, 12.2% below the close. That is $202 per contract of 100 shares, 60 days out.
  • Arista: the $165 put for the same date had a midpoint of the bid and ask of about $8.23 at Monday’s close. The strike is 11.8% below the close, the effective entry about $156.78, 16.2% below the close, and the premium $822.50 per contract.

Arista’s put pays about 5% of the strike against 2.4% for Cisco’s: the market charges more for Arista’s swings. For more ways to earn from Arista shares you own, see how to create income from Arista stock. This is education, not personal advice; options aren’t right for every account.

The idea underneath is simple: if you would buy at a lower price but not at today’s, say so with an order, and let the market pay you for the patience. Pick the stock whose risk you can live with if it keeps falling.

A record quarter followed by a two-day drop in both stocks is the kind of turn nobody times well. That is why a price you set in advance, sized to what you can hold through a surprise, does more work than any forecast.

Stop Guessing. Start Positioning.

No one can predict surprises like this one. The Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio doesn’t try: it holds 30 quality stocks in equal weight, so no single surprise decides your result. Come see how it works.

See How HQ Works

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.