Is Caterpillar Stock Priced Right Against Its Rivals?
Today’s big story: Could Anthropic Stock Fall 25%?
Caterpillar (CAT) earns the widest operating margin among six machinery makers, a group that also includes Deere, PACCAR, Cummins, Terex and Oshkosh. Caterpillar’s margin was 18.3% over its latest four fiscal quarters, putting it first in the group. Yet its stock returned less than four of its five rivals over the year to November 18, 2026. So what are investors paying for Caterpillar’s results, next to the rival they reward most?

Caterpillar Outgrows Deere At A Lower P/E
Caterpillar trades at 21.7 times earnings, against 35.7 times for Deere. Yet Caterpillar’s revenue grew 20.3% over its latest four fiscal quarters, while Deere’s grew 8.0% over its own four quarters ending August 2, 2026. Caterpillar’s operating margin is also higher than Deere’s 17.6%. Deere is mainly a farm machinery maker, though, so the two margins come from different kinds of business.
| CAT | DE | PCAR | CMI | TEX | OSK | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Four Fiscal Quarters | ended 2026-09-30 (Q4 FY2025 to Q3 FY2026) | ended 2026-08-02 (Q4 FY2025 to Q3 FY2026) | ended 2026-09-30 (Q4 FY2025 to Q3 FY2026) | ended 2026-09-30 (Q4 FY2025 to Q3 FY2026) | ended 2026-09-30 (Q4 FY2025 to Q3 FY2026) | ended 2026-09-30 (Q4 FY2025 to Q3 FY2026) |
| Market Value (USD billion) | 257 | 174 | 54.7 | 58.7 | 6.1 | 8.65 |
| P/E | 21.7 | 35.7 | 19.8 | 17.7 | 30.8 (not in the P/E rank) | 17.4 |
| Revenue Growth | 20.3% | 8% | -1.5% | 6.7% | 40.1% | 4.2% |
| Operating Margin | 18.3% | 17.6% | 10.8% | 12.4% | 5.7% | 6.8% |
| Total Return, Incl. Dividends, 2025-11-17 to 2026-11-18 | 2.1% | 37% | 13% | -5% | 23.7% | 16.9% |
Investors have still rewarded Deere more. Over that same year, Deere stock returned 37.0%, while Caterpillar returned 2.1%. Caterpillar’s stock also fell 22.8% in the month to November 18, 2026. It closed at $558.77 that day, almost half below its highest close of the past year, $1,060.41 on June 30, 2026.
Caterpillar stock has fallen by almost half since its June 30 high of $1,060.41. If it is a big part of your savings, that fall is hard to sit through, and selling can bring a tax bill. Our partner advisory firm offers a free 30-minute strategy review covering a floor under losses and a lower-tax way out. Map your exit options.
Against the rest of the group, Caterpillar’s P/E looks earned. PACCAR, Cummins and Oshkosh trade at lower P/Es, and each also grew revenue more slowly. Terex grew faster, at 40.1%, but the company lost money in one quarter, so its P/E is not comparable.
What Is Behind Caterpillar’s Faster Growth?
In fiscal 2025, Caterpillar’s growth came from Power and Energy, the segment that sells engines and turbines. Fiscal 2025 ended on December 31, 2025, so it covers only the first of the latest four quarters. That segment’s revenue rose 11.6% that year, to $32.2 billion. Revenue at Construction Industries, its second-largest segment, slipped 1.6%.
Demand for power has kept building. On its October 2026 call, management said power generation sales to end users grew 75% in the third quarter. It tied that growth to strong demand for turbines and large engines used in data centers. Growth also spread wider that quarter, with Construction Industries sales up 18%.
Caterpillar now has more orders than it can yet build. Its backlog of unfilled orders reached a record $78 billion, up 96% from a year earlier. Adding factory capacity is still the main limit on growth in Power and Energy, management said. Caterpillar plans to nearly triple its capacity for large reciprocating engines by 2030, against the 2024 level.
What Does Caterpillar Expect For Full-Year 2026?
Management expects full-year 2026 sales and revenues to grow in the mid- to high teens. For the fourth quarter alone, the company expects only moderate growth, because it is up against a strong quarter a year earlier.
The risk is in Caterpillar’s costs. On the call, management said its adjusted operating margin sits near the bottom of its own target range. The company also said it faces some inefficiencies as it adds capacity. It expects tariff costs of around $2.2 billion for 2026, excluding tariff refunds it has already booked.
Investors pay less for each dollar of Caterpillar’s earnings than for Deere’s, even though Caterpillar’s revenue has grown faster. So far, Caterpillar has a record backlog behind it, yet management itself expects a slower fourth quarter. Caterpillar’s next quarterly report will show how full-year 2026 sales growth compares with the mid- to high-teens forecast.
Caterpillar shows that the best results in a group do not guarantee the best stock in it over a year. Owning a spread of strong companies, rather than one leader, means one stock’s bad year matters less.
Why Own One Leader When You Can Own 30?
If you like finding quality companies like Caterpillar, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio holds 30 of them in equal weight, and has returned more than 105% since its September 2020 launch. You’re welcome to look inside.
Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.